Client sues design team after Costain project cost nearly doubled

Aaron Morby 3 years ago
Share

Developer Standard Life is suing some of its professional design team on the Newbury Parkway shopping centre and flats scheme after the cost of the project soared from around £77m to £146m.

Newbury Parkway project was completed over six years ago but a legal battle of cost overruns is rumbling on through the courts
Newbury Parkway project was completed over six years ago but a legal battle of cost overruns is rumbling on through the courts

The firm is now locked in a legal battle with its design team – Building Design Partnership, Sutton Griffin Architects, and Cundall – claiming £38m for alleged professional negligence.

Main contractor Costain completed the project back in June 2013 and concluded a final settlement agreement, whereby it agreed to assist Standard Life with any dispute against third parties relating to contract administrators instructions and confirmation of verbal instructions.

Standard Life claims that £50m of the final settlement was made up of £28m from variations to the building contract and nearly £22m from contractor’s loss and expense from delay and disruption.

Project manager Buro Four analysed in detail a sample of over 100 CVIs and CAIs for Standard Life, which represented £14.6m of the extra cost.

Of these, it assessed 49% had arisen because of a “design team issue”, 10% from a “client issue” and 41% were “unclassified”.

This analysis has been used by Standard Life to extrapolate the final claim, which has just been contested by the design firms in the high court before moving to the full case being heard.

The members of the design team, which deny allegations against them, argued that they objected to the full claim going to trial because it was based on the extrapolated £25m variations claim and loss and expense claim.

To avoid lengthy assessment of each of the CVIs and CAIs through the court, Justice Kerr has ruled that Standard Life should select which of the 3,604 individual variations and 280 delay notices it wants to submit to support a fresh claim involving a trial by samples.

BDP will be allowed to selected 80 of these variations, SGA up to 40 others and Cundall 40. Standard Life would be required to set out its case against these.

A similar sample procedure should be used for the client’s loss and expense claim, ruled Justice Kerr.

Judge Kerr accepted that the procedure to reassess the claim may delay the trial date but added: “I think the delay resulting from the current exercise is a price worth paying for enabling the case to be managed properly”

Latest news

Construction buyers see fastest growth for 14 months

Commercial building work leads the way in April
9 hours ago

Go Modular Technologies files administration notice

Southampton bespoke volumetric specialist employs around 60 staff
12 hours ago

Cladding firm went down owing supply chain £7.7m

Debts revealed at Everton stadium cladding contractor Alucraft Systems Ltd
13 hours ago

Rydon dogged by legacy fire safety remediation costs

£19m spent on fire safety remediation work to date
13 hours ago

Carpenter killed by falling timber frame panels

Court fines specialist contractor £8,000 after site tragedy
4 days ago

Trio of builders win King’s Award for sustainability

Henry Brothers, Willmott Dixon and ZED Pods recognised for sustainability
12 hours ago

Kent police seize huge haul of stolen site tools

Hunt for power drill fitted with tracker busts tool theft ring
12 hours ago

Robertson names new Northern construction chiefs

Ian Phillips promoted and Ricky Brown joins from Morgan Sindall
13 hours ago

Road sweeper specialist files administration notice

Go Plant lodges court notice
5 days ago

Anglian Homes rides in to finish crashed Everest contracts

Rival doubled glazed window specialist commits to complete orders
4 days ago

Final work starts to connect super sewer to London system

End in sight with 1.5m thick concrete wall to be demolished to link-up to Lee Tunnel sewer system
5 days ago

Legal challenge launched against £1.5bn A66 dualling

Balfour Beatty, Kier and Keltbray must now await outcome of court challenge
5 days ago

John F Hunt wins 24-storey Battersea tower

Specialist to carry-out demolition, enabling works and RC frame construction
5 days ago

William Hare wins steelwork on £500m Broadgate towers

Specialist to work on 2 Finsbury Avenue with McAlpine
5 days ago

McAlpine appoints MD to grow ventures business

Owain Thomas will build on private rental and healthcare development successes
5 days ago

BAM Co-op Live Arena opening delayed yet again

Another gig cancelled last night amid last minute safety concerns
5 days ago

National Grid unveils winners for £9bn network upgrade

New 'enterprise model' to deliver infrastructure schemes quicker and cheaper
6 days ago

Turkish insulation panel maker to build £45m UK factory

Assan Panel to open first UK plant at Freeport East
6 days ago

Expanding consultant Stantec swoops for Hydrock

Stantec UK business expands by a third as 950 staff join from Bristol-based engineer
6 days ago

Contractors wanted for £800m highways deal

Bids invited for Eastern Highways Alliance Framework 4
5 days ago

Galliford Try names group head of infrastructure

David Lowery promoted to Divisional Managing Director – Infrastructure.
6 days ago

Chigwell Group looks at stock market listing

Essex contractor registers as Public Limited Company
7 days ago

A57 Mottram Bypass clears final legal challenge

Balfour Beatty to get go-ahead to start shortly
7 days ago

100 jobs axed as Geoffrey Osborne confirms administration

Chairman Andrew Osborne calls it a 'sad day' as board loses fight for survival
1 week ago

Midgard set for Notting Hill office tower overhaul

Landmark project edges towards final approval after 10-year planning saga
7 days ago

Cumbrian civils firm clinches £40m Sellafield contract

Civils specialist Stobbarts will support McAlpine on groundworks and concrete
6 days ago

Designers named for London 2000-bed student rooms job

Bouygues will build £400m London School of Economics student scheme next to Tate Modern
6 days ago

£117m-turnover contractor files administration notice

ARJ Construction lodges court notice
1 week ago

£1bn London Blackfriars tower blocks approved

Trio of buildings rising to 45, 40 and 22 storeys approved by Southwark Council
1 week ago

Council decides to end Balfour deal after 13 years

Contractor has been maintaining roads across Herefordshire since 2013
1 week ago

Contractor services