St George fined £50,000 for platform collapse

Grant Prior 4 years ago
Share

Developer St George has been fined after a formwork carpenter was seriously injured when a temporary platform collapsed at a landmark site in south London.

Noel Doyle, 32, from Hammersmith, suffered a shattered right elbow, broken vertebrae, fractured pelvis and ribs, and damage to internal organs in the incident at St George Wharf in Vauxhall on 10 February 2009.

He fell almost ten metres onto a concrete staircase when the platform gave way.

Southwark Crown Court heard that on the day of the fall Doyle was helping two colleagues, including a foreman, to raise a temporary work platform inside a concrete shaft to house a stairwell within a building under construction, which was known as ‘Block A’.

The platform was lifted from one floor to another by a crane using four lifting chains before being locked in place in the shaft to enable the next level to be constructed.

It had been raised from the fourth to the fifth floor level when the crane operator was inadvertently instructed by the foreman to take the chains away while one of them was still attached.

The platform was lifted by only one corner and disintegrated.

Of the three workers standing on the temporary structure at the time, two managed to jump to safety but Doyle was unable to do so.

He fell into the shaft beneath with parts of the platform and equipment that had been stored on top raining down on him.

Mr Doyle required extensive treatment and physiotherapy, and has been left with limited movement in his right arm because of the elbow injury. He is no longer able to work in construction.

An HSE investigation identified that St George South London Ltd, as the principal contractor, had failed to properly plan and manage the construction work so as to avoid risks to safety.

The company failed to ensure that their subcontractors had developed and implemented safe systems of work, particularly in relation to the management and use of temporary works.

St George South London Ltd, of Imperial Wharf, Fulham, was fined £50,000 and ordered to pay £27,386 in costs after pleading guilty to a breach of the CDM regulations.

After sentencing HSE Inspector Loraine Charles said:

“It is vitally important that principal contractors appreciate that managing and monitoring subcontractors involves more than merely requiring them to provide risk assessments and method statements, and then carrying out basic hazard spotting inspections.

“They need to make sure that there is a proper assessment of the content of the documentation provided to ensure that they make sense and properly address the risks associated with the work being undertaken.

“In this case, St George South London concerned themselves more with the existence than the content of the subcontractor safety documents, and although they themselves carried out regular site safety inspections, all of these were superficial and failed to indentify significant systemic failures.”

The company subcontracted for the construction of the reinforced concrete frame of the building was also prosecuted over the collapse.

J Reddington Ltd, of Borehamwood, Herts, was fined £70,000 and ordered to pay £22,193 in costs after pleading guilty to a breach of the Health and Safety at Work etc Act 1974 at Southwark Crown Court on 28 June last year.

Latest news

Network Rail to pay Carillion workers for next three months

Suppliers will also be paid for work carried out post-insolvency
9 hours ago

Carillion bankers set up £225m fund to help subcontractors

Task force launched to help stricken supply chain
1 day ago

HS2 reveals 3.4km Colne Valley viaduct design

New sleek-look railway viaduct will be one of the longest in the country
18 hours ago

Barratt to build 2,700 homes in Swindon

House builder will invest over £180m in infrastructure and housing
19 hours ago

Balfour Beatty in talks to head off more Crossrail strikes

Unite union announces plans for four more days of industrial action
19 hours ago

Survey drone hits crane on construction site

Air accident investigators called in after drone strike
19 hours ago

CITB calls on contractors to save Carillion apprentices

Skills body could be £3.8m better off following collapse
1 day ago

Betting Spy: West Ham and Leicester at the double

Hammers can beat Bournemouth despite yet another injury to Andy Carroll
1 day ago

Opinion: Carillion legacy must be pay and procurement reform

Carillion car-crash must finally jolt industry and government into action
2 days ago

Boost your online presence with the new Enquirer Directory

New site for suppliers and buyers will showcase their products, services and latest stories
3 months ago

Barratt London shelves 27-storey Aldgate tower project

Barratt abandons Phase 2 of city fringe tower scheme
2 days ago

Banks pledge not to pull plug on Carillion subcontractors

High street lenders promise raft of measure to help small businesses
2 days ago

NAO challenges value of PFI contracts

Little evidence PFI offers more construction cost certainty or operating efficiency, says watchdog
2 days ago

Skanska UK on alert as group plans 3,000 job cuts

Skanska Group says UK business focus to switch to core markets
3 days ago

Sheffield United submits plan for South Stand

Championship club plans landmark stand raising capacity to 38,000 seats
2 days ago

Kier fined £100,000 for hospital oil spill

Leak at Dorset hospital site lands contractor in court
2 days ago

Carillion sites still on hold as hopes rise for services deals

Insolvency Service update gives hope to suppliers
3 days ago

Subcontractors left stranded by Carillion “early payment” system

Millions sitting in controversial system may never reach suppliers
3 days ago

Crunch day for over 8,000 Carillion staff

Carillion went bust with just £29m left and would have been out of cash today
3 days ago

Balfour tipped for Carillion’s Leeds ring road job

£115m East Leeds Orbital Route contract consolation for Balfour after £45m hit
3 days ago

Colmore Tang offers early payment to Carillion subbies

Birmingham contractor to speed-up payments to its suppliers hit by Carillion collapse
3 days ago

Lendlease launches £1.5bn build-to-rent partnership

First £450m tranche invested in private rental build at Elephant & Castle
3 days ago

Government fast-tracks probe into Carillion directors

Business secretary extends investigation into actions of directors and auditors
4 days ago

Race starts for £8.7bn Highways England framework

New approach will allow smaller contractors to take part in regional roads delivery
4 days ago

Supply chain owed £2bn by Carillion

Subcontractors hoping for protection from Project Bank Accounts
4 days ago

Carillion fall-out hits Van Elle and Speedy

Specialist subcontractors start to disclose cost of collapse
4 days ago

Winvic lands Sheffield build-to-rent deal

Construction to start this month on nine-storey block
4 days ago

Willmott Dixon wins second Kent Uni project

Firm to start £13m contract for School of Economic building
4 days ago

Carillion collapse to cost Balfour Beatty £45m

Galliford Try also hit for up to £40m on Aberdeen Western Peripheral Route
5 days ago

Carillion staff and suppliers told to carry on working

Liquidator sets up website offering advice to anyone hit by the collapse
5 days ago

Contractor services