St George fined £50,000 for platform collapse

Grant Prior 4 years ago
Share

Developer St George has been fined after a formwork carpenter was seriously injured when a temporary platform collapsed at a landmark site in south London.

Noel Doyle, 32, from Hammersmith, suffered a shattered right elbow, broken vertebrae, fractured pelvis and ribs, and damage to internal organs in the incident at St George Wharf in Vauxhall on 10 February 2009.

He fell almost ten metres onto a concrete staircase when the platform gave way.

Southwark Crown Court heard that on the day of the fall Doyle was helping two colleagues, including a foreman, to raise a temporary work platform inside a concrete shaft to house a stairwell within a building under construction, which was known as ‘Block A’.

The platform was lifted from one floor to another by a crane using four lifting chains before being locked in place in the shaft to enable the next level to be constructed.

It had been raised from the fourth to the fifth floor level when the crane operator was inadvertently instructed by the foreman to take the chains away while one of them was still attached.

The platform was lifted by only one corner and disintegrated.

Of the three workers standing on the temporary structure at the time, two managed to jump to safety but Doyle was unable to do so.

He fell into the shaft beneath with parts of the platform and equipment that had been stored on top raining down on him.

Mr Doyle required extensive treatment and physiotherapy, and has been left with limited movement in his right arm because of the elbow injury. He is no longer able to work in construction.

An HSE investigation identified that St George South London Ltd, as the principal contractor, had failed to properly plan and manage the construction work so as to avoid risks to safety.

The company failed to ensure that their subcontractors had developed and implemented safe systems of work, particularly in relation to the management and use of temporary works.

St George South London Ltd, of Imperial Wharf, Fulham, was fined £50,000 and ordered to pay £27,386 in costs after pleading guilty to a breach of the CDM regulations.

After sentencing HSE Inspector Loraine Charles said:

“It is vitally important that principal contractors appreciate that managing and monitoring subcontractors involves more than merely requiring them to provide risk assessments and method statements, and then carrying out basic hazard spotting inspections.

“They need to make sure that there is a proper assessment of the content of the documentation provided to ensure that they make sense and properly address the risks associated with the work being undertaken.

“In this case, St George South London concerned themselves more with the existence than the content of the subcontractor safety documents, and although they themselves carried out regular site safety inspections, all of these were superficial and failed to indentify significant systemic failures.”

The company subcontracted for the construction of the reinforced concrete frame of the building was also prosecuted over the collapse.

J Reddington Ltd, of Borehamwood, Herts, was fined £70,000 and ordered to pay £22,193 in costs after pleading guilty to a breach of the Health and Safety at Work etc Act 1974 at Southwark Crown Court on 28 June last year.

Latest news

£80m twin hotel plan for Manchester Airport

Ibis and Holiday kick-start new £180m Airport City hotel district
33 mins ago

Mace to start £120m Crossrail office scheme

PLP Architecture reveals latest images of Farringdon scheme
14 hours ago

Worker in plunge removing fall arrest bags from school site

Court hears edge protection was not up to industry safety standards
38 mins ago

First packages awarded on £28m Milton Keynes office job

Galliford Try gets going on eight-storey complex
15 hours ago

Network Rail to build £46m Wigan train depot

Preparation works are getting underway for Ince-in-Makerfield depot
18 hours ago

Boost your online presence – join the new Enquirer Directory

New site for suppliers and buyers will showcase their products, services and latest stories
2 weeks ago

Specialist trade bodies petition No 10 for payment reform

Unprecedented coalition of trade associations urge Prime Minister to act
1 day ago

Construction boss and developer jailed for contracts bribery

Skansen Interiors MD and and DTZ project manager sentenced
23 hours ago

Murphy wins Wessex Water Trym Tunnel relief sewer

North Bristol tunnel scheme to start next year
22 hours ago

Graphene concrete game-changer for industry

Exeter Uni scientists produce concrete with twice the strength and four times water resistance
23 hours ago

Kier lands lead role in £19.4m Glasgow theatre revamp

Work to start in September revamping the Citizens Theatre
1 day ago

Hill boasts record year as partnerships margin hits 3%

Partnership housing drives growth at Hill as pre-tax profit hits £47m
22 hours ago

CMS wins £10m glazing deal on BAM’s Atlantic Square job

Major package win on £100m scheme
2 days ago

Contractors fold before £2m site death fines

Judge hands out huge fines but firms are no longer in business
2 days ago

Green light for £350m Leeds South Bank scheme

Preparation works can now start with construction planned to start next year
2 days ago

Mace go-ahead for London £150m Hanover Square scheme

Great Portland Estates JV secures pre-let to start building work on Mayfair scheme
2 days ago

Growth to rebound to 2.7% next year after flat 2018

30% fall in office activity over two years offset by surge in infrastructure
2 days ago

Crystal Palace to start £100m main stand next summer

Iconic main stand plan to go to London mayor to rubber stamp
2 days ago

Builder murdered by colleague on central London site

Murder hunt under way after construction worker bludgeoned by colleague on Hatton Garden roof
5 days ago

Barratt to pay for post Grenfell cladding upgrade on Croydon block

Government urges more house builders to pay for safety work rather than leaseholders
5 days ago

Carillion’s Midlands Pf2 hospital to cost extra £125m

Skanska confirmed for Midlands Metropolitan Hospital as trust waits for Government go-ahead
5 days ago

BAM Nuttall fined £900,000 after painter tears ligament

Court hears how worker plunged through station waiting room roof
6 days ago

Builders told to wait over a year for brick orders

Smaller builders warn of rising materials prices and lead times
5 days ago

14-storey Milton Keynes ‘sun hotel’ approved

Hotel La Tour gets nod for tallest building in Milton Keynes city centre
5 days ago

Hill bags £41m Homes England direct commission job

Public land direct commissioning scheme entails building 160 homes
5 days ago

KBR buys Carillion’s Aspire Defence business

Deal secures workforce and future of Project Allenby Connaught contract
6 days ago

New Seddon built Coronation Street set makes debut tonight

Contractor has been working on Weatherfield extension since last summer
5 days ago

Betting Spy: Bookies keep under-estimating Burnley

The Clarets are a big price at 5/2 to beat sinking Stoke
5 days ago

London roads upkeep JV loses court battle with TfL

High Court backs TfL in rates row with Colas, VolkerHighways and AECOM
6 days ago

Keltbray looks overseas for new rail work

Contractor targets Canadian market as UK rail electrification work dries-up
6 days ago

Contractor services