Steel firm fined £100k for school canopy collapse

Grant Prior 12 years ago
Share

A structural steelwork specialist has been ordered to pay fines and costs of more than £200,000 after five roofers were seriously injured when a canopy for a new secondary school collapsed.

The workers sustained injuries ranging from fractures and broken bones to cuts and bruising following a 13-metre plunge at the Abraham Darby Academy in Telford in August 2011.

Droitwich-based Adstone Construction Ltd was prosecuted by the HSE after an investigation identified failings with the steelwork that gave way.

Shrewsbury Crown Court heard that key pieces of the canopy truss steelwork were insufficiently welded together.

As a result when the roofing contractors added further materials to the roof, key welds failed and the structure collapsed – taking the roofers with it and causing enormous damage to the front of the new school where Kier was main contractor.

The collapsed canopy was 57 metres long and weighed in at over 40 tonnes.

A large vertical steel support column for the canopy, called the ‘skylon’ also collapsed as a direct result of the canopy failure.

HSE found Adstone Construction, which was responsible for the structure, had failed to provide adequate instructions to those responsible for the fabrication and welding of the canopy truss, and failed to adequately inspect the completed work.

One of the roof workers, Philip Drury Jr, 29, from Mansfield, was air-lifted to hospital strapped to a spinal board and in a neck brace. He was discharged after two days with damage diagnosed to two vertebrae and his shoulder.

Another worker, Mark Drury-Tuck, 32, who lives in Ripley, was taken by ambulance to hospital where he was kept in overnight for observation. He was left with pain in his ribs.

A third, Joshua Wolak, 24, from Edwinstowe, was kept in hospital overnight with a suspected fractured rib and multiple cuts and bruises.

The fourth, James Buchanan, 32, also from Edwinstowe, suffered arm injuries and swelling and bruising to his neck. He had to wear a neck brace for the two days he spent in hospital, and needed ultrasound scans and x-rays.

The final roof worker, Philip Drury Sr, 54, from Mansfield, had a fractured ankle, three cracked ribs with internal bruising, head injuries and cuts and bruising to his face and head.

Adstone Construction of Lovett Industrial Estate, Droitwich, was fined a total of £100,000 and ordered to pay £106,098 in costs after pleading guilty to a safety breach.

Speaking after the hearing, HSE inspector Andrew Bowker said: “This incident had enormous potential for loss of life.

“The canopy collapsed suddenly and violently without warning taking the five roofers that were on it down over 13 metres to the ground on what can only be described as a terror ride. It is a miracle that they were not more seriously injured or even killed.

“Other construction workers had been working directly under the school canopy for most of the day installing windows in the new school. Fortunately they were not under the canopy when it collapsed.

“Adstone Construction Ltd fabricated the steelwork for the canopy and failed to ensure that critical welds within the design of the steel truss were completed to the required specification and size.

“This failure led the canopy to collapse as more roofing material was added.

“It is vital that companies carrying out this type of work have suitable and sufficient quality control measures in place in order to ensure that the structural integrity of the new building is never in question.”

Abraham Darby Academy

Latest news

Carey demolition cartel claim settled with developer

Legal action withdrawn after both sides agree settlement
1 day ago

Strabag seals financial close for £3bn HARP project

Work to start next year on North West's Haweswater aqueduct upgrade
2 days ago

Civils winners revealed for £12bn National Grid high voltage work

Contractor wins complete £59bn investment programme
3 days ago

Watch giant HS2 bridge move complete ahead of schedule

Video highlights engineering feat in Birmingham
2 days ago

Lee Marley posts record revenue despite project delays

Brickwork contractor weathers hiatus in high-rise starts to deliver fifth year of growth
2 days ago

Latest contract winners in military living revamp

First phase sites allocated under new approach to Single Living Accommodation
2 days ago

Plans go in for £45m transformation of derelict site

Family homes proposed for brownfield land in Edgbaston
2 days ago

Cruden gets green light for Edinburgh housing job

Construction to start later this year to transform vacant 1950s building
2 days ago

United Living quits new-build housing as costs mount

£136m-turnover housing arm to wind down as focus shifts to core infrastructure
3 days ago

Fight looms for £3bn West Midlands building framework

Galliford Try, Morgan Sindall and others face fight to keep CWM seats
3 days ago

Industry anger over sudden CITB funding changes

Smaller contractors lose funding route worth £10,000 a year
3 days ago

Plans in to transform former GSK London HQ with 2,300 homes

Landmark 13-acre scheme set to transform Brentford Great West Road campus
3 days ago

Watch Murphy near completion of major new rail bridge

Latest video reveals progress on Greek Street bridge during 21-day train suspension
3 days ago

Mount Anvil’s in-house builder drives results in testing market

Group development pipeline holds steady at 3,384 homes despite dip in profit
3 days ago

Costain margin heads for 4.5% after half-year profit rise

Roads and HS2 rephasing hit transport revenues but £5.6bn forward book to support growth
4 days ago

Hinkley contractors face prosecution over rebar mesh fall

Bouygues and Laing O'Rourke face action brought by the Office for Nuclear Regulation
5 days ago

Farrans to build new £59m Paisley bridge

Work to start soon on transport project for Renfrewshire Council
4 days ago

Crown Estate hires Olympics village veteran to lead delivery push

John Nicholson to oversee £16bn portfolio’s major UK development pipeline.
4 days ago

Henry Boot gets green light for 2,500 new homes

Hallam Land division sees signs planning system is speeding-up
4 days ago

Wates inks £100m deal on first new-design prison houseblocks

HMP Onley expansion leads roll-out of new standardised design
5 days ago

£122m deal to unlock Newcastle’s last brownfield site

Land remediation funding paves way for 2,500-home Forth Yards neighbourhood
5 days ago

McLaren lands Heathrow logistics deal

1.6 hectare airport site to be transformed into modern warehouses
5 days ago

McAlpine veteran to lead T&T’s project management drive

Former Olympic Stadium lead Mike O’Donnell takes lead role with focus on major capital project delivery
5 days ago

IES snaps up Nexus Power out of administration

Utilities group strengthens expertise in 400kV jointing and offshore markets
5 days ago

Thames Water tenders £120m water main rehab deal

Company seeks 2–5 contractors for London and South East renewal works
5 days ago

Lower Thames Crossing to lead green planning reforms

New system to avoid another £100m HS2 bat tunnel
5 days ago

Mace lands latest 30-storey City of London tower

85 Gracechurch Street near Leadenhall Market to be transformed
6 days ago

Vinci gets go-ahead for £250m Stockport 8 scheme

Contractor to start first phase of 435 net zero homes next year
6 days ago

£80m bid race to convert Oxford Debenhams into labs

Crown Estate advance plan to convert former six storey department store
6 days ago

Bennett steps-in to finish Guinness Covent Garden brewery

Original fit-out contractor Beck Interiors fell into administration
6 days ago