M1 fraud probe exposes contract management problems

Aaron Morby 2 years ago

A National Highways fraud probe revealed by the Enquirer last year has found a string of concerning management issues on the M1 J13-16 smart motorway scheme.

The investigation by the agency’s in-house counter fraud squad has now concluded and found that National Highway has suffered financial loss.

But the national roads agency has decided not to pursue any criminal prosecution due to ‘insufficient conclusive evidence’, according to the final report seen by the Enquirer.

The investigation was launched into the Costain Galliford Try joint venture job after multiple accusations were leveled between 18 September 2020 and 2 February 2021, each alleging wrongdoing on the project.

These implied procurement fraud, theft of assets and collusion leading to false claims.

This scheme for a stretch between Milton Keynes and Northampton was awarded to the CGT JV with an agreed budget of £297m. This has ballooned to £453m.

Investigators for National Highways found £320,000 of central barrier scrap metal was ‘missing from the records and unaccounted for’ .

But after failing to secure any reliable witness testimony, the probe team said they were unable to prove the allegation of theft.

The investigation also failed to find hard evidence to support allegations of the use of ghost workers on the job, and bribes for subcontract work or business favours.

While labour supply on the project soared from £362,000 to around £9.5m, an investigation by the CGT JV uncovered no evidence to support whistleblowers claims, says the report.

In response to allegations of “brown envelopes” being passed around, National Highways investigators said that, although there was evidence cash-filled envelopes changed hands, it accepted the explanation that the money was requested from subcontractors to contribute to project staff parties.

Investigators also looked at a large package contract, which jumped from an original order value of £28m to a forecast end cost of £68m.

This was due for the most part to 1,389 compensation events, which were accepted as resulting from a number of complex underlying reasons.

National Highways’ commercial assurance partners have worked with the internal project team to understand the causes for the overspends and to challenge the escalating costs where appropriate.

In the final report, investigators did raise several concerns that ‘presented an increased risk of fraud and further possible accusations of bribery or corruption’ if not addressed.

These included poor contract management, in relation to escalating costs and proper implementation of the compensation events process.

They also highlighted a lack of record-keeping supporting key decisions during a live procurement and to validate ongoing subcontractor costs throughout the life-cycle of the project.

The team also red-flagged lack of governance around single-source procurement decisions.

A CGT JV spokesperson said: “The CGT JV responded comprehensively to all the issues brought to light with a detailed and thorough investigation, with appropriate action taken and further strengthening of its compliance procedures.

“Both companies in the JV have strong policies and procedures in place, fully promote a culture of transparency and encourage potential whistle-blowers to come forward.

“Both the CGT JV and National Highways investigations confirmed that there is no connection between any of the allegations and increased costs of the M1 junction 13-16 project.

“Any inference that the two are connected in any way or that the alleged activities that were under investigation have incurred a cost to the taxpayer is incorrect. Project scopes can evolve as was the case here, and those changes have the support of all parties involved.”

National Highways smart motorways programme director David Bray said: “We take any suggestion of criminal behaviour on our projects extremely seriously and investigate every allegation thoroughly. 

“We investigated, working collaboratively with our contractors, the allegations around the M1 and M6 schemes and prevented the payment of any amounts that we were not fully satisfied with.” 

Latest news

First sign of price falls for construction products

Supply returns to pre-covid levels as demand drops
21 hours ago

Three giant lab buildings approved at £700m Oxford R&D district

Phase 2 Oxford North office and lab buildings to deliver 460,000 sq ft of space
2 days ago

PM fails to quash speculation about plan to axe HS2 phase 2

Sunak ducks future of HS2 question at big net zero Government briefing
22 hours ago

Green light for giant North Wales offshore wind farm

Awel y Môr wind farm is the biggest renewable investment in Wales for a decade
21 hours ago

T&T breaks £1bn revenue mark for first time

Global consultant enjoys strong growth across all seven geographical regions
22 hours ago

Subcontractors and suppliers wanted across Scotland

Constructionline Meet the Buyer event next week at Hampden Park: Register now
21 hours ago

Springfield switches strategy as private housing slumps

Scottish house builder turns back to affordable homes market
2 days ago

Sunak details zero carbon targets climbdown

Ban on gas boilers delayed five years; 50% rise in scrappage scheme
1 day ago

RG Group to build tallest student block in the world

Contractor confirmed on 45-storey tower in Leeds
2 days ago

Galliford Try forecasts profit to double next year

Contractor delivers strong results this year and raises expectation for 2024
2 days ago

Strabag hires 15 senior Buckingham Group staff

Austrian civils giant to set up UK building business with pool of staff
3 days ago

Contractors raise pay offer to avert engineering construction strike

Blue book agreement employers up final offer to 10%
2 days ago

Former Mid Group chief joins Tilbury Douglas

Steven Hearn gets new role as regional director of the South East division
2 days ago

Crumbly concrete found at extra 27 schools

A total of 174 schools now found to contain RAAC concrete
3 days ago

Henry Boot Construction struggling to find work

Contracting arm looking to fill order book
3 days ago

More schools found to have crumbly concrete

Surveyors find another 27 schools containing Raac
3 days ago

Buckingham Plant Hire still trading as normal

Separate plant business "not affected" by collapse of contractor
3 days ago

NG Bailey makes £25m loss after Britishvolt shock

Gigafactory loss and problem contracts blow hole in books
4 days ago

Steelwork specialist Billington delivers record first-half

Overseas recruitment push boosts headcount by 10% to drive growth
3 days ago

Vinci wins major St Helens town centre revamp

£90m first phase includes new market hall, 120-bed hotel and over 60 flats
3 days ago

Mace deputy chairman to step down from board

Mace veteran Mark Holmes will leave at the end of the year
3 days ago

CHIC extends bid deadline on £3.2bn new build framework

Closing date for 8-year framework set for 20 October
4 days ago

Work to start this year on Manchester £250m spa resort

Developer Therme gets green light for re-engineered 28-acre Trafford complex
4 days ago

Costain bags £80m water order for upgrades at 16 sites

Severn Trent contracts include work to improve wastewater quality and protect wildlife
4 days ago

Barhale JV sign-off for £18m Dewsbury sewage works upgrade

Project forms part of Yorkshire Water’s £500m investment in Phosphorous removal
4 days ago

Murphy seals main build on £124m Essex station

Contractor lands main contract after successful start on enabling works package
7 days ago

GMI lands latest £42m phase of lab cluster

Citylabs life sciences complex in Manchester continues to grow
4 days ago

Director ban for asbestos dumper

Twenty tonnes of construction waste illegally dumped on farmland
4 days ago

HS2 leg to Manchester could be axed

Rishi Sunak and Jeremy Hunt are reportedly in talks to axe Northern leg
7 days ago

FM Conway revenue tops £500m

Highways contractor reduces net debt by £10m amid strong operating cash flow
7 days ago

Contractor services