Fears grow over Covid contract disputes as attitudes harden

Aaron Morby 5 years ago
Share

Construction leaders fear the industry could be heading for a big rise in contract disputes as signs emerge of hardening attitudes against claims for financial loss.

The Construction Leadership Council said that while the industry had worked together last year to get sites up and working, a survey has revealed the mood is changing.

Now there was real concern that as impacted projects begin to complete businesses will become embroiled in costly and long-running disputes over the effects of Covid-19 on projects.

It also warned that the indications were that 2021 may bring the ‘perfect storm’ of Brexit; reduced construction activity; the end of government business support schemes; introduction of reverse charge VAT and a significant increase in the number of claims across the supply chain.

The CLC surveyed was carried out among a range of leading industry professionals in the field of construction claims and disputes.

This revealed there had been an increase in the number of Covid-19 related construction claims being rejected.

Initial indications found that while parties were inclined to settle an entitlement to additional time for completion, there was reluctance to agree financial losses, costs and expenses.

Those responding said that high rise projects and finishing and commissioning trades would face the greatest contractual difficulties.

The survey uncovered anecdotal evidence of commercial behaviour hardening throughout the supply chain, including greater emphasis on management of existing contracts, increased tender lists and sub-economic pricing, increasing insolvencies and robust protective discussions on risk allocation in new contracts.

The CLC warned that without proper fair and reasonable administration of construction contracts, Covid-19 could have a significant and detrimental effect on the industry.

“The CLC asks that industry works together to support the long-term health of our sector by constructively resolving all contractual disputes arising from the pandemic,” said a spokesman.

Legal experts at Fenwick Elliott confirmed clients and contractors were taking a harder line on claims.

Senior Partner Simon Tolson said: “Many of those projects are now at or nearing practical completion.

“Numerous contractors and subbies are telling me there are now even harder chins out there. I strongly believe this reflects employers and main contractors protecting their margins amid fears of how 2021 may pan out.

“Brexit is in that mix too, so all that pent up caution breeds disputes as cashflow is not going in the right direction.

“I suspect that because the industry is seen as doing well picking itself off the floor since last April many feel the claims made are exaggerated.

“But with 15 to 20% drops in productivity, it’s a bit like the reality of ‘excess deaths’. Its very real, and claims are seen as only way out.

“I have seen from last spring to the end of 2020 many Covid Extension of Time and Loss & Expenses claims ‘parked’ until final account. A few have settled on a haggle but not many.

“Suicide bidding is also back in fashion as I am seeing bad contracts taken up that should have been declined so more blood on the carpet is likely.

“I think the CLC and Build UK have done a great job to encourage dialogue to avoid disputes but jaw jaw sometimes only goes so far.”

 

Latest news

Ardmore collapse triggers 275 job losses

Two insolvency practitioners - BTG and Panos Eliades Callender & Co - start assessing assets
1 hour ago

Wates wins £138m Sevenoaks town centre revamp

Contractor to take plans forward for new leisure centre and surrounding development
59 minutes ago

Costain lands road job to unlock giant estate

Work will start next year on £122m Norfolk project
3 hours ago

Speedy Hire racks-up £32m loss

Bosses confident of better times ahead at hire giant
9 hours ago

Higgins lands first phase of £500m estate revamp

West Kentish Town Estate redevelopment gets underway with £27m initial contract
9 hours ago

£1bn London film quarter scheme in Camden approved

Eleven sound stages and 485 homes planned for creative industries hub in Kentish Town
1 day ago

Bachy creates technical director role as ex-Skanska boss joins

Piling firm creates new technical director role as former Cementation Skanska leader takes over southern division
9 hours ago

RE:GEN, Esh and Bell set for slice of £48m Gentoo retrofit push

Sunderland housing association mobilises firms for 2,800 homes upgrade plan
9 hours ago

Graham signals start of £17m railway museum rebuild

New Central Hall project will unite buildings at York National Railway Museum
1 day ago

London mayor invests £100m in Silvertown revamp

"Singapore-style" fund launched as City Hall becomes more active in development market
1 day ago

Winvic lands £130m Leeds BTR towers job

Twin-block scheme of 578 flats to start in the late Autumn
2 days ago

Race starts to create blueprint for ultra-low-carbon schools

Government lines up experts for pioneering school building trial
1 day ago

Platform collapse fractures neck of drilling worker

Court hears catalogue of errors around temporary platform during concrete cutting work
2 days ago

Marlborough beats big rivals to £150m West Berkshire roads deal

Firm beats Ringway, VolkerHighways, M Group and Costain to 7-year upkeep deal
1 day ago

Domis clears Gateway 2 hurdle for Manchester tower

July start confirmed on 237-home Cornbrook scheme with aparthotel
2 days ago

Steel tariff loophole puts 30,000 fabrication jobs on the line

Industry demands urgent Government rethink as 1 July tariff cliff edge looms
2 days ago

Vistry launches voluntary exit scheme for staff

Swathe of job cuts loom as staff offered route out as debt reduction becomes top priority
2 days ago

Scores bag places on £9.5bn education building framework

Galliford Try, Graham, Seddon, CBES and GMI feature across multiple lots on CPC deal
2 days ago

Groundworks firm Mackoy bought in pre-pack deal

Former chairman and MD set up new firm after administration
5 days ago

Met Police launch £560m construction framework hunt

Nine-lot deal will drive refurbishments, security upgrades and new-build projects
2 days ago

CITB set for £20m pension windfall

Training body set to receive cash from fund wind-down
2 days ago

Construction leaders recognised in King’s birthday honours

Former Tideway boss Andy Mitchell knighted, and Rick Willmott gets OBE
2 days ago

McAlpine replaced on £4bn Somerset gigafactory job

Rival contractor TSL believed to be waiting in wings to take over
5 days ago

Contractors circle to finish Ardmore’s 10 big London jobs

De Group and RED Construction close in on two jobs
5 days ago

Ardmore Construction Group collapses into administration

Safety liability fears choke new work pipeline as London contractor shuts sites and calls in administrators
6 days ago

Kier wins £140m water contract extension

Sole appointment on two-year South West Water framework extension
5 days ago

New boss strengthens Severfield delivery team

Steelwork specialist appoints transformation and operations chiefs
5 days ago

Guildmore gets start date for £68m leisure centre

Demolition to get underway this autumn at Tower Hamlets site
5 days ago

Gatwick picks 11 firms to drive £2bn airport upgrade

Mace, Morgan Sindall and Costain land Gatwick framework spots
6 days ago

Allied London unveils landmark Castlefield tower plan

46-storey residential block would complete regeneration of long-vacant city centre site
6 days ago