True cost of cladding crisis as high as £50bn

Aaron Morby 5 years ago
Share

The true cost of the national fire safety recladding project is 10 times higher than the Government’s allocated funding, according to one of the largest specialist contractors in the Midlands.

The government has set aside £5bn for cladding remediation works but this falls woefully short of the £50bn estimate Colmore Tang Construction believes is needed to make every high-rise housing development compliant.

The firm, which set up a specialist cladding arm at the start of this year, has priced remedial projects on over 20 typical developments in Leeds, Liverpool, Manchester.

It found the average cost of these works to be around £4.65m for buildings above 18m and £2m for buildings between 11m and 18m, which they claim is fair reflection of typical costs across the country.

According to Government figures around 5,000 buildings over 18m require an EWS1 certificate and may require remedial works, while around 35,000 11-18m buildings also fall into this category.

According to Colmore Tang’s pricing, which reflects their first-hand remedial works pricing experiance, this would bring the total to around £25bn for buildings over 18m and £70bn for buildings between 11m and 18m.

Given the paucity of information generally available and taking an optimistic view, they have reduced the theoretical total of £95bn by around half for safe measure, arriving at almost £50bn + VAT  as a realistic upper sum.

There has been mounting pressure from MPs to reassess the size of the Building Safety Fund, with the Housing, Communities and Local Government committee claiming the full cost of remedial works could be closer to £15bn.

The firm warns that some professionals have submitted budgets that are as much as three to four times below the real cost of the works.

It said that a developer in Birmingham submitted a bid for £3m despite the full project being worth closer to £10m, and claims it is a phenomenon being repeated across the country.

Steve Underwood, Chief Operating Officer of Colmore Tang, said: “The bottom line is that the true cost of remedial works has been severely underestimated and meaningful progress won’t be made until politicians and industry professionals develop a clearer understanding of funding and logistical challenges at hand here.

“Our estimates are not plucked out of thin air but are based upon real life scenarios which we see day in, day out. There’s a stark difference between costing a project and actually executing it, which largely explains this discrepancy.

“We’re seeing developers and surveyors quoting budgets that are nowhere near where they should be and we’re sleep walking into a scenario in which that only becomes apparent half way through the remedial works. That’s bad news for everyone.

“Suggestions that by simply re-tendering schemes we can reduce costs to original figures are patently unrealistic and quite frankly, dangerous.

“The race to the bottom approach to costing produced the poor workmanship, material standards and quality control which led to the cladding crisis in the first place and we are in danger of things spiralling out of control if we don’t buck up our ideas,” he warned.

 

Latest news

Police swoop on site safety test centre

Four arrested after probe into suspected payments to pass safety tests
12 hours ago

Fit-out firm Artemis files administration notice

Court papers lodged by £21m-turnover specialist
4 hours ago

Former Carillion chief Richard Howson fined £237,000

Group chief executive fined for "misleading statements"
17 hours ago

£100m Eden Project Morecambe gets green light

Councillors back halved-size scheme with two domes and 2028 opening target
3 hours ago

Ferrovial bags £80m Slough sewage works revamp

JV with sister company Cadagua to start construction early next year
4 hours ago

Battersea Power Station masterplan reset for final 16 acres

Architect hired to unlock 3.2m sq ft in riverside redevelopment endgame
3 hours ago

Graham clinches £286m Manchester student scheme

Contractor to deliver 2,300-bed campus rebuild for MMU
1 day ago

Chippenham £50m town centre reset go-ahead

Emery Gate shopping centre to be transformed with 225 homes
1 day ago

Green light for Italian plaster factory in Derbyshire

Fassa Bortolo picks old Stanton Ironworks site for new UK headquarters
1 day ago

Gateway 3 delays leave legacy homes still empty

Decisions on 44 schemes containing 5,594 flats still outstanding
2 days ago

Contractors wanted for £75m coastal civils deal

Portsmouth city council to hold bidders day ahead of April tender race
1 day ago

MTX signs deal for health campus near Cardiff

Offsite construction specialist appointed under PCSA as work set to start on site later this year
1 day ago

HBC breaks ground on £24m Sheffield co-living scheme

Hive 100 studio flats project starts in Kelham Island
1 day ago

Cheshire M&E specialist Gilks files administration notice

Management tells staff firm will close days before salaries due to be paid
4 days ago

Severfield facing strike action next week

Industrial action to hit Bolton factory
5 days ago

Jackson wins race for £22m East Sussex bridge

Construction set-to start on Exceat Bridge replacement
4 days ago

Plans ramp-up for Wythenshawe £500m town centre revamp

Food hall latest phase of Manchester regen
4 days ago

Kier set to bag £35m Bristol station car park job

Seven-storey MSCP will free up land for homes at Bristol Temple Meads
4 days ago

Leeds £1bn Eastgate Quarter vision moves up a gear

Consultant team assembled for Leeds’ last big city centre site
5 days ago

Morgan Sindall eyes bumper 2026 on record workload

High-flying fit-out arm triggers another profit upgrade
5 days ago

Funding agreed for £220m Paddington overstation job

Mace lined-up to start main construction works next month
5 days ago

Salford set for record £525m wastewater reset

United Utilities alliance firms gear up to deliver twin wastewater works upgrades
5 days ago

Construction grew 1.8% last year despite sharp Q4 fall

Private housing slump behind 2.1% output fall in final quarter
5 days ago

Firms fined after two killed when MEWP overturns

Tragedy during testing of warehouse racking system
5 days ago

Hill bags £45m Kent high-rise flats job

Firm beats rival Higgins and Lovell to Springfield Library redevelopment
5 days ago

Willmott Dixon gets start date for £43m Kent leisure job

Spring start for Gravesend Cascades Leisure Centre
5 days ago

D-Day for £37bn NHS hospital framework

Winners due to be announced imminently for mega deal
6 days ago

Severfield hires ex-ISG finance chief to steer turnaround

New CFO Andrew Page joins at “pivotal time” for steel specialist
6 days ago

Barratt Redrow £1bn safety upgrade works shift up a gear

Nearly 200 blocks now at tender or on site as remediation spend tops £73m in half year
6 days ago

Green light for Liverpool Street Station revamp

Plans approved to upgrade Britain's busiest station
6 days ago