Pipework firm wins £615k payout over £200m Hull job

Aaron Morby 1 month ago

A small specialist pipework firm has won a £615,000 payout after a legal battle with main contractor MW High Tech Projects UK on a £200m Hull waste to energy project.

240,000 tonne-capacity waste gasification plant in Hull
240,000 tonne-capacity waste gasification plant in Hull

The legal battle, which hit the high court, concerned payments for labour supply on the late-running Energy Works plant.

Premier Engineering Lincoln claimed that it has been under-paid by about £1.3m, while MW said that it had already substantially overpaid Premier and counter-claims substantial sums

The major dispute centred on the number of hours worked by operatives supplied by Premier and its worksheet claims against MW’s site turnstile data.

Premier was asked to step in when MW fell out with a steel fabricator Engie Fabricom on the job.

Construction of the plant began in January 2016 but the facility missed its initial 2018 deadline for completion.

This saw the small pipework contractor rapidly raise staffing from a dozen men in late February 2018 to about 140 at one point in May 2018.

Payment issues arose when turnstiles data did not tally with worksheets although Premier argued turnstiles did not always function and record workers’ movements properly.

It also argued that some part of their men’s working days were spent outside the turnstiles for a number of reasons including that the office and facilities for food and relaxation were outside the perimeter controlled by the turnstiles.

Justice Stuart-Smith said: “Given the need for MW to try to accelerate and the substantial sums that they were incurring to Premier for its supply of labour, supervision and materials and the level of supervision and control being exercised by MW, I am confident that MW would have known if Premier’s men were simply not working (or available to work) significant proportions of the times that they had been requisitioned by MW and should have been working and for which they were billing week by week.

“And, if they had known any such thing, MW would have been on Premier’s back in no uncertain terms because of their financial need to accelerate.

“Similarly, if Premier’s men had been unproductive because of incompetence or inadequate supervision by Premier, MW would have complained and there would be documentary references to such complaints: but there is not.”

The Hull plant is now operational although client Energy Works (Hull) terminated the engineering, procurement and construction contract with MW High Tech Projects UK in March 2019, and brought in Black & Veatch as principal contractor to oversee its final stages of commissioning.

Latest news

Green light for £1bn London hotel

Kensington Forum scheme is huge vote of confidence in capital's hospitality sector
20 hours ago

Pothole repair robot unveiled in Liverpool

University team hope AI technology will revolutionise road maintenance
16 hours ago

Lone Star offer to buy McCarthy & Stone for £630m

Private equity investor swoops with recommended cash offer to buy retirement homes specialist
23 hours ago

Legal & General signs construction deal with nine contractors

Southern construction partners chosen by Inspired Villages - more regions now up for grabs
23 hours ago

Priti Patel snubs plea to ease controls on foreign brickies

Some big brickwork contractors warn four in five workers are EU nationals
23 hours ago

Plans in for Poole quay housing and hotel scheme

Fisherman's Dock plan for 228 flats and boutique hotel
24 hours ago

McAleer & Rushe bounces back with £350m haul of orders

Spate of wins restores two-year order book to near pre-Covid levels
23 hours ago

Graham signs off £161m Aberdeen hospital deal

Work to start next month of Baird Family Hospital and ANCHOR cancer centre
23 hours ago

ISG starts new £50m Royal Marsden cancer centre

Oak Cancer Centre due for completion in Summer 2022
2 days ago

Vital Energi lands £6.58m energy centre deal

Specialist to build Combined Heat & Power centre on Galliford Try site
2 days ago
Vital Energi

Causeway Donseed offers non-contact site monitoring

Facial recognition makes access control Covid safe
2 days ago

Osborne wins prelims for £1.7bn Stonehenge route

Record £35m archaeological protection and excavation deal also signed
2 days ago

Industry door and window supplier collapses

North West's Total Glass falls into administration
2 days ago

Hill Group launches £300m London land grab

Land buying drive to boost housing pipeline in the capital
2 days ago

Mace £500m Stevenage town centre revamp approved

Mace says town centre plan is a blueprint for Government build back better ambitions
3 days ago

McAleer & Rushe wins Brixton archive and homes job

Final phase of Muse's Lambeth Town Hall scheme gets underway
2 days ago

Alumasc and Travis Perkins see sales continue to rise

Post lockdown demand continues but commercial construction lagging other sectors
2 days ago

Big name winners confirmed for CITB management training cash

Major contractors get £2.8m towards in-house training for senior staff
3 days ago

B&K starts £70m MediaCity resi scheme

14 and 17 storey blocks will contain 280 flats for sale
3 days ago

Civils outfit Bemus heads for liquidation owing £4.6m

Founder Sean Walsh applies for creditors voluntary liquidation
3 days ago

UWE Bristol to tender 900-bed student digs

Trio of six-storey blocks to be built at Frenchay Campus.
3 days ago

Amey trials pothole repair material made from old tyres

Unique rubber-modified material may be coming to Sheffield’s roads
3 days ago

HS2 reveals low-slung viaduct designs

Northamptonshire Edgcote and Lower Thorpe viaducts designed to be unobtrusive
4 days ago

Van Elle wins HS2 ground improvement deal

Firm will vibro pile 4,000 stone columns in north west London
4 days ago

Skanska wins Bristol Temple Street office job

Work to start next month on One Portwall Square project
4 days ago

Three sisters set-up plant hire business

Finnegan sisters buy first kit after securing funding deal
3 days ago

Network Rail SME spend tops £2.5bn for first time

Small and medium-sized firms account for 36% of total rail spend
4 days ago

Construction fears force immediate evacuation of London estate

Inspections raise serious concerns about Berkeley-built modular housing and student blocks
5 days ago

Bellway recladding costs overshadow hit from Covid

Pre-tax profit slumps 62% after £47m set aside for recladding and extra Covid costs
4 days ago

Workers stunned by construction pay freeze plan

Union slams "missed opportunity" to reward workers who have continued throughout pandemic
5 days ago

Contractor services