Fears grow over Covid contract disputes as attitudes harden

Aaron Morby 2 weeks ago
Share

Construction leaders fear the industry could be heading for a big rise in contract disputes as signs emerge of hardening attitudes against claims for financial loss.

The Construction Leadership Council said that while the industry had worked together last year to get sites up and working, a survey has revealed the mood is changing.

Now there was real concern that as impacted projects begin to complete businesses will become embroiled in costly and long-running disputes over the effects of Covid-19 on projects.

It also warned that the indications were that 2021 may bring the ‘perfect storm’ of Brexit; reduced construction activity; the end of government business support schemes; introduction of reverse charge VAT and a significant increase in the number of claims across the supply chain.

The CLC surveyed was carried out among a range of leading industry professionals in the field of construction claims and disputes.

This revealed there had been an increase in the number of Covid-19 related construction claims being rejected.

Initial indications found that while parties were inclined to settle an entitlement to additional time for completion, there was reluctance to agree financial losses, costs and expenses.

Those responding said that high rise projects and finishing and commissioning trades would face the greatest contractual difficulties.

The survey uncovered anecdotal evidence of commercial behaviour hardening throughout the supply chain, including greater emphasis on management of existing contracts, increased tender lists and sub-economic pricing, increasing insolvencies and robust protective discussions on risk allocation in new contracts.

The CLC warned that without proper fair and reasonable administration of construction contracts, Covid-19 could have a significant and detrimental effect on the industry.

“The CLC asks that industry works together to support the long-term health of our sector by constructively resolving all contractual disputes arising from the pandemic,” said a spokesman.

Legal experts at Fenwick Elliott confirmed clients and contractors were taking a harder line on claims.

Senior Partner Simon Tolson said: “Many of those projects are now at or nearing practical completion.

“Numerous contractors and subbies are telling me there are now even harder chins out there. I strongly believe this reflects employers and main contractors protecting their margins amid fears of how 2021 may pan out.

“Brexit is in that mix too, so all that pent up caution breeds disputes as cashflow is not going in the right direction.

“I suspect that because the industry is seen as doing well picking itself off the floor since last April many feel the claims made are exaggerated.

“But with 15 to 20% drops in productivity, it’s a bit like the reality of ‘excess deaths’. Its very real, and claims are seen as only way out.

“I have seen from last spring to the end of 2020 many Covid Extension of Time and Loss & Expenses claims ‘parked’ until final account. A few have settled on a haggle but not many.

“Suicide bidding is also back in fashion as I am seeing bad contracts taken up that should have been declined so more blood on the carpet is likely.

“I think the CLC and Build UK have done a great job to encourage dialogue to avoid disputes but jaw jaw sometimes only goes so far.”

 

Latest news

Sisk wins £260m Birmingham skyscraper

Moda picks Sisk for second major tower project in the city centre
14 hours ago

AECOM chief joins Kier as London building MD

David McKenzie to lead growth of London construction business
17 hours ago

Scaffolders take on 300 Government ‘kickstart’ youngsters

Fifty NASC contractors commit to industry work placement push
14 hours ago
NASC

£760m confirmed for East West Rail next stage

£34m released for plan to reopen Northumberland line from Newcastle to Ashington
1 day ago

Strong trading lifts hirer P Flannery revenue to £116m

Revenue soars to record high for fast-growing plant hirer
22 hours ago

Site demand soars for Covid killing spray tunnels

Battersea Power Station site latest to install personal protection tunnels
22 hours ago

CSCS skills cards go virtual

Workers can now hold cards on their mobile phones
21 hours ago

GMI starts final £27m phase of Sheffield office complex

Developer Scarborough Group International commits to latest scheme
21 hours ago

St Modwen starts on speculative logistics site

Developer starts demolition work on major Basingstoke site
21 hours ago

Keep the industry updated by joining the Enquirer Directory

Membership lets construction know you are open for business as recovery gathers momentum
6 days ago

Over 50 jobs axed as steelwork contractor collapses

Conder Allslade placed in voluntary administration
4 days ago

Henry Construction wins London City Road tower

Work to start shortly on 22-storey red-brick skyscraper project
4 days ago

Galliford Try poaches HS2 civils contract boss

David Lowery joins as operations director, responsible for highways
4 days ago

BAM bags £29m Dartford high school

Work to start on Stone Lodge School in Kent
4 days ago

Go-ahead for 850-home west London TfL scheme

Bollo Lane trackside high rise residential scheme to be built in Acton
5 days ago

Sinkhole swallows homes on Manchester street

Collapsed sewer blamed for 10ft sinkhole
4 days ago

Bouygues to build latest Tower Hamlets resi block

Construction to start in March on 100 per cent affordable development
5 days ago

Scaffolders plan strike action at British Steel works

Scunthorpe site faces disruption as scaffolders take strike action over pay
5 days ago

Construction set to grow by 14% this year

'W' shaped recession and recovery as housing and infrastructure lead the way
6 days ago

Wates to start on Oxford university’s biggest building job

Planning green light means construction can start this summer on £200m Life and Mind Building
6 days ago

Builder crushed by falling pile of plasterboards

Suspended prison sentence for director after worker fractures pelvis
5 days ago

Graham tipped for £30m Birmingham tech hub

11-storey office project to be built  in the city’s Eastside area
5 days ago

18 housing groups team-up for offsite homes push

Northern housing bodies to switch from 'endless pilot projects' culture to build 9,000 homes
5 days ago

Winners named for £187m Surrey building framework

Ten secure spots on major projects lot for Spelthorne Borough Council
5 days ago

Galliford Try set to return to profitability

Contractor starts 2021 with a £3.3bn order book
6 days ago

Duo win design for £400m concrete roads renewal plan

Atkins and Aecom seal £39m design deal to upgrade 600 miles of concrete roads
7 days ago

Van Elle eyes strong recovery after challenging first half

Piling contractor confident market growth will drive return to profitability
6 days ago

£250m A1 Birtley to Coal House upgrade approved

Costain A1 upgrade job adjacent to the Angel of the North to start within months
6 days ago

Eric Wright to pave way for £180m Wirral Waters neighbourhood

Infrastructure package awarded on latest phase of transformation of River Mersey bank
6 days ago

May start for McAleer & Rushe £47m Leeds office job

12-storey City Square House project to start in May
6 days ago

Contractor services