Opinion: Time for change as majors suffer £850m loss

Aaron Morby 10 years ago
Share

There can be little doubt that big name contractors suffered more pain than expected coming out of the last recession.

Seven major contractor businesses have emerged like walking wounded after jointly running up a staggering £850m loss.

Much of this may be down to Balfour Beatty and Vinci, but the extent of the malaise calls in to question the quality of management and risk control processes during the downturn.

Such staggering losses contrast starkly with the volume house builders who are now enjoying a bumper crop of record profits and the help of a Government under intense political pressure to coax them into building more.

Not so magnificent seven Seven of the best house builders
Firm Loss Turnover % loss
on sales
Firm Profit Turnover Profit
margin
Balfour Beatty Constn £391m £6.6bn 6% Barratt £565m £3.8bn 15%
Vinci UK £217m £1bn 22% Berkeley £540m £2.12bn 25%
Sir Robert McAlpine £108m £862m 12.5% Persimmon £475m £2.6bn 18%
Laing O’Rourke Europe £58m £1.7bn 3% Taylor Wimpey £450m £2.7bn 17%
ISG £28m £1.6bn 1.7% Redrow £213m £1.15bn 19%
Morgan Sindall* £27m £1.1bn 2.4% Bellway* £159m £831m 19%
BAM Nuttall £20m £774m 2.6% Bovis £133m £809m 16%
*half-year

The industry is now in a two-speed recovery.

At the front are the country’s leading house builders who have shrugged off their land legacy and debt problems since the 2008/09 housing crash. Two of the best are each serving up stunning pre-tax profits of over £500m a year.

The few publicly-listed volume contractors that doggedly stuck to the traditional and once unfashionable model of running contracting alongside housing businesses are also in good shape to ride the recovery.

And those that can, like Willmott Dixon and Wates, are rolling out more development-led business as a strategy to improve the quality of profits.

In the slower lane, the phrase legacy project is often used to explain away present problems, but this is disguising something more troubling about the past and the future.

Already tight for cash, the recovery is asking big questions of the majors.

They see clients loathe to front-load project payment, Government tightening up on supply chain payment and the rising use of project bank accounts which are all leaving little opportunity to make a living holding onto others cash.

At the same time subcontractor cost inflation shows little sign of abating.

It means the cash flow squeeze is here to stay and it is hard to see better times ahead unless the majors ring the changes.

The brutal fact is the UK business model that sees main contractors take on high project risk for a 1-2% margin is simply not viable any longer.

It must be abandoned for sanity to prevail.

Clients may be moaning about outturn costs on projects now, but they simply are too used to projects being subsidised by loss-making supply chains.

Despite anecdotes that clients are considering stalling the odd marginal scheme, there is still plenty of headroom for a decent profit as a glance at most developers’ accounts testifies.

It would be smart for clients to work much more closely with contractors to understand cash and risk profiles as a starting point.

It would be even smarter for clients to allow main contractors to start pricing building work at a 4% margin.

Then everybody would have a chance to invest in building better and faster.

 

Latest news

Costain transformation board director exits

Abi Lalani departs as 30-strong change team enters redundancy consultation
3 hours ago

Clancy profit up a third as infra boom drives growth

Family contractor lifts operating margin to 6.3% as turnover tops £430m
3 hours ago

Bouygues gets nod for £185m Exeter Uni student campus

Six new blocks and a major refurbishment to reshape Streatham campus
23 hours ago

Salford civils firms joins employee-owned ranks

Lowbury Construction builds future on employee ownership model
8 minutes ago

Southern Water gears up £70m Andover pipeline bid race

Hampshire pipeline job to boost water supplies and protect rare chalk streams
3 hours ago

Homes England signs deal to boost York housing push

Joint plan to deliver new homes at York Central, Maltkiln and Elvington
3 hours ago

UK cement production drops to lowest level since 1950

Domestic producers warn government construction plans are under threat
3 hours ago

Merit looking to expand despite unexpected tax demand

Offsite specialist blindsided by HMRC action
20 hours ago

Costain poaches Amey highways boss

Andy Denman charged with restoring growth in core road market
1 day ago

McAlpine slims down board with focus on three core markets

Former MDs step back from board but stay with business
1 day ago

Sisk swoops to buy Farrans from CRH

625-strong Northern Ireland based business to continue trading under own brand
2 days ago

Winvic breaks £1bn turnover as profit jumps 70%

Margins improve and order book swells as BSR approvals and frameworks kick in
1 day ago

IES Utilities installs utilities expert Neil Kirkby as new CEO

Ex-Enterprise and Balfour Beatty director appointed to drive growth push
1 day ago

Keepmoat to deliver 600-home urban village in Sandwell

Big decontamination job needed to unlock one of region’s largest brownfield sites
2 days ago

Michelmersh profits hit by ‘highly competitive’ pricing

Stocks back above average levels as Building Safety Act hits demand
1 day ago

Graham to start £71m enabling works at Liverpool Central Docks

Work to pave the way for Peel Waters’ 2,350-home waterfront neighbourhood
2 days ago

Bouygues to build LSE’s 2,000-bed London Bankside towers

LSE plans to replace Bankside House with trio of towers up to 28 storeys
2 days ago

Lack of sewerage blocking building work on 30,000 homes

House builders blast planning delays over inadequate wastewater infrastructure
2 days ago

Race starts for £145m River Dee Bridge rebuild

Welsh Government sets 2026 start date for major cross-border link
2 days ago

Canary Wharf to submit plan for Olympic-sized lido

Plan to deliver six-lane natural water pool at Eden Dock by 2026
2 days ago

Plans go in for six-tower Leeds resi scheme

New £100m "urban community" for 3.7acre site
2 days ago

Genuit buys ventilation firm Monodraught for £56m

Building products giant acquires £17m turnover business
2 days ago

Ardmore Construction Ltd falls into administration

Move isolates fire safety claims, leaving main Ardmore group free to grow profitability
5 days ago

Aston Villa gets go-ahead for £100m North Stand expansion

Project to modernise 1897-built ground ahead of EURO 2028
5 days ago

Quartet wins £1.75bn Midlands Rail Hub upgrade deal

VolkerRail, Laing O’Rourke, AtkinsRéalis and Siemens team up on Birmingham upgrade
6 days ago

McLaren confirmed for £250m Cardiff arena

Robertson Property secures planning green light for 16,500-capacity venue
6 days ago

John F Hunt starts work on £150m West End office revamp

Six month strip out deal at 125 Shaftesbury Avenue
5 days ago

Former Skanska vice president to join Galliford Try

Thomas Faulkner to head up specialist services division
5 days ago

Bowmer + Kirkland snaps up office fit-out firm Denton

Acquisition gives £40m turnover interiors specialist firepower to chase bigger jobs
6 days ago

Contractors sought for £667m Welsh Water mega project

Utility tests appetite for design, build and finance for twin water treatment jobs
6 days ago