HS2 leg to Leeds downgraded to low priority project

Aaron Morby 12 months ago
Share

Plans to extend HS2 from Birmingham to Leeds have suffered a blow after the National Infrastructure Commission gave a verdict that there are many more high priority rail investment projects for the North and Midlands.

NIC concludes there are more deserving cases in the North and Midlands for rail investment
NIC concludes there are more deserving cases in the North and Midlands for rail investment

The National Infrastructure Commission has recommended that investment should be focused on boosting mainline services across the North and the Midlands rather than the full eastern leg of HS2.

The independent advisory body said that government should progress the western route into Manchester, but delay starting the eastern side to Leeds in favour of investment in upgrading existing city rail links.

Its controversial report now has been sent to Government to help inform investment priorities.

The Commission has outlined how different mixes of schemes could fit together, developed as five packages of rail investments within three different budgets – £86bn, £108bn and £129bn.

Barry White, chief executive at Transport for the North, said: “The National Infrastructure Commission’s report validates the vision of Northern leaders – recognising the desperate need to better connect the North’s towns and cities through new lines and significant upgrades as part of Northern Powerhouse Rail.

“But in all the NIC scenarios this would fall short of the full stated ambition of Northern leaders.

“That such investment in our rail network would also come at the expense of HS2’s long-awaited arrival to Yorkshire is a bitter blow and one we oppose. The NIC was tasked with integrating these projects – not pitching them against each other.

Five NIC options – based on changing priority between local and long distance links


 

Sir John Armitt, Chair of the National Infrastructure Commission, said: “Major rail schemes will be an important component in levelling up the country’s economic geography, but we should ensure public money is carefully spent where it can make the most difference.

“The number and scale of rail schemes currently being proposed for the North and Midlands mean that some form of prioritisation will be necessary, and we think there are ways of bringing forward benefits for communities and businesses while keeping options open for additional investments if the circumstances are right.

“Our independent analysis offers government various ways of targeting spending depending on the precise economic and social outcomes it wants to achieve.”

White added: “The Government now has a bold choice to make on how much it truly wants to level-up through transport investment.

“As the report shows, increasing rail spend could transform the North’s fortunes.

“But constraining spending and ambition will lead to cut-price versions of the current plans and promised projects simply not being delivered – that will curtail investment in the North and cost many jobs.

He said: “We now strongly urge the Government to be ambitious in its decision-making. If the mission is to ‘build back better’, then the message is simple: commit to the options that deliver true transformation for the North.

“That includes better connections for communities such as those in Liverpool, Bradford, Sheffield, Hull and the North East; proper and reliable east and west links; and exploring ways to accelerate construction of projects including the full HS2 network.”

Latest news

Massive Stewart Milne development goes into administration

Countesswells new town now in hands of administrators
12 hours ago

Ex-Laing O’Rourke boss to head rejigged BAM UK business

BAM names new chief for combined UK and Ireland businesses in growth push
18 hours ago

Robertson submits £150m Cardiff Arena plan

Arena work to start next Autumn with wider Atlantic Wharf regen scheme to follow
1 day ago

HS2 pioneers first ‘box-slide’ bridge over motorway

BBV will start initial site preparation over the Christmas holiday period
1 day ago

Rocks smash site huts as quarry blast goes wrong

Breedon Trading Ltd fined £300,000 after court hears worker was forced to run for cover
18 hours ago

Sellafield names £250m HVAC key delivery partners

Balfour Beatty Kilpatrick and EJ Parker Technical Services take first integrated team deal
2 days ago

Cut-price home builds quadruple maintenance cost

Mount Anvil study attempts to quantify link between Capex and Opex costs
19 hours ago

Ray O’Rourke to step down from Group Chief Executive role

New CEO Seamus French to join from mining giant Anglo American
2 days ago

TClarke on track for £500m revenue target

Orders surge to £525m setting fresh record for M&E specialist
2 days ago

Northern contractors still reeling from rail cancellations

Firms fear "economic black hole which will have a huge impact on regional SME contractors"
2 days ago

Go-ahead for McAlpine’s £43m Edinburgh concert hall job

Work to start next year on first concert venue in Edinburgh for over 100 years
2 days ago

Miller Homes fined £200,000 for polluting dyke

Court hears details of second incident at same Huddersfield site
2 days ago

Plans in for £60m Stoke goods yard quarter

Bowmer & Kirkland are working on the scheme under a pre-construction agreement
2 days ago

Quinn Infrastructure goes into administration

Rail M&E specialist contractor stops work on sites
3 days ago

Farrans to build £30m rotating Glasgow footbridge

Steel price rises blamed for 40% jump in rotating bridge cost
3 days ago

Brickability buys renewable energy specialist

Materials distributor buys new housing green energy specialist
3 days ago

RSK swoops for Yorkshire surveying specialist

Infrastructure surveying specialist Centara employs 60 staff
3 days ago

Former Amey director takes reins at renamed SSE Contracting

Zak Houlahan to lead Enerveo from December
3 days ago

Bouygues wins £30m Swansea zero carbon office

Firm to break ground in coming weeks on The Kingsway project
3 days ago

Sisk names new UK framework director

Rebecca Hartshorn to take on Scape framework development
3 days ago

Expanded starts work on giant HS2 station box

Construction will see 690,000 cubic metres of clay removed
4 days ago

Builders slam plans for electric car chargers in all new homes

Construction firms will foot the bill while electricity companies make the profits
4 days ago

Kier set for £32m Bournemouth council flats job

Work to start next year on four blocks of flats rising to 10 storeys
4 days ago

Severfield rises with record orders after strong first half

Orders soar to nearly £400m after Everton stadium award, shed and HS2 wins
4 days ago

Plans in for Manchester Red Bank enabling works

Council plans to spend £51m preparing way for up to 5,500 homes on old railway sidings
4 days ago

Triton bags biggest shed job yet

Firm eyes big shed delivery market after Stakehill 185 wins
4 days ago

Driver crushed between vehicles at builder’s merchant

Company fined £180,000 after court hears banksman had left yard area
4 days ago

£610m finance deal for Moda build-to-rent housing

£1.7bn Moda project pipeline targets Birmingham, Brighton & Hove and London
5 days ago

GMI names head for new North East business

GMI completes build-up of new north east team for regional expansion drive
4 days ago

National Highways halts first Smart motorway job

Balfour Beatty's £140m M3 smart motorway job put on hold
5 days ago

Contractor services