Barnes family loses fight for £1.8m over bus station job

Aaron Morby 3 years ago
Share

The family owners of former Bury-based building contractor Thomas Barnes & Sons have lost their fight for compensation from the local council over the Blackburn bus exchange project.

Thomas Barnes administrator Begbies Traynor, backed by the family who are secured creditors, went to court claiming £1.8m from client Blackburn with Darwen Borough Council.

The building firm, which turned over more than £15m, was kicked off the Blackburn bus exchange project in June 2015 mid-way through construction over lack of progress on the complex job.

The administrators claim that failure by the council to make interim payments and the wrongful termination of the contract caused Thomas Barnes to collapse later in 2015.

According to the court papers, directors at Thomas Barnes at the time strongly believed that the problems which led to it being removed from the project were, in very large part, a consequence of failings of Capita, which had been hired by the council to provide a full design and project administration service on the project.

They said: “The claimant’s case is that those within the defendant and Capita who were responsible for this project were very keen to pin the blame for the serious time and cost overruns on the project on someone else and that the defendant’s decision to terminate was both led by Capita and politically motivated to put the blame on the claimant.”

All of this was strongly disputed by the defendant, said Judge Stephen Davies.

The council also argued it was entitled to terminate the contract and was entitled to a counter-claimed £1.9m for the cost of the extra work to complete the bus station.

Judge Stephen Davies accepted that Barnes was entitled to an extension of time which was greater than that allowed for by its client.

But he added that since the end of February 2015 the works had been plagued by delays which were almost entirely Barnes’ own fault and contractual responsibility.

He said any delay related-damages for Barnes fell short of the claim relating to damages arising from the council’s right to terminate the contract under provisions for delay-related breaches.

In a written judgement he said: “It follows that the claimant has no prospect of recovering anything in this litigation, since any entitlement it may establish under a final account analysis would be more than extinguished by the defendant’s right to recover and to set off against such entitlement the net cost of having the contract completed by replacement contractors.”

Latest news

Civils winners revealed for £12bn National Grid high voltage work

Contractor wins complete £59bn investment programme
11 hours ago

United Living quits new-build housing as costs mount

£136m-turnover housing arm to wind down as focus shifts to core infrastructure
14 hours ago

Fight looms for £3bn West Midlands building framework

Galliford Try, Morgan Sindall and others face fight to keep CWM seats
14 hours ago

Industry anger over sudden CITB funding changes

Smaller contractors lose funding route worth £10,000 a year
14 hours ago

Plans in to transform former GSK London HQ with 2,300 homes

Landmark 13-acre scheme set to transform Brentford Great West Road campus
13 hours ago

Watch Murphy near completion of major new rail bridge

Latest video reveals progress on Greek Street bridge during 21-day train suspension
14 hours ago

Mount Anvil’s in-house builder drives results in testing market

Group development pipeline holds steady at 3,384 homes despite dip in profit
15 hours ago

Costain margin heads for 4.5% after half-year profit rise

Roads and HS2 rephasing hit transport revenues but £5.6bn forward book to support growth
2 days ago

Hinkley contractors face prosecution over rebar mesh fall

Bouygues and Laing O'Rourke face action brought by the Office for Nuclear Regulation
2 days ago

Farrans to build new £59m Paisley bridge

Work to start soon on transport project for Renfrewshire Council
2 days ago

Crown Estate hires Olympics village veteran to lead delivery push

John Nicholson to oversee £16bn portfolio’s major UK development pipeline.
2 days ago

Henry Boot gets green light for 2,500 new homes

Hallam Land division sees signs planning system is speeding-up
2 days ago

Wates inks £100m deal on first new-design prison houseblocks

HMP Onley expansion leads roll-out of new standardised design
3 days ago

£122m deal to unlock Newcastle’s last brownfield site

Land remediation funding paves way for 2,500-home Forth Yards neighbourhood
3 days ago

McLaren lands Heathrow logistics deal

1.6 hectare airport site to be transformed into modern warehouses
3 days ago

McAlpine veteran to lead T&T’s project management drive

Former Olympic Stadium lead Mike O’Donnell takes lead role with focus on major capital project delivery
3 days ago

IES snaps up Nexus Power out of administration

Utilities group strengthens expertise in 400kV jointing and offshore markets
3 days ago

Thames Water tenders £120m water main rehab deal

Company seeks 2–5 contractors for London and South East renewal works
3 days ago

Lower Thames Crossing to lead green planning reforms

New system to avoid another £100m HS2 bat tunnel
3 days ago

Mace lands latest 30-storey City of London tower

85 Gracechurch Street near Leadenhall Market to be transformed
4 days ago

Vinci gets go-ahead for £250m Stockport 8 scheme

Contractor to start first phase of 435 net zero homes next year
4 days ago

£80m bid race to convert Oxford Debenhams into labs

Crown Estate advance plan to convert former six storey department store
4 days ago

Bennett steps-in to finish Guinness Covent Garden brewery

Original fit-out contractor Beck Interiors fell into administration
4 days ago

Work-to-rule set to hit Sellafield clean-up

Action by 1,500 construction workers across 34 contractors
4 days ago

Aureos breaks ground on £45m Howden Relief Road

Yorkshire road will pave way for 2,000-home scheme
4 days ago

Oxford United win green light for £150m all-electric stadium

Planners back 16,000-seat Kidlington ground with hotel, plaza and community hub
7 days ago

Demolition record as eight cooling towers come down

Watch Brown & Mason set record at Cottam Power Station
1 week ago

Hitachi Energy named for EGL3 converter station deal

Firm to build major HVDC converter stations in Aberdeenshire and West Norfolk
7 days ago

PAS NW secures landmark £20m civils deal in Lancashire

Groundworks firm wins infrastructure for 429-home Wain Homes scheme
7 days ago

Subcontractors wanted for jobs across the South West

Register now for latest Constructionline event in Bristol
7 days ago