Pimlico Plumbers holiday pay ruling could trigger wave of claims

Aaron Morby 2 years ago

Contractors are being warned to clarify the status of self-employed subbies following a landmark supreme court ruling that saw a Pimlico Plumbers worker win a claim for £74,000 in holiday back pay.

In a long-running legal battle, heating engineer Gary Smith, who worked for the company between 2005 and 2011, claimed he was owed holiday pay by Pimlico after the Supreme Court had previously ruled separately that he was a worker and not self-employed.

In his subsequent case that followed on from the employment status ruling, Smith’s claim for backdated holiday pay was at first rejected by an employment appeal tribunal on the grounds that he had not filed his claim quickly enough.

Under tribunal rules, Smith should have made his claim for missed pay within three months of each holiday period, dating back to 2005.

But the Court of Appeal has now overturned the lower courts’ judgments in a landmark decision this month that will have far-reaching impacts across the industry.

It held that ‘a worker can only lose this right if the employer can specifically and transparently show that they gave the worker the opportunity to take paid annual leave, encouraged the worker to take paid annual leave and informed the worker that the right would be lost at the end of the year.’

This means that ‘if the employer cannot evidence this, then the right does not lapse at the end of the year, it carries over and accumulates until termination of the contract.’

The ruling has prompted several industry trade bodies to write to its member contractors.

The Electrical Contractors Association warned members the ruling was important to all employers who deny workers the right to paid annual leave, usually on the basis that they are ‘self-employed.’

It reminded firms of the importance of correctly determining employment status and implementing the applicable rights that status confers.

The industry’s largest payer of subcontractors, Hudson Contract, said the ruling upped the ante but added it all hinged on ensuring the correct employment status.

Ian Anfield, managing director of Hudson Contract, said that it was important to remember that not all subbies are automatically ‘workers’.

He said: “The key fact in the Smith v Pimlico Plumbers case was that very early on an Employment Tribunal found Smith was a ‘worker’ – without that ruling the latest simply would not have happened.

“However, the bigger picture is that many users of subbies will be at risk.

“We have seen an explosion of so-called commercial contractors and employment agencies setting up CIS payroll companies to generate cash.

“The vast majority cut corners and wouldn’t have the funds or the knowledge to deal with complex cases.

“This places their clients at huge risk so there could be thousands of subbies out there eyeing Pimlico-type claims. If the economy turns and things tighten up we can expect to see lots of these cases go to court.

“During the last recession, before most of our competitors even existed, we fended off a number of spurious worker claims and our experience goes back even further than that.

“The question for contractors going forward is whether their current arrangements are watertight and can stand up to scrutiny.

“There’s no doubt this ruling by the Court of Appeal has upped the ante by increasing financial liabilities if a status case is lost, so it must be time to re-examine and scrutinise the credibility of what payroll companies claim they bring to the table.”


Latest news

McAlpine signs £500m Broadgate dual towers deal

Work to start on iconic 36-storey and 21-storey towers
13 hours ago

Worker rescued from collapsed four metre deep trench

Fire crews take six hours to save trapped builder near Blackwall Tunnel
17 hours ago

Gove puts another major building scheme on hold

Secretary of State starts another planning fight after M&S defeat
1 day ago

Greenwich University tenders £300m framework

Up to five firms will carry out upgrade and newbuild work at three campuses
17 hours ago

Work starts on Manchester 26-storey Obsidian tower

Contractor Domis starts Salboy's 10th Manchester scheme in seven years
15 hours ago

Race for £1.3bn West Midlands social homes framework

The Community Housing Group reboots tender race for new build housing
16 hours ago

Delancey submits £400m King’s Cross lab plans

200,000 sq ft lab/office project will be built above railway and tube tunnels just 4.5m below
1 day ago

Winners revealed for £150m fire safety framework

New deal will help organisations comply with the Building Safety Act
16 hours ago

Sellar plans £500m City tower next to Walkie-Talkie

Consultation starts on London 60 Gracechurch Street tower
2 days ago

Severfield ends year on high with record order book

Orders top £500m with strong future pipeline of opportunities ahead
2 days ago

Second senior director exits National Highways

Commercial director Malcolm Dare set to move on to new role
2 days ago

New scheme fuels London lab building boom

Plans in for 160,000 sq ft Whitechapel scheme near Royal London hospital
2 days ago

Contract race starts for next £155m section of A9 dualling

Prior Information Notice published for Tay Crossing to Ballinluig stretch
2 days ago

£55m Sheffield build-to-rent scheme approved

Demolition to start later this year for 158-flat Sheffield Garden project
2 days ago

London back as most expensive place to build in world

Capital leapfrogs Geneva to top costliest construction rankings
3 days ago

Gas supplier Regent to buy TClarke for £90m

£491m turnover listed building services specialist to be sold
3 days ago

Steel contractor Billington launches into bridge market

Steelwork firm hires staff from failed architectural and bridge specialist SH Structures
3 days ago

McGee employees benefit from rise in profits

Pre-tax profit doubles boosting payouts for Employee Ownership Trust
3 days ago

Lendlease veteran is latest new McAlpine director

Paul Sims joins as Operations Director after 40 years at rival contractor
3 days ago

Costain signs site labour supply deal with four firms

Contractor to use only a quartet of providers for temporary labour supply
3 days ago

BAM go-ahead for Leeds 200,000 sq ft office

Latitude Yellow will complete final plot at Doncaster Monk Bridge site
3 days ago

VolkerFitzpatrick wins £30m logistics job

Latest deal to build five distribution units for Prologis UK
3 days ago

Trio win new Scape utilities consultancy framework

Perfect Circle, AtkinsRéalis and Arcadis win places on
3 days ago

Precast firm FP McCann cleared after immigration raid

Home Office takes no action after public raid on construction site
4 days ago

Wates-owned SES restructure delivers record profit and revenue

Building services contractor revenue soars to almost £300m
4 days ago

25 groundworks firms win £100m Places for People deal

M&J Evans, Carmac and Churngold Construction feature in housing association's line-up
4 days ago

Energy efficiency firms angry at lack of CITB support

SME contractors funding bid "does not meet the current criteria for supporting productivity or EDI"
4 days ago

£400m South Cambridge science park approved

Outline approval allows former sewage treatment works to be demolished
4 days ago

McLaren gets green light for 45-storey Leeds tower

Landmark Wellington Square scheme will see 464 flats built with 360,000 sq ft of offices
7 days ago

Heavy rain causes 1.9% construction output fall

Hopes remain undampened of a resi-led recovery this summer
7 days ago

Contractor services