Barnes family loses fight for £1.8m over bus station job

Aaron Morby 2 years ago
Share

The family owners of former Bury-based building contractor Thomas Barnes & Sons have lost their fight for compensation from the local council over the Blackburn bus exchange project.

Thomas Barnes administrator Begbies Traynor, backed by the family who are secured creditors, went to court claiming £1.8m from client Blackburn with Darwen Borough Council.

The building firm, which turned over more than £15m, was kicked off the Blackburn bus exchange project in June 2015 mid-way through construction over lack of progress on the complex job.

The administrators claim that failure by the council to make interim payments and the wrongful termination of the contract caused Thomas Barnes to collapse later in 2015.

According to the court papers, directors at Thomas Barnes at the time strongly believed that the problems which led to it being removed from the project were, in very large part, a consequence of failings of Capita, which had been hired by the council to provide a full design and project administration service on the project.

They said: “The claimant’s case is that those within the defendant and Capita who were responsible for this project were very keen to pin the blame for the serious time and cost overruns on the project on someone else and that the defendant’s decision to terminate was both led by Capita and politically motivated to put the blame on the claimant.”

All of this was strongly disputed by the defendant, said Judge Stephen Davies.

The council also argued it was entitled to terminate the contract and was entitled to a counter-claimed £1.9m for the cost of the extra work to complete the bus station.

Judge Stephen Davies accepted that Barnes was entitled to an extension of time which was greater than that allowed for by its client.

But he added that since the end of February 2015 the works had been plagued by delays which were almost entirely Barnes’ own fault and contractual responsibility.

He said any delay related-damages for Barnes fell short of the claim relating to damages arising from the council’s right to terminate the contract under provisions for delay-related breaches.

In a written judgement he said: “It follows that the claimant has no prospect of recovering anything in this litigation, since any entitlement it may establish under a final account analysis would be more than extinguished by the defendant’s right to recover and to set off against such entitlement the net cost of having the contract completed by replacement contractors.”

Latest news

Expanding consultant Stantec swoops for Hydrock

Stantec UK business expands by a third as 950 staff join from Bristol-based engineer
10 hours ago

National Grid unveils winners for £9bn network upgrade

New 'enterprise model' to deliver infrastructure schemes quicker and cheaper
11 hours ago

Chigwell Group looks at stock market listing

Essex contractor registers as Public Limited Company
18 hours ago

A57 Mottram Bypass clears final legal challenge

Balfour Beatty to get go-ahead to start shortly
18 hours ago

100 jobs axed as Geoffrey Osborne confirms administration

Chairman Andrew Osborne calls it a 'sad day' as board loses fight for survival
1 day ago

Midgard set for Notting Hill office tower overhaul

Landmark project edges towards final approval after 10-year planning saga
18 hours ago

Cumbrian civils firm clinches £40m Sellafield contract

Civils specialist Stobbarts will support McAlpine on groundworks and concrete
17 hours ago

Designers named for London 2000-bed student rooms job

Bouygues will build £400m London School of Economics student scheme next to Tate Modern
17 hours ago

£117m-turnover contractor files administration notice

ARJ Construction lodges court notice
2 days ago

£1bn London Blackfriars tower blocks approved

Trio of buildings rising to 45, 40 and 22 storeys approved by Southwark Council
2 days ago

Council decides to end Balfour deal after 13 years

Contractor has been maintaining roads across Herefordshire since 2013
2 days ago

Six civils clients to switch to low carbon concrete and steel

National Highways, Northumbrian Water and Sellafield sign fresh decarbonising pledge
2 days ago

Fortem extends homes repair deal across Birmingham

Willmott Dixon owned firm adds another two years to deal worth £170m
2 days ago

Kier wins £118m civil service Darlington hub

Work is expected to start towards the end of this year
3 days ago

Green light for 34-storey Digbeth apartments tower

480 flats will be delivered for Clarion housing association
2 days ago

LHC starts race for major retrofit and decarb framework

Hunt starts for firms to help with 6.1m social homes upgrade target
3 days ago

Windows giant Everest crashes into administration

Around 350 jobs at risk while hunt starts for a buyer to salvage business
3 days ago

Green light for £500m Newcastle health complex

Mixed use scheme will promote healthy living across all stages of life
3 days ago

Olympian Homes gets go-ahead for Bristol’s tallest building

Work on student and co-living towers to start this summer
3 days ago

ISG gets nod to start £20m Glamorgan school job

Ysgol y Deri specialist needs school is to built at Cosmeston, near Penarth
3 days ago

Walker Modular lands £5m bathroom pod contract

Specialist to work with Graham and Watkin Jones on major build-to-rent scheme

Banned building boss jailed for fraud

Court hears how disqualified director siphoned off cash from new housing company
3 days ago

Osborne staff start looking for new jobs

"Open to Work" flags appear on LinkedIn profiles
6 days ago

Plan rejected for 42-storey tower above historic building

Councillor describes as ludicrous plan to build 300 flats above Georgian mansion
6 days ago

Ventilation deal could hike product prices for contractors

Watchdogs at CMA launch probe after duct firm acquires rival
6 days ago

Tide gets go-ahead for London 412 student flats scheme

Volumetric developer secures planning for West Ealing project
6 days ago

Green light for £75m Friar Gate Goods Yard in Derby

Construction set to start this summer on revamp of historic buildings
6 days ago

Robertson to deliver £45m Newcastle NHS Trust works

Capital works will be focused on Freeman Hospital and the Royal Victoria Infirmary sites
6 days ago

Winners named for £2bn Healthy Homes framework

CHIC reveals line-up of over 40 firms for net zero and building safety works
6 days ago

Plan lodged for tallest skyscraper outside London

Developer Salboy submits plan for 76-storey Manchester resi tower
7 days ago

Contractor services