Balfour Beatty pays £137,000 to whistleblower

Grant Prior 2 years ago
Share

Balfour Beatty has been ordered to pay £137,000 to a former regional pre-construction manager who accused the firm of under-estimating potential profits on a Welsh government job.

callaghan_square_cardiff_picture_by_philip_halling_via_wikimedia_commons
The Callaghan Square project was eventually cancelled by the Welsh government

Nigel McArthur had worked at the company for nearly ten years and had nearly 40 years’ experience in the construction industry.

Balfour Beatty tendered in 2014 for an £18.5m project at Callaghan Square in Cardiff which would be paid for out of public funds by the Welsh Government.

But McArthur believed Balfour would be making greater profits than declared to the client by not submitting the lowest quotes received by subcontractors to the Welsh government.

He raised concerns internally through the company’s whistleblowing procedures but claims he was subsequently bullied.

McArthur resigned in February 2015 and began a claim for constructive dismissal.

Balfour Beatty admitted his claim in November 2015 and the compensation judgement of £137,000 has now been handed down by the court.

Balfour Beatty said: “In the employment tribunal proceedings, Balfour Beatty did not contest Mr McArthur’s claim for unfair dismissal and is paying compensation to him as assessed by the Court.

“We accept that we failed to properly support our employee following concerns he raised, which resulted in him feeling it was necessary to resign.

“Balfour Beatty encourages its employees to report workplace concerns they may have and we have the tools in place to support them in doing so.

“We regret that on this occasion we fell short of the high standards we set for ourselves in this area. We will use the lessons learnt from this experience to provide better support to our employees in the future.

“Balfour Beatty did not behave illegally or fraudulently in relation to the Callaghan Square project.

“Once senior management were aware of the facts regarding the Callaghan Square project, we provided full disclosure to the Welsh Assembly.

“The Welsh Assembly later made a decision not to pursue the project for reasons of their own unrelated to this matter.”

Terry Falcão, employment lasw partner at Stephens Scown who represented McArthur, said: “Nigel has shown immense integrity throughout this case and has had the courage of his convictions to stand up for the truth.

“This case clearly underlines that even though many companies have whistleblowing hotlines and model policies and procedures in place, it remains very difficult for employees who speak out.”

Latest news

Plans in for £400m Kent housing scheme

Medway's 1,400-home Rochester Riverside plan submitted
2 hours ago

Hotel contract row forces Primus into CVA

Contractor set up by former Multiplex boss Martin Tidd faces cash flow crisis
1 day ago

Manchester’s tallest building set for green light

Allied London's most ambitious scheme so far set for approval
1 day ago

Morgan Sindall hunts top talent at virtual jobs fair

Construction & Infrastructure division takes careers event online to boost diversity
1 day ago

Landmark VAT ruling on student rooms projects

Tax tribunal overturns HMRC’s VAT policy on student accommodation
1 day ago

Grenfell cladding fire test verdict due next week

Government slashes estimate of residential blocks at risk from 600 to 208
1 day ago

£100m East Riding prison gets green light

Category C jail to be built next to HMP Full Sutton, near York
1 day ago

GSK scraps £350m Cumbria pharma plan

Pharma giant will invest extra £140m existing facility expansion
1 day ago

Specialists land first trade packages at huge Berkeley site

Main construction starts on 88-acre Southall Waterside site
2 days ago

Electrification plans scrapped on three major rail routes

Contracts worth millions axed as Government switches focus to new train technology
2 days ago

Project delays dent Clugston results

Contractor confident about future prospects following a "challenging" year
2 days ago

UK drags Skanska Europe into £40m loss

Skanska chief aims to cut operational costs and tighten risk management
2 days ago

McLaren set to bag £45m Lakeside extension

Contractor beats off McAlpine, ISG and Sisk to take Essex retail deal
2 days ago

Demand grows for immediate revamp of building regs

Local council chief attacks BRE, contractors and manufacturers for not sharing previous fire test results
2 days ago

Canary Wharf Contractors pays £11,000 tax on £70m profit

Company offsets £13.9m Corporation Tax bill against losses at other group divisions
3 days ago

Mount Anvil plans 1,000 flats in London Royal Docks

Deal with London ExCel centre paves way to build block of apartments
2 days ago

Consultant RLB stages mass raid on Mace managers

Five senior figures jump ship to join rival
3 days ago

Ministers reject client levy option in Farmer Review

Government backs most calls for reform but stops short of 0.5% charge on clients
3 days ago

Construction and fit out boost profits at Morgan Sindall

Contractor bucks recent sector trend by telling City to expect higher than predicted profits
3 days ago

Lendlease ordered to pay £14.8m for city tower falling glass

Cladding contractor to pick up bill after 15-foot glass pane fell from 17th floor
3 days ago

Civil engineers act to avert Grenfell-style disasters

ICE launches review of lessons from tower tragedy to avoid infrastructure failures
3 days ago

Man killed in derelict church collapse

Tragedy at Cardiff site where old church was being demolished
3 days ago

CH2M and BDP to lead revamp of Parliament

Firms to assess scale of work needed ahead of potential £4bn restoration
3 days ago

Wates southern boss joins Midas

Peter Whitmore charged with growing turnover in the south to £100m
3 days ago

Willmott Dixon wins £24m laser testing centre

Another major win for contractor at Harwell Science Campus
3 days ago

HS2 confirms shortlists for new stations

Design teams battle to win trio of stations as development partners fight for major Euston site
4 days ago

Willmott Dixon starts redundancy talks as divisions merge

Contractor confident most housing staff will be redeployed during merger into main construction arm
4 days ago

Tower crane drivers hold ballot over summer strikes

Unite warns of widespread project delays as dispute with HTC Wolffkran intensifies
4 days ago

Government confident Carillion JV will deliver HS2 deals

Rail chiefs seek guarantees from joint venture partners
5 days ago

Site start next month for £70m Broadgate revamp

Facelift for 1 Finsbury Square as tech firm Mimecast set to move in to financial hub
4 days ago

Contractor services