Bechtel’s £100m HS2 legal claim over contract award fails

Grant Prior 1 month ago
Share

A legal challenge launched by Bechtel against HS2 over the £1.3bn contract award for Old Oak Common station in west London has failed.

Bechtel claimed for £100m in losses after losing out to the BBVS joint venture between Balfour, Vinci and Systra back in 2019.

Bechtel alleged that its bid had been incorrectly evaluated and the BBVS bid was an abnormally low tender.

But in a 152-page judgement handed down today all claims brought by Bechtel were dismissed.

Addleshaw Godard partner Bill Gilliam, who worked on the HS2 legal team, said: “This is an important judgment that provides crucial analysis for authorities and bidders alike on a number of aspects of procurement processes, including the courts’ involvement in challenges.

“Its impact will generate an increased confidence in approach for contracting authorities and utilities and useful guidance for bidders to take into account when formulating their bids, particularly when deciding whether it is necessary to qualify their bid in any way.”

A Bechtel spokesperson said: “We brought this case because we believed the ‘practical achievability’ of a bid was central to its evaluation.

“We are disappointed the judgement has come to a different conclusion.

“We will continue to press for fundamental reform to how major projects are procured.

“HS2 is an important multi-billion pound programme for the UK and we remain focused on our role as their development partner on Phase 2B.”

Latest news

Bauer/Keller JV to start £95m HS2 foundations job

Over 200 ground engineering experts will work on Chilterns to Warwickshire stretch
44 mins ago

All phases of £161m north London housing scheme approved

Countryside gains planning for full Peel Place in Kilburn
1 hour ago

Kane nets £29m MEP package on Balfour resi blocks

Specialist to focus on offsite construction across four south London towers from 11 to 30 storeys
43 mins ago

Formula 1 flywheel tech powers up Kier tower crane

Innovative energy storage technology delivers 40% fuel saving at Shakespeare North site
20 hours ago

Willmott Dixon bags £23m futuristic car park in Gateshead

10-storey steel-framed car park will be fitted with photovoltaic panels
18 hours ago

Construction rebound resumes as output jumps 1.6%

Optimism grows as commercial new work jumps 4%
22 hours ago

Laing O’Rourke targets staff gender balance by 2033

New mission statement also commits to operational net zero by the end of the decade
1 day ago

Ex-Wates Resi MD launches housing contractor Real

Paul Nicholls launches builder after buying Rydon Construction's businesses in the south
2 days ago

Billington warns of further steel price volatility ahead

Profits plunge by over 70% to £1.6m after Covid impacts sales and steel prices soar
1 day ago

Green light for £46m Shoreditch hotel and office scheme

Construction to start next year on former street food site
1 day ago

B&K set for £200m Nottingham Broadmarsh offices scheme

400,000 sq ft New Albion Place scheme planned next to old Broadmarsh shopping centre
1 day ago

Readie lands £28m deal for Moog Controls centre

Contractor confirmed by developer Barberry at Tewkesbury site
1 day ago

BAM names new construction chief for Scotland

Jim Ward replaces Bruce Dickson who is promoted to Royal BAM
2 days ago

Costain head of digital construction leaving

Contractor and chief digital officer Nathan Marsh part company
2 days ago

Bristol Uni puts back £300m Temple Quarter start to 2022

Delay supports design rethink to create more flexible space post-Covid
2 days ago

Engie gets green light for Rugeley Power Station revamp

Remediation work to start on site next month before cooling towers come down
2 days ago

FM Conway nabs infrastructure for Kent innovation park

Deal paves way for 1.1m sq ft Innovation Park Medway
2 days ago

Planning for 1,000 homes at north west London hospital site

Network Homes gains outline planning for full Northwick Park Hospital site regeneration scheme
2 days ago

Eric Wright to start £21m Burnley retail scheme

Work to start this summer on Pioneer Place shops and leisure development
2 days ago

Contractor jailed for filling old quarry with hazardous waste

M E Foley (Contractors) boss jailed for over two years
5 days ago

Bids invited for £540m JV North contractors framework

Race start for places on northern housing association consortium new-build framework
5 days ago

Contractor moves to four-day-week to boost work/life balance

Building and renovation specialist Orocco to give all site and office staff Fridays off
5 days ago

Scaffolding collapses on top floor of apartment site

Roads sealed off around resi job after scaffolding damaged during high winds
5 days ago

£250m South East Consortium housing framework winners

Vistry and Wates gain places on major projects lot for first time
5 days ago

Construction buyers report strong “spring surge” in output

Industry output expands at sharpest pace since September 2014
6 days ago

Three consortia shortlisted for Britain’s longest road tunnel

Murphy joins international line-up of firms shortlisted for £2.3bn Lower Thames Crossing
7 days ago

Arup staff have bank details hacked by cyber criminals

Ransomware attack sees staff data compromised at consultant
6 days ago

Skanska to switch all site equipment to vegetable oil power

Contractor wants to go all electric or hydrogen powered when technology allows
6 days ago

Lead time warnings on cement and aggies deliveries

Heavyside products and plastic drainage products join supply bottleneck list
7 days ago

Taylor Woodrow secures £328m Somerset A358 upgrade

Vital 9-mile section of A358 will be dualled to the M5
6 days ago

Contractor services