Emails reveal key Grenfell firms knew cladding would fail in blaze

Aaron Morby 6 years ago
Share

Emails revealed in the second day of evidence to the Grenfell Inquiry suggest that architect Studio E, contractor Rydon, facade subcontractor Harley and fire consultant Exova knew cladding panels would fail in the event of an external fire.

Emails reveal fire consultant, architect, main contractor and facade contractor new cladding would fail in external fire
Emails reveal fire consultant, architect, main contractor and facade contractor new cladding would fail in external fire

Insulation manufacturer Celotex – which itself has been accused of producing misleading market information about product performance – revealed a crucial email exchange regarding the use of fire stopping.

In emails between staff at the firms, a technical manager at Harley said: “there is no point in ‘fire stopping’, as we all know; the ACM will be gone rather quickly in a fire!”

In another email fire consultant Exova, accepted the zinc cladding being considered at the time would fail if there were external flames.

In response, an architect at Studio E said that “metal cladding always burns and falls off”.

In its evidence Celotex said: “None of the individuals involved in the March 2015 email exchange have sought to explain how their knowledge that the cladding would fail in the event of a fire with external flaming can be reconciled with their responsibility as designers, contractors or consultants to ensure, or exercise reasonable care to ensure, that the rainscreen cladding system on Grenfell Tower complied” with building regulations relating to the spread of fire.

The inquiry heard that there was no indication that any of those involved contemplated requesting a full-scale test of the proposed system.

Evidence from fire consultant Exova revealed that the Grenfell Tower was originally expected to be clad in zinc.

But value engineering led to the use of cheaper ACM cladding saving £454,000, according to a Harley estimate.

It said that when Rydon was appointed, it was on the basis of employer’s requirements which specified zinc cladding with an aluminium honeycomb core; and contemplated that alternative materials might be used but must comply with prevailing fire regulations.

“It was only later that – evidently guided by the pressure to cut costs – Rydon (together with Studio E and Artelia, and with support from Harley) pursued, and obtained client KCTMO’s approval for the change to ACM,” said Exova.

The fire consultant added that it was only then that work on designing the cladding system commenced, under a team that comprised Rydon, Studio E, and Harley.

The inquiry continues today with cladding manufacturer Arconic providing its opening statement.

Latest news

Retentions could be banned in late payment crackdown

Government considers abolition of hated system in construction
2 days ago

Heathrow Airport unveils £49bn ‘superhub’ expansion

Airport operator says it is ready to start design and supply chain activity this year
1 day ago

National Grid names contractors for £8bn of substation work

Regional deals will give firms first refusal on work in their area
2 days ago

Keltbray names Ferrovial’s Karl Goose as new CEO

New boss to take over in December as Vince Corrigan retires
1 day ago

Green light for first 880 homes at Manchester Mayfield

Four blocks rising to 28 storeys set to cost around £250m to build
2 days ago

Fit-out trade body hits back at bloated contracts

Dry walling and interiors body backs 500-word contract in fight against legal traps
2 days ago

Arora and Bechtel pitch rival Heathrow expansion plan

New Terminal 6 and runway said to be faster, greener and cheaper option
3 days ago

Major delays hit £4.8bn Levelling Up project programme

Whitehall admits most projects still stuck in design or planning phase
3 days ago

London new home starts slump 59% as safety regime bites

National rise masks capital’s fall amid BSR delays and social housing slowdown
2 days ago

Maidstone seeks builder for £50m flats project

10-storey tower part of council’s Springfield Library redevelopment plans
3 days ago

Former Lambeth council office to become Premier Inn

Developer Whitbread looking for contractor for latest conversion project
3 days ago

Construction to start on UK’s first floating padel courts

Liverpool Waters gets green light for unique leisure complex
3 days ago

Bombshell cavity barrier defects wipe out Taylor Wimpey profits

Fresh £222m provision for fire safety failings behind brick facades
4 days ago

39 firms win £3bn South East schools framework

LCP panel covers new build, retrofit and fire safety upgrade work
4 days ago

Esh boss bullish as profits and prospects rise

North of England contractor looking forward to continued growth
4 days ago

Government sets up Platform4 to build 40,000 homes on rail land

Former Lendlease Development chief Bek Seeley to head Platform4
4 days ago

Race starts for £858m London highways consultancy deal

Ealing Council is leading the launch of a major new highways and transport consultancy framework
4 days ago

Bridge parts set sail for £20m Murphy Stockport site

"Dress rehearsal" bridge assembly ahead of three week rail closure
4 days ago

22 firms win Prosper £500m new build homes framework

Deal designed with input from Believe Housing, Gentoo and Karbon Homes
4 days ago

Civils contractor Galldris sold to staff

£125m turnover firm transitions to Employee Ownership Trust
5 days ago

Fit-out firepower drives Morgan Sindall to record half-year

£390m cash pile supports push on partnerships and frameworks
4 days ago

Grid delays now rival planning as chief threat to project delivery

Turner & Townsend flags urgent need to prioritise electricity connections on projects
5 days ago

Forterra to shut down two divisions

Materials giant exiting Formpave block paving and Bison Bespoke precast businesses
5 days ago

Vistry and Kier team up again for Wokingham homes plan

Third major partnership kicks off first phase of 1,400-home Berkshire plan
5 days ago

Wates preps £200m Middlesbrough regen site

Work begins on landmark Crown Square project with hotel, student flats and homes
6 days ago

BAM Nuttall rail boss to join Balfour

Richard Watts to become Managing Director of UK Rail business
1 week ago

Peel Ports unveils £60m expansion plan for Yarmouth

New Southern Terminal to target big infrastructure and offshore energy schemes
5 days ago

£1bn beach defence mega-framework up for grabs

Environment Agency seeks two marine contractors to protect England’s coastlines
6 days ago

Bovis set for £220m tower job near British Museum

John F Hunt to start demolition work for big West End scheme
6 days ago

Carnell poaches another National Highways director

Maintenance contractor becomes latest private firm to lure public sector chief
5 days ago