Second cladding system gets fire test ‘all clear’

Aaron Morby 8 years ago
Share

The first cladding system using PIR solid foam insulation has passed the Government’s stringent fire tests in the wake of London’s Grenfell disaster.

Aluminium cladding using a limited combustibility filler (A2) and PIR foam insulation boards passes BRE large-scale fire test
Aluminium cladding using a limited combustibility filler (A2) and PIR foam insulation boards passes BRE large-scale fire test

It is the second cladding system to pass the large-scale fire test giving the industry a clear insight into which systems meet Building Regulation performance guidance.

The latest test results now suggest that PIR insulation can be fitted to a high-rise building, but only when used with aluminium composite material cladding using a ‘limited combustibility’ (stone) filler.

So far no high-rise buildings have been registered with the Government as having this particular combination of materials.

The Government’s testing body is carrying out a total of seven tests incorporating each of the three common types of aluminium cladding material panel, using either core filler materials of unmodified polyethylene (PE), fire retardant polyethylene (FR), or limited combustibility mineral (A2).

These are being tested in combination with two insulation materials – rigid polyisocyanurate (PIR) foam or non-combustible stone wool. The seventh test, recently added to the testing programme, will examine the performance of commonly-used phenolic foam board with ACM with a fire resistant filler (A2).

Designers and contractors will be eagerly awaiting this result, in particular.

With just one other test result due in for what is the least combustible combination of elements a picture is now emerging of which cladding systems meet the Building Regulations.

Cladding system tests Result 18m-plus buildings
ACM with unmodified polyethylene filler with PIR foam insulation Failed 82
ACM with unmodified polyethylene filler (PE) with mineral wool insulation Failed 111
ACM with a fire retardant polyethylene filler (PE) with PIR foam insulation Failed 13
ACM with fire retardant polyethylene filler (FR) with mineral insulation Passed 13
ACM with a limited combustibility filler (FR) with phenolic foam insulation Not published N/A
ACM with a limited combustibility filler (A2) with PIR foam insulation Passed 0
ACM with a limited combustibility filler (A2) with mineral wool insulation Not published N/A

 

Findings so far suggest that at least 206 buildings over 18m in height that have been reported to the Government will need to be reclad.

Unmodified polyethylene filled ACM cladding, like that used on the Grenfell tower, fails Building Regulation requirements.

An aluminium cladding system using fire retardent polyethylene filler (FR) could be used, but only when installed in conjunction with mineral wool insulation and not PIR foam board.

ACM cladding using limited combustibility filler (A2) can be used with PIR foam insulation boards.

A cladding industry source said: “These results must be welcomed because they bring some clarity to what systems comply with Building Regulation requirements.

“But the use of the terminology used by manufacturers around combustibility of fillers used in aluminium cladding needs to be addressed to end market confusion.”

Another added: “The importance of these tests are that we can finally move forward with confidence in the industry.

“What is disappointing is BRE’s obsession with ACM. They have to start carrying out the same testing on other products, high pressure laminate, for example.”

Even with the latest test information the Government still advises that building owners need to continue to take professional advice regarding remedial work that takes into account the specific circumstances of their building.

The way materials have been fitted and maintained can also affect the safety of the cladding system.

Last month the government announced an independent review of building regulations and fire safety, focussed on the regulatory system around the design, construction and on-going management as well as related compliance and enforcement issues.

Latest news

Retentions could be banned in late payment crackdown

Government considers abolition of hated system in construction
2 days ago

Heathrow Airport unveils £49bn ‘superhub’ expansion

Airport operator says it is ready to start design and supply chain activity this year
1 day ago

National Grid names contractors for £8bn of substation work

Regional deals will give firms first refusal on work in their area
1 day ago

Keltbray names Ferrovial’s Karl Goose as new CEO

New boss to take over in December as Vince Corrigan retires
1 day ago

Green light for first 880 homes at Manchester Mayfield

Four blocks rising to 28 storeys set to cost around £250m to build
1 day ago

Fit-out trade body hits back at bloated contracts

Dry walling and interiors body backs 500-word contract in fight against legal traps
1 day ago

Arora and Bechtel pitch rival Heathrow expansion plan

New Terminal 6 and runway said to be faster, greener and cheaper option
2 days ago

Major delays hit £4.8bn Levelling Up project programme

Whitehall admits most projects still stuck in design or planning phase
2 days ago

London new home starts slump 59% as safety regime bites

National rise masks capital’s fall amid BSR delays and social housing slowdown
2 days ago

Maidstone seeks builder for £50m flats project

10-storey tower part of council’s Springfield Library redevelopment plans
2 days ago

Former Lambeth council office to become Premier Inn

Developer Whitbread looking for contractor for latest conversion project
2 days ago

Construction to start on UK’s first floating padel courts

Liverpool Waters gets green light for unique leisure complex
2 days ago

Bombshell cavity barrier defects wipe out Taylor Wimpey profits

Fresh £222m provision for fire safety failings behind brick facades
3 days ago

39 firms win £3bn South East schools framework

LCP panel covers new build, retrofit and fire safety upgrade work
4 days ago

Esh boss bullish as profits and prospects rise

North of England contractor looking forward to continued growth
4 days ago

Government sets up Platform4 to build 40,000 homes on rail land

Former Lendlease Development chief Bek Seeley to head Platform4
3 days ago

Race starts for £858m London highways consultancy deal

Ealing Council is leading the launch of a major new highways and transport consultancy framework
3 days ago

Bridge parts set sail for £20m Murphy Stockport site

"Dress rehearsal" bridge assembly ahead of three week rail closure
3 days ago

22 firms win Prosper £500m new build homes framework

Deal designed with input from Believe Housing, Gentoo and Karbon Homes
4 days ago

Civils contractor Galldris sold to staff

£125m turnover firm transitions to Employee Ownership Trust
4 days ago

Fit-out firepower drives Morgan Sindall to record half-year

£390m cash pile supports push on partnerships and frameworks
4 days ago

Grid delays now rival planning as chief threat to project delivery

Turner & Townsend flags urgent need to prioritise electricity connections on projects
4 days ago

Forterra to shut down two divisions

Materials giant exiting Formpave block paving and Bison Bespoke precast businesses
4 days ago

Vistry and Kier team up again for Wokingham homes plan

Third major partnership kicks off first phase of 1,400-home Berkshire plan
5 days ago

Wates preps £200m Middlesbrough regen site

Work begins on landmark Crown Square project with hotel, student flats and homes
5 days ago

BAM Nuttall rail boss to join Balfour

Richard Watts to become Managing Director of UK Rail business
1 week ago

Peel Ports unveils £60m expansion plan for Yarmouth

New Southern Terminal to target big infrastructure and offshore energy schemes
5 days ago

£1bn beach defence mega-framework up for grabs

Environment Agency seeks two marine contractors to protect England’s coastlines
5 days ago

Bovis set for £220m tower job near British Museum

John F Hunt to start demolition work for big West End scheme
5 days ago

Carnell poaches another National Highways director

Maintenance contractor becomes latest private firm to lure public sector chief
5 days ago