More than 30 firms paid for slave labour across London sites

Grant Prior 2 weeks ago

More than 30 construction companies were caught-up in the operations of an organised crime gang who trafficked slave labour onto sites across London and the South East.

A report by the independent anti slavery commissioner reveals the full extent of the gang’s operations and construction companies who “unwittingly” paid money into their accounts for workers.

The Operation Cardinas and Beyond report examines the fall-out of the investigation into a Romanian organsised crime group who placed more than 500 victims onto major projects between 2009 and 2018.

The criminals are now either in jail or awaiting sentencing while some of construction’s biggest names were interviewed as part of the report.

It stated: “The victims were usually employed as unskilled labour. Undertaking cleaning, or fetching and carrying jobs, they received less scrutiny than qualified tradespeople.

“Most were working on construction sites, but some were placed in the demolition sector and forced to do gruelling shifts without any training. The gang used a range of tactics to manipulate site security.”

The gang worked with corrupt testing centres to obtain fraudulent CSCS cards and the report highlighted “worrying systemic weaknesses in vetting and security.”

It stated: “For reasons of security and safety, most major contractors stipulate that workers must be registered and have their documentation checked before they can access a site.

“Given the rapid churn of workers, processing people places a heavy burden on resources. Responsibility is often passed down the supply chain: principal contractors will check right to work on their own employees and direct hires, but rely on suppliers to manage the process in the tiers below them.

“In the best cases, sites have airport type scanners for verifying passports, but many locations rely on staff to do visual checks. Interviewees acknowledged the risk of sophisticated forgeries being missed.

“They also said that, without specialised training, site teams could struggle to understand complex visa arrangements. The standard of labour agency processes is variable. Some are relying on video calls and photocopies of passports, rather than face to face meetings, when recruiting new workers.

In Operation Cardinas, criminals habitually found ways to undermine apparently tight security, even on large sites.”

How one subcontractor reacted to finding slave labour on is site

What does a contractor do when it suspects that there is forced labour on one of its projects? A common reaction is to remove the traffickers immediately. This strategy may minimise reputational damage, but it does little to disrupt the organised criminals that can easily move on to other targets. It also risks putting victims in greater danger.

A subcontractor had this dilemma when police first made contact while investigating Operation Cardinas. This case study explores the measures that the business took to protect workers over an 18 month period, while working closely with police.

The subcontractor operates predominantly in London and the southeast, it is typically involved with between 40 and 50 live projects at any time, working on a mixture of high profile commercial, residential and mixed use developments. A high proportion of its workforce is made up of migrant workers, mainly from Eastern Europe.

The investigation
Police contacted the company’s payroll department in 2018 asking for details of two workers. After liaising with the officer, the employee decided to carry out her own payroll investigation. She discovered that a number of workers on different projects were linked to the same bank accounts.

Although the police investigation had initially focused on two people, the subcontractor now suspected that 12 potential victims were hidden within its operations.

Protecting victims
After discussions with the police, the company agreed to keep the victims working on its sites, so that the investigation could continue without alerting the traffickers. At this point, many companies would have decided to terminate contracts in order to reduce corporate risk. But the company’s first priority was to protect the victims.

The construction director said: “At this point I took a deep breath. It’s a natural instinct to want to get rid of the risk immediately, but we didn’t want to kick the problem down the road. We wanted to manage it. We felt a moral commitment to the people that were being abused.”

Health, safety and wellbeing
While the investigation was ongoing, there were significant health and safety risks to manage. The general health of the victims was not known. If, as was suspected, they were not getting enough food and rest, they posed a danger to themselves and fellow workers. To further complicate matters, victims were dispersed across different sites.

To manage the situation, the director moved all the victims onto one very large project. He ensured that the work they were given was not too physically arduous.

“I put one of my most diplomatic and robust managers on site with them,” he said. “We hadn’t seen any sign of violence, but I chose someone that would be able to step in and intervene if there was trouble.”

The company also found a way of ensuring that victims could receive free nutritious food every day. In an initiative that was disguised as a pilot scheme, workers were given vouchers to use in the site canteen. Multiple sites were chosen for the pilot to avoid raising suspicion.

Watching the criminals operate
The investigation lasted another 18 months, but to prevent rumour or speculation within the business, only four people were aware of what was happening: the CEO, the construction director, the site manager and the payroll specialist.

As time went on, the construction director says that he was surprised at how easily the vulnerable people blended with the rest of the workforce on site.

“Superficially there was no obvious sign that anything was wrong. There was no sign of tension or coercion in the group, and all the paperwork and ID documents were in order. The only red flag was with payroll.”

How the OCG manipulated the company systems
Management have since discovered that the OCG scoped out the company before introducing victims into the business. Joining as self-employed workers, they became familiar with the vetting systems and security processes, and what would be required to pass through the system.

“They knew that we would insist on seeing a genuine passport, rather than a photocopy, and that workers must produce a proper CSCS card. They were smart enough to know that their men had to have the proper steel capped boots to be allowed to work on our sites. They did everything right,” the construction director said.

He added that the dirty clothes of the victims would not necessarily have raised concerns. “Labouring is a dirty job. Some people get changed when they come to site, but many don’t bother. Their appearance didn’t necessarily raise suspicion.”

Learning from Operation Cardinas
As a result of Operation Cardinas, the company vets worker gangs more closely, deliberately asking more challenging questions. It has also introduced a policy of paying all workers individually and directly into bank accounts. Staff training to raise awareness of modern slavery has also been rolled out across the business. The company has also shared its experience with industry peers.

The construction director said: “We use our experience to explain how the situation arose, and how challenging it can be to spot the signs. Our advice to other organisations is, ask awkward questions. Make sure people are who you think they are. This is a bigger problem than industry realises.”

Latest news

Failed London fit-out specialist owed trade firm 13m

Twenty 1 Group owed HMRC £9.7m leaving more than 300 firms with no hope of payment
7 hours ago

B&K returns to strong profit growth across the group

Pre-tax profit jumps 23% to £65m as revenue edges up to £1.18bn
18 hours ago

British Land expects tender price inflation to hit 10%

Developer says 91% of costs are fixed on planned schemes
18 hours ago

Morgan Sindall set for £80m leisure and health hub

West Suffolk public service development to be built at no extra cost to tax payers
19 hours ago

Plans in for £500m Hollow Mountain pumped hydro scheme

Work removing 2m tonnes of rock could start within two years
2 days ago

L&G to pump £4bn into West Midlands developments

West Midlands Mayor Andy Street signs landmark investment deal with L&G
18 hours ago

Hunt starts for £250m Stockport 8 site developer

Town centre 8-acre site is earmarked for 1,200 homes, shops and leisure
1 day ago

Higgins bags trio of East London passivhaus schemes

Partnership to build 220 affordable homes for Newham council
1 day ago

Water industry revives PFI model for £1bn job

Vast Haweswater Aqueduct upgrade to pilot new DPC model, hailed as the future for water companies
2 days ago

VolkerRail fined £550,000 after trench collapse

Court hears how two metre deep excavation was unsupported
2 days ago

‘Ratty the Robot’ takes bite out of costly pipe inspections

Pipe-crawling tetherless robo-rat makes light work of complex underground inspections
2 days ago

Graham gets green light for £124m M25 Junction 28

Consent allows work to start this Autumn on Essex junction upgrade
2 days ago

Six win £600m panelised housing DPS deal

Better Building alliance of 29 housing associations signs up manufacturers
2 days ago

Watkin Jones reports record £2bn pipeline

Student rooms and BTR builder plans corporate name change in big rebrand
2 days ago

Race starts for £500m Scottish zero carbon hospital job

Bidding starts for new University Hospital Monklands near Airdrie
3 days ago

Manchester airport taxis out £60m terminal 2 pier job

Bidding to start before the end of 2022 for project start early next summer
3 days ago

Plan for 1,100-home complex at Leicester factory site

Galliford Try investments plots Corah Factory transformation
3 days ago

Axed House by Urban Splash staff plan legal action

Ex-workers consult with lawyers following administration
3 days ago

Summer slowdown fears as latest contract award data droops

Latest Barbour ABI Snap Analysis paints uncertain picture
3 days ago

Farrans wins £39m Somerset recycling hub

Site preparation gets underway for Keynsham Recycling Hub
3 days ago

Balfour gets green light for £250m M25 junction 10

Autumn start for M25 junction 10/A3 Wisley interchange improvement scheme
6 days ago

Leeds plumbing contractor sinks with loss of 30 jobs

Dickinsons Plumbing and Heating goes down but renewables arm salvaged in sale
6 days ago

HS2 achieves first diesel-free construction site

Skanska Costain STRABAG JV runs Kilburn site with green kit
6 days ago

Administration confirmed at House by Urban Splash

160 jobs lost following "operational issues" at modular factory
7 days ago

Network Rail fined £1.4m after worker crushed by track machines

Judge highlights "many layers of failure" within site management
6 days ago

Kier picked for £350m Leatherhead regen plan

Property arm to draw up plans to redevelop two large town centre sites
7 days ago

Two seriously injured in London steelwork collapse

Two steel erectors left fighting for their lives after collapse at Ardmore site
1 week ago

Urban Splash modular staff start looking for new jobs

Work stops at House by Urban Splash factory and housing sites
1 week ago

Building facade specialist CMS goes into administration

Building envelope firm had turnover of £43m
1 week ago

Office work uplift returns construction output to growth

New commercial work drives output uplift for the first time since the pandemic
7 days ago

Contractor services