Ten demolition firms fined £60m for bid rigging

Grant Prior 2 years ago
Share

Cartel busters at the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) have fined 10 construction firms a total of nearly £60m for illegally colluding to rig bids for demolition and asbestos removal contracts

The CMA has also secured the disqualification of three directors of firms involved in the unlawful conduct across 19 contracts worth £150m.

The long running investigation has culminated in fines of £59,334,957 for colluding on prices through illegal cartel agreements when submitting bids in competitive tenders for contracts.

These bids were rigged, deceiving the customer that they were competitive when that was not the case.

Each of the ten firms was involved in at least one instance of bid rigging between January 2013 and June 2018.

The fines for each are:

  • Brown and Mason (£2,400,000)
  • Cantillon (£1,920,000)
  • Clifford Devlin (£423,615)
  • DSM (£1,400,000)
  • Erith (£17,568,800)
  • JF Hunt (£5,600,000)
  • Keltbray (£16,000,000)
  • McGee (£3,766,278)
  • Scudder (£8,256,264)
  • Squibb (£2,000,000)

Brown and Mason, Cantillon, Clifford Devlin, DSM, John F Hunt, Keltbray, McGee and Scudder were handed reduced fines as settling parties who had, as announced in June last year, admitted their involvement in the cartel activity.  

The CMA has secured the disqualification of three directors of companies involved in the unlawful conduct.

These are David Darsey (formerly a director of Erith) for a period of 5 years and 10 months, Michael Cantillon (formerly a director of Cantillon) for 7 years and 6 months and Paul Cluskey (current director of Cantillon) for 4 years and 6 months.

Each of these directors has benefited from reduced disqualification periods, having voluntarily agreed to the disqualification by way of undertakings to the CMA. 

The bids were rigged by one or more of the construction firms agreeing to submit bids that were deliberately priced to lose the tender. This practice of ‘cover bidding’ can result in customers paying higher prices or receiving lower quality services.  

In addition, the CMA found that five of the firms, on at least one occasion each, were involved in arrangements by which the designated ‘losers’ of the contracts were set to be compensated by the winner. Those firms were Brown and Mason, Cantillon, McGee, Scudder and Erith.  

The value of this compensation varied but was higher than £500,000 in one instance.  Some firms produced false invoices to hide this part of the illegal behaviour. 

The CMA found that the instances of illegal collusion took place over a five-year period and affected 19 contracts for demolition work in London, the Southeast, and the Midlands. 

The public and private sector contracts impacted included the development of Bow Street Magistrates Court and Police station, the Metropolitan Police training centre in Hendon, Selfridges (London), properties belonging to Oxford and Coventry Universities, shopping centres in Reading and Taplow, a large office block on London’s Southbank and other sites in central London.

Not all the firms were involved in colluding in each of these contracts, and not every contractor who submitted a bid for these contracts was involved in the illegal collusion. 

Michael Grenfell, the CMA’s Executive Director for Enforcement, said: “The construction sector is key to our country’s prosperity, so we want to see a competitive marketplace delivering value, innovation, and quality. 

“Today’s significant fines show that the CMA continues to crack down on illegal cartel behaviour. It should serve as a clear warning: the CMA will not tolerate unlawful conduct which weakens competition and keeps prices up at the expense of businesses and taxpayers. 

 “We have also secured the disqualification of certain company directors involved. Company directors must understand that they have personal responsibility for ensuring that their companies comply with competition law, and that disqualification may follow if they fail to do so.” 

The CMA’s decision follows a complex and large-scale investigation, opened in 2019.

The CMA conducted unannounced inspections of 15 business premises, interviewed 35 people, served over 120 notices requiring the provision of information or documents and undertook a detailed review of emails, mobile phone communications and financial records relating to the parties.  

In a statement John F Hunt said: “John F Hunt, as previously stated in our statement of 24 June 2022, acknowledge and accept the findings of the CMA investigation which has found that John F Hunt was involved in breaches of competition law in relation to a small number of historic and unrelated bids.

“We note the CMA’s acknowledgement that John F Hunt was not involved in any compensation arrangements relating to those bids.  John F Hunt also did not benefit from the award of any of the relevant contracts nor instigate any of the infringements.

“John F Hunt had already provided fully for the amount of the fine within their Financial Statements for the year ending 31 March 2021 so the Group’s net asset value will not be impacted in this or future financial years. We also intend to settle the amount fully due to the CMA at the earliest opportunity with free cash that had already been set aside.

“The Group has fully cooperated with the CMA’s investigation and is fully committed to compliance with competition law. We have strengthened our competition law compliance measures and do not condone any activity which limits or restricts competition in the market.”

Latest news

Wills Bros wins latest £152.7m A9 dualling deal

Contractor beats off competition from Balfour and Graham
10 hours ago

Lorne Stewart pulls plug on modular arm as losses mount

MDSL modular business wound down as parent LSRM reports £1.9m loss
19 hours ago

New law to force tower block cladding fix by 2029

Jail threat looms as £1bn fund launched to fix unsafe social housing
1 day ago

Infrastructure Pipeline published with 780 projects worth £530bn

New online tool to provide live updates on hundreds of schemes
2 days ago

World’s largest crane lifts Hinkley dome: Video

Construction times cut by 30% on nuclear site
1 day ago

Aviva funds council housing push in north London

Barnet council seals first big institutional funding deal for housing
19 hours ago

Tarmac lands Welsh road repairs deal

Tarmac will also be able to bid for improvement work on the A55 North Wales Expressway
19 hours ago

Flannery invests £22m with JCB to boost fleet

Plant hirer strikes latest deal with machinery giant as fleet investment continues
2 days ago

BAM boots Danny Sullivan off £100m HS2 bat tunnel

Contractor terminates labour supply deal on controversial project
2 days ago

Mace confirmed for £200m Paddington overstation job

Helical JV also sets start date for 429-room student job over Southwark station
2 days ago

Kier names new construction boss for clients and markets

Rebecca Boundy promoted to lead sector teams after year of framework wins
2 days ago

Elements Europe went down owing supply chain £8.7m

Korean owner kept offsite specialist afloat with £71.8m of loans in bid to stem losses
3 days ago

Bristol awards £288m civils and highways framework

Eurovia, Tarmac, Colas and regional SMEs share 10-lot deal
2 days ago

Kier seals PCSA deal for £55m Bridgend school

Heronbridge special school move back on track after cost hike and delay
2 days ago

Mobile crane fire closes M11 motorway

City Lifting machine catches fire in Essex
2 days ago

Altius and Erith win landmark London tower rebuild

Westminster council advances Huguenot House redevelopment
3 days ago

Corbyn suppliers left £4.4m out-of-pocket

£33m-turnover civils contractor only employed eight staff
3 days ago

McAlpine to restore England’s largest Victorian water tower

Colchester’s iconic ‘Jumbo’ to be reborn as visitor destination
3 days ago

Andrew Scott lands £20m Grand Pavilion revamp in Porthcawl

Restoration of landmark Art Deco building gets underway with 2027 finish target
3 days ago

Keepmoat profit drops 35% as completions slide

Land pipeline expands to 24,400 plots as firm eyes rebound
3 days ago

Bid race begins for £425m water transfer scheme

Contractors invited to help shape Affinity Water project
3 days ago

Legacy building defects return to haunt Barratt Redrow

House builder sets aside £248m for Redrow fire and concrete frame fixes
4 days ago

Skanska agrees £153m price to revamp A47 Thickthorn junction

New link roads and underpasses to ease traffic near Norwich
4 days ago

First tower plans go in for £1bn Liverpool Pier Head site

First design will "set tone" of scheme which could contain 60-storey tower
4 days ago

Barhale creates new low-carbon chief board role

Haddon takes board seat while Solomon becomes eastern regional director
4 days ago

Met Police preps £300m framework for estate upgrade

Early market talks start ahead of October bid contest
4 days ago

Raft of SME firms win £94m framework places

More than 50 demolition and asbestos specialists chosen: Full list
4 days ago

GRAHAM gets go-ahead for £110m Boddingtons Brewery revamp

Work to start this summer after Gateway 2 approval secured
5 days ago

Thames Water finance chief joins BAM UK & Ireland

Abigail Farrell-Black joins contractor as new finance head after senior roles at Thames and Southern Water
5 days ago

FM Conway profit jumps to £33m under Vinci

Turnover hits £608m and cash surges £68m just two months into new ownership
5 days ago