Client sues design team after Costain project cost nearly doubled

Aaron Morby 4 years ago
Share

Developer Standard Life is suing some of its professional design team on the Newbury Parkway shopping centre and flats scheme after the cost of the project soared from around £77m to £146m.

Newbury Parkway project was completed over six years ago but a legal battle of cost overruns is rumbling on through the courts
Newbury Parkway project was completed over six years ago but a legal battle of cost overruns is rumbling on through the courts

The firm is now locked in a legal battle with its design team – Building Design Partnership, Sutton Griffin Architects, and Cundall – claiming £38m for alleged professional negligence.

Main contractor Costain completed the project back in June 2013 and concluded a final settlement agreement, whereby it agreed to assist Standard Life with any dispute against third parties relating to contract administrators instructions and confirmation of verbal instructions.

Standard Life claims that £50m of the final settlement was made up of £28m from variations to the building contract and nearly £22m from contractor’s loss and expense from delay and disruption.

Project manager Buro Four analysed in detail a sample of over 100 CVIs and CAIs for Standard Life, which represented £14.6m of the extra cost.

Of these, it assessed 49% had arisen because of a “design team issue”, 10% from a “client issue” and 41% were “unclassified”.

This analysis has been used by Standard Life to extrapolate the final claim, which has just been contested by the design firms in the high court before moving to the full case being heard.

The members of the design team, which deny allegations against them, argued that they objected to the full claim going to trial because it was based on the extrapolated £25m variations claim and loss and expense claim.

To avoid lengthy assessment of each of the CVIs and CAIs through the court, Justice Kerr has ruled that Standard Life should select which of the 3,604 individual variations and 280 delay notices it wants to submit to support a fresh claim involving a trial by samples.

BDP will be allowed to selected 80 of these variations, SGA up to 40 others and Cundall 40. Standard Life would be required to set out its case against these.

A similar sample procedure should be used for the client’s loss and expense claim, ruled Justice Kerr.

Judge Kerr accepted that the procedure to reassess the claim may delay the trial date but added: “I think the delay resulting from the current exercise is a price worth paying for enabling the case to be managed properly”

Latest news

Comment: Gateway is acting like a barricade

Contractors left banging their heads on an (unbuilt) brick wall
3 days ago

Final phase of £1.5bn Elephant and Castle revamp hits planning

Get Living submits revised plan for 500 homes and 450-bed student block
3 days ago

Ealing backs final phase of £1.3bn estate rebuild

Friary Park estate rebuild in Acton reaches end stage
2 days ago

Green light for scaled-down Nottingham student tower

Glasshouse Street scheme will deliver 247 student rooms
3 days ago

Aston Villa to revamp North Stand

Club to reuse existing structure rather than complete rebuild
3 days ago

Mace signs ex-ISG director to lead Euro health and tech push

Gary Sweeney to head up healthcare and life sciences consultancy arm
2 days ago

Sir Robert McAlpine claws way back into profit

Firm says return to profit and strong cash balance validates new strategy
4 days ago

Severfield to cut staff by 6% amid pricing pressure

Steelwork contractor warns of extended tighter pricing due to project delays
4 days ago

JRL completes sale of 50% stake to Malaysian giant IJM

Deal boosts balance sheet and kicks starts growth plan
4 days ago

Green light for £100m Liverpool Baltic station build

Enabling highway works to start in the autumn
4 days ago

First live tests for flying construction robots

Drones can lay construction materials at height on site
4 days ago

Three firms land £170m Gentoo Sunderland housing deal

PHS Solutions, Esh and RE:GEN to deliver 10-year home upgrade plan
4 days ago

Gateway gridlock hits build-to-rent delivery as starts nosedive

Build to rent starts plunge 18% in the capital
5 days ago

Call to shift Gateway 2 checks to end building bottleneck

"The current system isn't working but we all want to see safe buildings"
5 days ago

GBN launches £600m bid race for SMR engineer roles

Owner engineers to provide technical and assurance services
5 days ago

Wates hires ex-Homes England chief to head public sector push

Robert Stone to spearhead its public sector and national frameworks strategy
5 days ago

Acheson Construction collapse costs suppliers £8.5m

One frustrated creditor seized a telehandler after contractor went into administration
5 days ago

Dominus wins go-ahead for 173-bed Glasgow scheme

Old Wynd Street job expected to cost around £25m to build
5 days ago

Safety Regulator misses deadline to clear Gateway 2 backlog

Investors pulling out of funding high rise buildings
5 days ago

CITB still sitting on £95m cash pile

Staff numbers jump from 666 to 763 as training body wage bill soars
6 days ago

£500m road surfacing framework market call

NEPO goes out to consultation on north east regional highways deal
6 days ago

Two share £220m Scottish rail repairs and minor works deal

AmcoGiffen and CPMS win civils and building repair deals
6 days ago

Builder wanted for £60m London leisure and flats job

Tower Hamlets aims to replace St George’s Leisure Centre in Shadwell
6 days ago

Contractor confirmed for business park expansion

Roe Developments to start on next phase of Castle Donington scheme
6 days ago

Driver escapes injury as scaffold collapses onto van

Major three-lift scaffold fall blocks north London high street
2 weeks ago

Gilbert Ash to be sold to staff

£267m turnover contractor to transition to an Employee Ownership Trust
2 weeks ago

M Group seals biggest-ever deal with Telent takeover

Digital infrastructure specialist deal lifts turnover to £3bn
2 weeks ago

Aggregates firm Ashville went down owing more than £3m

Debts revealed in Companies House update
2 weeks ago

Cardo saves 100 jobs at Breyer roofing arm

Private equity-backed Welsh maintenance group continues to expand
2 weeks ago

Excavator knocked off lorry going under bridge

Traffic Commissioner inquiry after accident in south London
2 weeks ago

Contractor services