Client jail threat over trench collapse death fine

Grant Prior 12 years ago
Share

The director of a Hertfordshire contractor and the co-owners of a south London property undergoing conversion have been sentenced for safety failings after a worker was killed in a trench collapse.

Xian Hou Ye, 56, was crushed and suffocated by nearly nine tonnes of soil in the fatal incident at Waldram Park Road, Lewisham, on 30 September 2010.

Woolwich Crown Court heard that he was one of a group of workers contracted by Croxley Green-based HMB Services Ltd and company director Vijay Patel to convert an existing three-storey property into nine flats.

The property was co-owned by brothers Mukesh Shah and Kiran Shah, also from Hertfordshire, who appointed HMB Services and Patel as the principal contractor to oversee the project.

As part of the works, a large trench had been dug out that was approximately seven metres long, between one to two metres wide and almost three metres deep. This was being extended at one end at a 90-degree angle to form an L-shape.

A digger was helping to shape the extension whilst Ye was working in the deeper existing section.

As work progressed, the inside corner of the L-shape caved in and buried him under approximately 8.7 tonnes of earth.

He died at the scene despite frantic efforts to dig him out.

The Health and Safety Executive found the trench was inadequately supported with sheets of plywood and timber props.

More substantial supports or using a safer method of trench construction, known as battering, should have been used.

This was a failing on behalf of both HMB Services and Patel, who were responsible for the work, and clients Mukesh and Kiran Shah, who should have ensured their principal contractor was competent to carry out the project.

Mukesh Shah and Kiran Shah, both of Pindar Road, Hoddesdon, Herts, were each found guilty of two separate safety breaches.

Mukesh was fined £40,000 with costs of £34,750. Kiran was fined £25,000 and was also ordered to pay £34,750 in costs.

The brothers were told they would be jailed if they failed to make the necessary payments.

Vijay Patel, of Croxley Green, Herts, was ordered to undertake 270 hours of community work after pleading guilty to a single safety breach. The court ruled he had no means to pay a fine or contribute towards costs.

HMB Services Ltd, of the same address, is now dissolved so the company avoided prosecution.

After sentencing HSE Principal Inspector Russell Adfield said: “Mukesh and Kiran Shah were having this conversion undertaken as part of a business venture and they were therefore ‘clients’ in this project.

“A client has a very major influence over how a construction project is run as they have responsibility for appointing competent advisors – principal contractors – and ensuring that arrangements are in place for carrying out the project safely.

“The clients in this case failed on all fronts.

“They had no advisors to help them understand what was required of them, the principal contractor they appointed was not competent to manage this work safely and there were no formal arrangements in place to ensure the safety of those workers on site.

“It appeared neither the clients nor principal contractor had any understanding of the very real risks on that site – or how to ensure those risks were controlled.”

Latest news

Council terminates Spencer bridge repair contract

Delays have hit restoration of Grimsby’s historic Corporation Road Bridge
37 minutes ago

Westminster gears up for £500m housing repairs deal

Council eyes multiple strategic alliances for major housing overhaul
5 hours ago

Henry Boot sets October start on £1bn cyber hub next to GCHQ

160,000 sq ft IDEA office building starts 10-year build plan
6 hours ago

Cementation Skanska names new operations director

Emma Haddow now heads up UK-wide ground engineering services
6 hours ago

Forterra fires-up kilns as house building demand returns

Materials giant boosts production of bricks and concrete floor beams
6 hours ago

Plans in for £100m Church Wharf regeneration in Bolton

Developer Watson submits plan for over 400 homes and 130-bed hotel
5 hours ago

McAvoy on the hunt for new subcontractors

Meet the Buyer event in Manchester next month: Register now
6 hours ago

Ex-Lendlease boss seals £24bn Crown Estate mega sites JV

Crown Estate/Lendlease alliance to build out at Euston, Silvertown and Thamesmead sites
1 day ago

Brookfield gets green light for latest City office scheme

Retrofit-first approach will retain 70% of the original structure at 1 Moor Lane
22 hours ago

Knauf commits £170m to build Deeside insulation plant

Work to start next year at former Shotton steelworks site
1 day ago

Construction trade bodies vote to keep training levy

CITB gets green light to collect contractor's cash for another three years
1 day ago

McLaren to build 2,400-bed worker campus at Sizewell C

Worker camp to raise the bar on site accommodation standards
1 day ago

Soaring costs and work drought sunk historic scaffolding firm

Rodells had been in business since 1898
1 day ago

Clarion set to tender £79m Kirkstall Road Phase 2

Bidding to start for Dyecoats blocks 1 and 3 after Graham bagged phase 1
1 day ago

TfL seeks firms for £700m civils and station framework

Works include £80m South Kensington and £60m Elephant & Castle station upgrades
1 day ago

Early market talks on £2.5bn Yorkshire mass transit plan

Supplier talks open for West Yorkshire’s biggest ever transport scheme
1 day ago

Robertson starts Redcar town centre revamp

Culture and Leisure Anchor Attraction will enhance Redcar’s Esplanade
1 day ago

Alun Griffiths set to rescue firm he sold for £36m

Tarmac to hand back Welsh civils contractor after five years of losses
4 days ago

Landsec to pump £2bn into new house building drive

Developer to build 6,000 homes as it sells offices to fund new schemes
4 days ago

Severfield to start steel on McAlpine car battery site

Specialist to start on £4bn site next month after steel package signed-off
4 days ago

Construction Manager of the Year crowned

Jason Hunt of Willmott Dixon wins for work on Bristol concert hall
4 days ago

Tide gets go-ahead for over 1,000-home London scheme

Volumetric expert gains planning for co-living homes scheme in Southwark
5 days ago

Vital Energi lands £250m Gatwick decarbonisation deal

Five-year programme to switch airport away from gas heating
4 days ago

Construction output flickers into life in March

First quarter activity flatlines after slow start to year
5 days ago

Skanska lifts margin to 4.3% as profit hits £78m

Infrastructure and FM drive near-tripling of profits
6 days ago

Mayor backs 46-storey student tower at Canary Wharf

City Hall overturns Tower Hamlets council rejection of 912-bed scheme
6 days ago

Plans go in for 100 acre Port of Tilbury expansion

Construction could start next year on site the size of 70 football pitches
5 days ago

Inland Homes creditors face £38m hit

Administrator confirms no cash for supply chain
6 days ago

Durkan dogged by legacy jobs despite return to trading profit

Durkan scales down new homes contracting to focus on retrofit work
6 days ago

Munnelly founder hands over CEO role to son

Paul David Munnelly steps up to CEO as father becomes chairman
5 days ago

Contractor services