Call for fire tests transparency as 75 buildings fail

Aaron Morby 8 years ago
Share

Industry fire experts are calling for much greater transparency around what type of fire testing regime is being used to check cladding systems.

Cladding is being removed from buildings from Plymouth to Liverpool
Cladding is being removed from buildings from Plymouth to Liverpool

Questions are being raised after the Government revealed the total number of buildings with condemned cladding has soared to 75  – 100% of all those tested.

So far the Government has only confirmed that the Building Research Establishment combustibility test has three categories rated 1 to 3.

It has been judged that cladding material falling in category two or three does not meet the requirements for limited combustibility in Building Regulations, although the details of what this test involves has not been revealed.

Some industry professionals are concerned that the Government has applied the most stringent Building Regulation guidance that only allows materials of limited combustibility or Class A2.

But building elements do not need to comply with A2 grading if fire tests prove the system as a whole meets the requirements to BS8414.

Experts have warned that far more comprehensive tests on the entire cladding system are needed to establish if buildings are at-risk including the insulation and design details such as fire stops.

A cladding contractor and former fireman told the Enquirer: “Nobody knows what the three-stage tests are that they are applying to samples sent in, but all are failing.

“The letter states that the ACM should achieve A2 standard to comply with Building Regs but Approved Document B does not say that. We can’t understand where they are getting their information from.

“It’s highly likely they are failing tower blocks unnecessarily. ”

The shadow housing secretary, John Healey, warned the House of Commons that “cladding is not the whole story”.

Fire risk consultant Stephen Mackenzie said: “The government is fundamentally flawed in its use of the BRE to conduct overly simplistic and limited fire test samples and not the complete cladding assembly.

“The small scale tests on external panels need to to be extended to a full disassembly.”

Another source told the Enquirer: “We are still not being told what materials or systems are failing – is it just Reynobond (PE) cladding or other materials? More information is required.”

In an update on the failed number of cladding samples found on buildings within 26 local areas, Communities Secretary Sajid Javid said the Government was also working with the Government Property Unit to oversee checks on wider public sector buildings.

“Hospitals are well prepared – each one has a tailored fire safety plan,” he said.

“But nothing is more important than the safety of patients and staff, so on a precautionary basis we have asked all hospitals to conduct additional checks.”

Across the wider government estate 15 buildings have been identified as requiring further investigation.

Latest news

Arora and Bechtel pitch rival Heathrow expansion plan

New Terminal 6 and runway said to be faster, greener and cheaper option
6 hours ago

Major delays hit £4.8bn Levelling Up project programme

Whitehall admits most projects still stuck in design or planning phase
5 hours ago

London new home starts slump 59% as safety regime bites

National rise masks capital’s fall amid BSR delays and social housing slowdown
4 hours ago

Maidstone seeks builder for £50m flats project

10-storey tower part of council’s Springfield Library redevelopment plans
5 hours ago

Former Lambeth council office to become Premier Inn

Developer Whitbread looking for contractor for latest conversion project
4 hours ago

Construction to start on UK’s first floating padel courts

Liverpool Waters gets green light for unique leisure complex
5 hours ago

Bombshell cavity barrier defects wipe out Taylor Wimpey profits

Fresh £222m provision for fire safety failings behind brick facades
1 day ago

39 firms win £3bn South East schools framework

LCP panel covers new build, retrofit and fire safety upgrade work
2 days ago

Esh boss bullish as profits and prospects rise

North of England contractor looking forward to continued growth
2 days ago

Government sets up Platform4 to build 40,000 homes on rail land

Former Lendlease Development chief Bek Seeley to head Platform4
1 day ago

Race starts for £858m London highways consultancy deal

Ealing Council is leading the launch of a major new highways and transport consultancy framework
1 day ago

Bridge parts set sail for £20m Murphy Stockport site

"Dress rehearsal" bridge assembly ahead of three week rail closure
1 day ago

22 firms win Prosper £500m new build homes framework

Deal designed with input from Believe Housing, Gentoo and Karbon Homes
2 days ago

Civils contractor Galldris sold to staff

£125m turnover firm transitions to Employee Ownership Trust
2 days ago

Fit-out firepower drives Morgan Sindall to record half-year

£390m cash pile supports push on partnerships and frameworks
2 days ago

Grid delays now rival planning as chief threat to project delivery

Turner & Townsend flags urgent need to prioritise electricity connections on projects
2 days ago

Forterra to shut down two divisions

Materials giant exiting Formpave block paving and Bison Bespoke precast businesses
2 days ago

Vistry and Kier team up again for Wokingham homes plan

Third major partnership kicks off first phase of 1,400-home Berkshire plan
3 days ago

Wates preps £200m Middlesbrough regen site

Work begins on landmark Crown Square project with hotel, student flats and homes
3 days ago

BAM Nuttall rail boss to join Balfour

Richard Watts to become Managing Director of UK Rail business
6 days ago

Peel Ports unveils £60m expansion plan for Yarmouth

New Southern Terminal to target big infrastructure and offshore energy schemes
3 days ago

£1bn beach defence mega-framework up for grabs

Environment Agency seeks two marine contractors to protect England’s coastlines
3 days ago

Bovis set for £220m tower job near British Museum

John F Hunt to start demolition work for big West End scheme
3 days ago

Carnell poaches another National Highways director

Maintenance contractor becomes latest private firm to lure public sector chief
3 days ago

Plans go in for Warrington logistics site revamp

Outdated units to be replaced at Hawleys Lane
3 days ago

Morgan Sindall site closed after fatal accident

Tragedy at £90m Mill Yard job in Cambridge
6 days ago

DfE signs off £148m school rebuild trio

B+K and Bouygues land major academy projects across England
6 days ago

Contract race starts for £205m A9 dualling job

Latest deal involves building or upgrading nine bridges
6 days ago

Higgins to turn former care home site into council houses

Construction to start early next year on Buckinghamshire scheme
6 days ago

Green light for £1.7bn Edgware town centre revamp

Ballymore to deliver 3,365 new homes
7 days ago