Watchdog MPs raise alarm over HS2 Euston station plan

Aaron Morby 5 months ago
Share

MPs on the Public Accounts Committee have lambasted the management of the HS2 project and raised grave concerns about the latest plan to deliver the Euston terminus in London.

Grand plans for Euston, but PAC questions when it will actually get built
Grand plans for Euston, but PAC questions when it will actually get built

Their report published today calls for “fundamental reset” of the project by the summer.

They warn that they remain sceptical about the Government’s ability to successfully deliver its revised programme following a litany of failures and unheeded warnings.

The report says that the HS2 programme has become a casebook example of how not to run a major project.

“It is unacceptable that over a decade into the programme we still do not know what it will cost, what the final scope will be, when it will finally be completed or what benefits it will deliver,” states their report.

Watchdog MPs also highlighted the significant challenges facing plans to build the Euston Station terminus using a third party development body.

As plans stand, HS2 will open with a terminus at Old Old Common. Despite plans to launch the TBM tunnel drive next year to Euston from Old Oak Common there are no detailed plans or timescale for delivering the Euston Terminus, warns the report.

The Government’s Euston plans currently rest on the £6bn cost being significantly underpinned by the private sector.

The PAC said it was concerned that there is no clear plan for this, and said it was sceptical the private sector would come forward to the level required.

The government confirmed that HS2 would terminate at London Euston in the Autumn 2024 budget.

However, the PAC warns the Department still does not yet have a plan for the work at Euston which includes: the HS2 station, the existing Network Rail station, the underground station, and the commercial and housing developments near the station.

“In addition, the Department intends the work to be sustantively privately funded, but it is unclear how achievable this goal is,” they warn.

Sir Geoffrey Clifton-Brown MP, Chair of the Committee, said: “Our Committee has not made recommendations in our report on delivering better outcomes for HS2’s future passengers.

“We are long past that point. It is time to deal with HS2 as what it is – a cautionary tale that should be studied by future Governments in how not to run a major project.

“We are sceptical of Government’s ability to successfully deliver even a curtailed scheme, one which we already know will on its face bring very poor value for money. The question has instead become: what possible benefit can the Government now salvage for the taxpayer, from a mess that presents real risks to the UK’s overall reputation?”

The Department for Transport’s present cost estimated set out in November 2023 is £45bn to £54bn compared with HS2 Ltd’s latest estimate of £54bn to £66bn in June 2024.

Both cost estimates are still in 2019 prices, once adjusted for inflation, the total programme costs might be close to £80bn, states the report.

 

Latest news

China told to lift veil on ‘greyed-out’ London super embassy plans

Ministers give China two weeks to justify redactions in blueprints for £255m Royal Mint Court scheme
35 minutes ago

Mace wins £1.1bn British Library extension

Work to start on site next year after construction manager contract awarded
20 hours ago

Spencer shunts Volker on £29m Waterbeach rail station job

VolkerFitzpatrick misses out despite early contractor involvement
22 hours ago

Regulatory gridlock ‘knocks confidence’ in construction

RICS urges action as firms struggle with safety Gateway inconsistencies and regional planning delays
21 hours ago

McLaren tops contract league with Ebury Estate rebuild

July order haul among top 50 firms rises 14%
23 hours ago

Cheetham Hill Construction sold to staff

Howard Chamberlain to step-back from MD role after nearly 60 years
2 days ago

Buyers see sharpest fall in activity for five years

Grim July for construction as all sectors slump
2 days ago

Breheny bags Kent road upgrade contract

Work to start later this month on Maidstone site
23 hours ago

Caddick breaks ground on £28m Bilston logistics park job

166,500 sq ft logistics hub to be built at Foundry Business Park
23 hours ago

Mears grows profit as maintenance work ramps up

100% contract retention and rising margins deliver strong first-half performance
23 hours ago

Cardiff to get 50-storey skyscraper in bold new tower plan

Developer ups height to 50 storeys for BTR landmark near Principality Stadium
2 days ago

Bid race starts for Manchester £1.6bn light rail infrastructure work

Up to ten bidders wanted to compete for Metrolink work
2 days ago

Competitive brick market sees Ibstock struggle to increase prices

Revenue rises but profits dip at materials giant
2 days ago

Collins starts major London city fringe office retrofit

30 Finsbury Square refurb scheme will transform office block
2 days ago

Civils boss banned over classic car sales

Director sold assets cheaply to sister company before folding
3 days ago

Ex-Kier director joins Stepnell to grow specialist units

Mike Smedley steps in as strategic director to lead growth push
2 days ago

Clegg wins £80m Leeds office scheme

Eight-storey office project to rise on former Wellington Plaza site
3 days ago

Avant Homes takes £107m fire safety hit as losses mount

Builder led by Jeff Fairburn lifts provision by £39m for legacy cladding repairs
3 days ago

Profit recovery continues at Laing O’Rourke

CEO Cathal O’Rourke vows to "push the boundaries of what’s possible, in service of humanity"
4 days ago

Torsion clears Gateway 2 for Leeds student scheme

Firm to share lessons from the Gateway 2 process on Kirkstall Road 10-storey job
3 days ago

Bouygues chosen to build new children’s hospital

Construction to start within next 18 months on Cambridge site
3 days ago

Firms readied for £145m Welsh bridge race

Bidding to start this month for River Dee bridge replacement job
4 days ago

Cladding training boost to accelerate remediation work

Free courses for installers and supervisors to help accelerate post-Grenfell work
3 days ago

JRL replaces Ardmore on £150m City landmark revamp

Malaysian developer IJM calls in part-owned contractor for 25 Finsbury Circus job
4 days ago

Green light for Bristol Brabazon over-station office block

YTL to start eight-storey HQ building above new train station ticket office
4 days ago

£200m funding deal for hydrogen from waste plant

Tilbury site will be first stage of national network for green fuel
4 days ago

Go-ahead for London major hospital-to-resi scheme

Developer TT Group to deliver 140 homes and 65-bed care home on historic site
4 days ago

Civil specialist M Lambe slips into the red

Firm predicts bounce back this year as social housing recovers
4 days ago

Pickstock plans to revamp derelict Birmingham site

Developer looks to transform Soho Hill in the city
4 days ago

Retentions could be banned in late payment crackdown

Government considers abolition of hated system in construction
1 week ago