Crane jib collapse costs McCarthy & Stone £100,000

Aaron Morby 12 years ago
Share

Retirement homes specialist McCarthy & Stone has been ordered to pay £97,681 for safety breaches that led to a crane jib collapsing in Saffron Waldon two years ago.

Residents living near the construction site in Essex were evacuated when a 45m JOST crane jib collapsed and was left swing dangerous in high winds.

It was one of two incidents with the crane at the Sutton Road site in December 2011.

Chelmsford Crown Court heard that McCarthy & Stone Retirement Lifestyles employed its own team of crane erectors to erect the 24m tall tower crane, which had a 45m long jib.

The court heard that on 15 December crane erectors were carrying out a test lift when the lifting rope broke, causing a heavy block and seven tonne test load to fall onto a trailer.

No one was injured but witnesses described how the crane and jib recoiled violently, bucking back and forth.

A new lifting rope was installed, but the crane remained unused pending the delivery of a new “load indicator” rope.

Crane Jib Saffron Waldon JOST

But two days before Christmas, the crane’s jib collapsed, causing the 280kg hook block to swing and fall outside the boundary, partly demolishing a garage and fence belonging to a neighbouring developer.

The bent jib was left hanging vertically from the top of the tower crane.

Fortunately, both construction sites had closed for the Christmas break and no one was injured.

But emergency services evacuated 30-40 residents from nearby homes while the area was made safe before they were able to return home for Christmas Day.

HSE found that safety-critical high-tensile steel bolt connections had not been suitably installed and maintained in the crane jib.

Evidence indicated that the correct pre-tension torque was not applied to tighten these vital components and that no suitable lubrication regime was implemented.

The crane had been subjected to damage in the first incident, when the lifting rope failed.

Clearly, at this point, the company could have ensured that a thorough mechanical examination of the crane was carried out, but it failed to do so.

In fact, little more than a visual examination was carried out and the crane later collapsed after the connecting components in the lower jib failed in tension.

McCarthy & Stone Retirement Lifestyles was fined £50,000 including a victim surcharge and ordered to pay £47,681 in costs after pleading to safety breaches.

HSE Principal Inspector Norman Macritchie, said: “It is only by good fortune that no one was injured or killed in these incidents.

“The jib collapse may have been avoided had the company identified and repaired any damage caused by the earlier incident when the lifting rope broke.”

Latest news

Ardmore Construction Ltd falls into administration

Move isolates fire safety claims, leaving main Ardmore group free to grow profitability
2 days ago

Aston Villa gets go-ahead for £100m North Stand expansion

Project to modernise 1897-built ground ahead of EURO 2028
2 days ago

Quartet wins £1.75bn Midlands Rail Hub upgrade deal

VolkerRail, Laing O’Rourke, AtkinsRéalis and Siemens team up on Birmingham upgrade
3 days ago

McLaren confirmed for £250m Cardiff arena

Robertson Property secures planning green light for 16,500-capacity venue
3 days ago

John F Hunt starts work on £150m West End office revamp

Six month strip out deal at 125 Shaftesbury Avenue
2 days ago

Former Skanska vice president to join Galliford Try

Thomas Faulkner to head up specialist services division
2 days ago

Bowmer + Kirkland snaps up office fit-out firm Denton

Acquisition gives £40m turnover interiors specialist firepower to chase bigger jobs
3 days ago

Contractors sought for £667m Welsh Water mega project

Utility tests appetite for design, build and finance for twin water treatment jobs
3 days ago

Worker killed on Mace London site

Fatal accident on major site in Brent
4 days ago

Willmott Dixon veteran takes construction COO role

Former trainee Stewart Brundell promoted after nearly 40 years at the firm
4 days ago

BSR delays dent margins at OHOB despite record sales

Turnover up 18% to £369m as pre-tax profit nudges £22m
3 days ago

Plans go in for 30-storey Preston tower

£40m scheme will be tallest residential building in Lancashire
3 days ago

Former Laing O’Rourke leader to join Skanska

James Davies to oversee key defence and health projects
3 days ago

Green light for £10bn data hub prep works in Northumberland

Enabling works to roll out over 16 months on former Blyth Power Station site
5 days ago

VolkerWessels UK profits jump as rail and marine work surges

Infrastructure contractor posts £48m pre-tax profit and stronger order book
5 days ago

Groundworks boss wins payout over gagging order

Subcontractor raised fears over asbestos on housing sites
4 days ago

B+K to start £50m rebuild of Northumberland school

Cramlington Learning Village redevelopment contract signed off
5 days ago

New Homes Accelerator targets six new major sites

Construction to be sped-up on another 12,000 homes
4 days ago

Network Rail spend down as CP7 shift bites contractors

Firms warn of inflation squeeze and reprofiled workbanks
5 days ago

Wall of six towers planned for North London strip site

Hendon Goods Yard site plan for line of resi blocks rising to 29 storeys
5 days ago

SCF opens door to single stage tenders for first time

Gen-6 Southern Construction Framework to widen scope for smaller jobs
5 days ago

M&J Evans lifts profits as eastward regional push pays off

Groundworks specialist sharpens tender strike rate and grows pipeline to £504m
5 days ago

CHIC confirms 33 winners on £1bn housing framework

Equans, Guildmore, Seddon and Wates land spots on new four-year deal
5 days ago

Trade body joins attack on CITB over funding changes

Fit out specialists describe move as a "kick in the teeth"
5 days ago

Carey demolition cartel claim settled with developer

Legal action withdrawn after both sides agree settlement
1 week ago

Strabag seals financial close for £3bn HARP project

Work to start next year on North West's Haweswater aqueduct upgrade
1 week ago

Civils winners revealed for £12bn National Grid high voltage work

Contractor wins complete £59bn investment programme
1 week ago

Watch giant HS2 bridge move complete ahead of schedule

Video highlights engineering feat in Birmingham
1 week ago

Lee Marley posts record revenue despite project delays

Brickwork contractor weathers hiatus in high-rise starts to deliver fifth year of growth
1 week ago

Latest contract winners in military living revamp

First phase sites allocated under new approach to Single Living Accommodation
1 week ago