Failure of three ‘non-critical’ RAAC beams forced safety rethink

Aaron Morby 2 years ago
Share

The education secretary has revealed that the sudden failure over the summer of three RAAC concrete planks previously classified as non-critical prompted the decision to close over 100 schools.

In a statement to Parliament Gillian Keegan said surveyors discovered the non-critical RAAC failures during a programme of assessments started last September.

This led to the identification of three previously classified non-critical risk failures that happened without warning.

The first was in a commercial building setting, the second in a school, with the most recent failure, which came to light at the end of August, prompting the decision to close a further 104 school buildings.

She said: “In September 2022 we started a programme where the DFE sent a professional surveyor to assess whether RAAC is present.

“If RAAC was present, the previous DFE guidance was to grade it as critical or non-critical, and only take buildings out of use for critical RAAC cases.

“Such was the level of our concern, however, that I asked officials to seek evidence of risks, including to non-critical RAAC.

“It is because of this proactive approach that we discovered details of three new cases over the summer, where RAAC that would have been graded as non-critical had failed without warning.”

Keegan added: “The first was in a commercial setting. The second was in a school in a different educational jurisdiction.

“In that instance, the plank that failed remained suspended, resting on a steel beam. As the plank was fully intact, DFE engineers were able to investigate the situation. In their professional judgment, the panel affected would have been previously rated as non-critical, but it had failed.

“Ministerial colleagues and I were already extremely concerned, but then a third failure of RAAC panels occurred, at a school in England in late August. This was a panel that had previously been graded as non-critical.

“Because children’s safety is our absolute priority, it was right to make the difficult decision to change our guidance for education settings, so that areas previously deemed to contain non-critical RAAC are now being closed.”

Keegan confirmed the DfE will publish the list of the 156 schools with confirmed cases of RAAC this week, with details of initial mitigations in place.

After that, she pledged to provide updated information as new cases of RAAC were confirmed and existing cases resolved, following the safety reporting model adopted in the cladding fire safety crisis.

In an echo of action taken over RAAC in the hospital sector, contractors now fear there will be a further slippage in the school rebuilding programme as at risk schools are prioritised over others being worked on in the programme.

One told the Enquirer: “We saw this in the new hospital building programme when the Government suddenly added five hospital projects to its £20bn building programme due to the risk of structural collapse because of weak concrete.

“These replaced existing schemes rather than adding to the total programme. It looks like the same will happen in education now the Government is suggesting emergency work will be delivered within existing budgets.”

In the schools crisis statement to parliament Keegan said DfE official were working with three contractors to ramp up the supply of temporary buildings, and accelerated the installation of these.

She said: “We have the support of our leading utility companies to ensure that those classrooms can be opened. In the small number of schools with confirmed RAAC, disruption to face-to-face learning has usually lasted a matter of days.

“We will also fund the longer-term refurbishment or rebuilding projects, where these are needed, to rectify RAAC.”

About a third of schools surveyed have been found to have used RAAC concrete.

She revealed that the remaining 600 priority schools still needing surveys were now in an accelerated programme.

To deliver this, the DfE has enlisted five more building surveying companies to the three in place to ensure sufficient capacity to complete the emergency assessments within the next couple of weeks.

Latest news

BESA audit blitz sees 14 specialist contractors suspended

Building engineering services trade body cracks down on standards
12 hours ago

JV North unveils winners of £500m housing blitz

Consortium gears up to deliver 3,000 new homes across North West
13 hours ago

Partnerships builder Keepmoat names new chief executive

Ian Hoad to take reins as Tim Beale steps down after eight years
15 hours ago

Ballymore to transform former Crossrail construction site

Limmo Peninsula will be new neighbourhood in East London
18 hours ago

Building Safety Regulator chief to step down

Search on to find replacement for Philip White
22 hours ago

Amazon unveils £40bn investment plan for UK sites

Four new fulfillment centres confirmed as part of huge spending package
21 hours ago

Glass bridge picked for Queen Elizabeth II memorial

New bridge and gardens will honour late Queen in the heart of London
21 hours ago

Mears set to beat profit forecasts after strong first half

Maintenance growth and 100% contract retention drive bullish outlook for 2025
21 hours ago

Bouygues lands London 150 key worker homes job

Affordable flats planned near London Bridge in landmark council scheme
22 hours ago

Hebden Bridge £68m flood defence job heads to market

Market engagement opens on four-year Environment Agency scheme
22 hours ago

Housing plans go in for abandoned theme park

Story Homes to transform former Camelot Theme Park in Lancashire
22 hours ago

Morris & Spottiswood sees turnover and profits surge

Growth at M&E division helps power record numbers
22 hours ago

Redundancies loom at M&E giant Dalkia

Consultation starts at Southern region
2 days ago

Land deal unlocks East London £750m health hub plan

Queen Mary University secures site to build Whitechapel life sciences complex
2 days ago

Aureos bags £45m Howden Relief Road job

Former Keltbray infrastructure business to start construction next month
2 days ago

Four injured after partially built floor collapses

Court hears how steel beams were cut at the same time Acrow props removed
2 days ago

Careys directors sacked after £4m job-loss showdown

Pair win unfair dismissal case after being accused of "tickling each other’s bollocks"
5 days ago

Octavius wins £31m A38 corridor upgrade

North Somerset picks firm for key trunk road improvement scheme
2 days ago

Danny Sullivan Group hits back over HS2 allegations

Labour supply giant confident it is "fully compliant with all tax obligations"
5 days ago

Bid race takes off for £500m MAG airport small works deal

Nine-lot framework to cover civils, building and M&E jobs up to £5m
5 days ago

Mace director joins Wates as Chief Commercial Officer

Pat Fitzgerald to lead commercial strategy at Wates
5 days ago

Rob Perrins steps up as executive chair in Berkeley shake-up

Long-serving chief steps up to lead housebuilder’s next growth phase
5 days ago

Competition watchdog turns attention to civil engineering

Competition and Markets Authority launches study into road and rail delivery
6 days ago

Timber imports rise for first time in four years

Softwood volumes and prices lead rebound as housing outlook improves
5 days ago

10-Year Infrastructure Strategy published

Full details as Government pledges £725bn of funding over the next decade
6 days ago

Korean firm buys part built Hackney job from failed Elements Europe

Work can now restart on 21-storey hotel and office development
6 days ago

Mark Wild radical reset plan to rescue HS2

Senior manager bonuses scrapped and non-permanent labour cutback
6 days ago

HS2 supply chain fraud claims spark ministerial probe

Transport secretary pledges one-year reset for HS2 to end 'litany of failures'
7 days ago

Lords launch inquiry into Building Safety Regulator delays

Industry asked for evidence of how system is failing: Have your say
6 days ago

Willmott Dixon director becomes co-owner of local contractor BSN

Nick Gibb targets £100m turnover at Dudley based national contractor
7 days ago