Watchdog MPs raise alarm over HS2 Euston station plan

Aaron Morby 4 months ago
Share

MPs on the Public Accounts Committee have lambasted the management of the HS2 project and raised grave concerns about the latest plan to deliver the Euston terminus in London.

Grand plans for Euston, but PAC questions when it will actually get built
Grand plans for Euston, but PAC questions when it will actually get built

Their report published today calls for “fundamental reset” of the project by the summer.

They warn that they remain sceptical about the Government’s ability to successfully deliver its revised programme following a litany of failures and unheeded warnings.

The report says that the HS2 programme has become a casebook example of how not to run a major project.

“It is unacceptable that over a decade into the programme we still do not know what it will cost, what the final scope will be, when it will finally be completed or what benefits it will deliver,” states their report.

Watchdog MPs also highlighted the significant challenges facing plans to build the Euston Station terminus using a third party development body.

As plans stand, HS2 will open with a terminus at Old Old Common. Despite plans to launch the TBM tunnel drive next year to Euston from Old Oak Common there are no detailed plans or timescale for delivering the Euston Terminus, warns the report.

The Government’s Euston plans currently rest on the £6bn cost being significantly underpinned by the private sector.

The PAC said it was concerned that there is no clear plan for this, and said it was sceptical the private sector would come forward to the level required.

The government confirmed that HS2 would terminate at London Euston in the Autumn 2024 budget.

However, the PAC warns the Department still does not yet have a plan for the work at Euston which includes: the HS2 station, the existing Network Rail station, the underground station, and the commercial and housing developments near the station.

“In addition, the Department intends the work to be sustantively privately funded, but it is unclear how achievable this goal is,” they warn.

Sir Geoffrey Clifton-Brown MP, Chair of the Committee, said: “Our Committee has not made recommendations in our report on delivering better outcomes for HS2’s future passengers.

“We are long past that point. It is time to deal with HS2 as what it is – a cautionary tale that should be studied by future Governments in how not to run a major project.

“We are sceptical of Government’s ability to successfully deliver even a curtailed scheme, one which we already know will on its face bring very poor value for money. The question has instead become: what possible benefit can the Government now salvage for the taxpayer, from a mess that presents real risks to the UK’s overall reputation?”

The Department for Transport’s present cost estimated set out in November 2023 is £45bn to £54bn compared with HS2 Ltd’s latest estimate of £54bn to £66bn in June 2024.

Both cost estimates are still in 2019 prices, once adjusted for inflation, the total programme costs might be close to £80bn, states the report.

 

Latest news

Mark Wild radical reset plan to rescue HS2

Senior manager bonuses scrapped and non-permanent labour cutback
2 hours ago

HS2 supply chain fraud claims spark ministerial probe

Transport secretary pledges one-year reset for HS2 to end 'litany of failures'
19 hours ago

Lords launch inquiry into Building Safety Regulator delays

Industry asked for evidence of how system is failing: Have your say
9 hours ago

Willmott Dixon director becomes co-owner of local contractor BSN

Nick Gibb targets £100m turnover at Dudley based national contractor
18 hours ago

Dry lining boss sentenced after mystery account moves

Court hears of £500,000 in unexplained transfers before contractor went under
1 hour ago

Barhale bags £16m shaft tank for Severn Trent Water

"Final piece in the puzzle" of Etruria Vale upgrade
28 minutes ago

Keltbray strikes £30m funding deal for growth

Three-year funding deal to support push into higher-margin work
1 day ago

Take That brother buys steelwork giant William Hare

Entrepreneur Simon Orange seals deal for £350m turnover contractor
2 days ago

Civils contractor LF Solutions files administration notice

£20m-turnover specialist has labour supply arm and own plant fleet
1 day ago

Joseph Gallagher lands £50m green energy deal

Major trenchless construction contract for HyNet North West project
1 day ago

New boss drives NG Bailey to record revenue

Fresh strategy lifts M&E group's order book to £1.6bn
1 day ago

Costain wins vast underground hydrogen storage design job

Firms lands FEED contract for Cheshire salt caverns conversion
1 day ago

Graham gets green light for £70m Glasgow student tower

Construction due to start this year on 25-storey Anderston scheme
1 day ago

New £16bn National Housing Bank to drive 500k new builds

Homes England given new powers to finance stalled and complex schemes
1 day ago

Morgan Sindall upgrades profits forecast for this year

Overbury fitout and construction operations exceed trading expectations
2 days ago

Major project bidders to face ‘British jobs’ test

Contractors to face tougher jobs pledge scrutiny under new procurement shake-up
3 days ago

Green light for £32m Wythenshawe Culture Hub

Construction to start this year on first phase of £500m town centre revamp
2 days ago

Hercules delivers record first half as HS2 fuels growth

Labour supply specialist says HS2 demand climbing with 630 workers now deployed
2 days ago

Private equity firm acquires Hepworth Clay pipes business

Historic UK drainage manufacturer sold by Wavin
2 days ago

Balfour Beatty names new Scottish MD

Nick Rowan to take reins as Hector MacAulay to retire after 40 years
3 days ago

£500m rail deal locks in future for Scunthorpe steelworks

Government-backed deal with Network Rail safeguards UK production
2 days ago

Morrison rides in for £19m mountain bike R&D hub

Flagship Borders cycling R&D hub set for Caerlee Mill site
3 days ago

Revised plan submitted for Manchester landmark towers

400 more flats added to Albert Bridge House scheme
3 days ago

Job losses loom at consultant GHD

Redundancy consultation underway with jobs at risk
3 days ago

Knight Harwood lifts margin to 4.9% as profit hits £6.5m

London specialist sees strong office and luxury resi pipeline
3 days ago

Hampshire launches £150m minor works reboot

General builders, M&E and roofing firms invited to apply
3 days ago

Winners named for £2.6bn NHS SBS Modular 3 framework

Twenty-seven secure spots on health, education and resi framework
6 days ago

Leeds kicks off homes vision for Elland Road regeneration

Council plans to deliver 2,000 homes around United’s revamped stadium
6 days ago

Former Mace deputy chairman Mark Holmes awarded CBE

King's Birthday Honours spotlights industry's architecture and environment achievements
3 days ago

Britcon targets £70m turnover after string of framework wins

Major AMP8 win and regional expansion fuel contractor’s biggest growth push yet
6 days ago

Contractor services