Balfour Beatty pays £137,000 to whistleblower

Grant Prior 5 months ago
Share

Balfour Beatty has been ordered to pay £137,000 to a former regional pre-construction manager who accused the firm of under-estimating potential profits on a Welsh government job.

callaghan_square_cardiff_picture_by_philip_halling_via_wikimedia_commons
The Callaghan Square project was eventually cancelled by the Welsh government

Nigel McArthur had worked at the company for nearly ten years and had nearly 40 years’ experience in the construction industry.

Balfour Beatty tendered in 2014 for an £18.5m project at Callaghan Square in Cardiff which would be paid for out of public funds by the Welsh Government.

But McArthur believed Balfour would be making greater profits than declared to the client by not submitting the lowest quotes received by subcontractors to the Welsh government.

He raised concerns internally through the company’s whistleblowing procedures but claims he was subsequently bullied.

McArthur resigned in February 2015 and began a claim for constructive dismissal.

Balfour Beatty admitted his claim in November 2015 and the compensation judgement of £137,000 has now been handed down by the court.

Balfour Beatty said: “In the employment tribunal proceedings, Balfour Beatty did not contest Mr McArthur’s claim for unfair dismissal and is paying compensation to him as assessed by the Court.

“We accept that we failed to properly support our employee following concerns he raised, which resulted in him feeling it was necessary to resign.

“Balfour Beatty encourages its employees to report workplace concerns they may have and we have the tools in place to support them in doing so.

“We regret that on this occasion we fell short of the high standards we set for ourselves in this area. We will use the lessons learnt from this experience to provide better support to our employees in the future.

“Balfour Beatty did not behave illegally or fraudulently in relation to the Callaghan Square project.

“Once senior management were aware of the facts regarding the Callaghan Square project, we provided full disclosure to the Welsh Assembly.

“The Welsh Assembly later made a decision not to pursue the project for reasons of their own unrelated to this matter.”

Terry Falcão, employment lasw partner at Stephens Scown who represented McArthur, said: “Nigel has shown immense integrity throughout this case and has had the courage of his convictions to stand up for the truth.

“This case clearly underlines that even though many companies have whistleblowing hotlines and model policies and procedures in place, it remains very difficult for employees who speak out.”

Latest news

Kier wins bid race for £25m Mackintosh restoration

Kier beats rivals with "extremely competitive" bid for fire-damaged building
12 mins ago

Balfour Beatty chief’s wife buys £200,000 company shares

Quinn holding in construction group rises to 0.7%
5 hours ago

Willmott Dixon abandons sale of support services arm

Contractor decides to keep division after bidders wanted to break-up maintenance operation
1 day ago

Firm fined £550,000 after two men fall to their deaths

Couple fell through Euston roadside hoarding into building site basement
6 hours ago

Redrow reports buyers unbowed by Brexit

House builder expects strong year-end profits after completions rise 17% to nearly 5,000
5 hours ago

HS2 phase one opening could be delayed a year

Spending watchdog warns HS2 timetable unrealistic despite good progress on procurement
4 hours ago

Murphy finance chief becomes new Barhale CEO

Matthew Behan to lead contractor as new corporate structure established to broaden portfolio
21 hours ago

£10,000 prize to cut roadwork disruption and delays

Amey and Staffordshire council seek smart digital solutions to roadwork traffic delays
6 hours ago

Currie & Brown trumps WSP bid for Sweett Group

WSP raises prospect of a bid war as it tells Sweett shareholders to sit tight
1 day ago

Suppliers hit as HOC goes into administration

Redundancies at north London firm as subcontractors left in dark
1 day ago

Student digs developer shrugs off Brexit worries

Empiric confident EU vote will have limited impact on expanding sector
1 day ago

Brexit leaves Heathrow third runway in the air

Fears grow about the future of major infrastructure projects
1 day ago

Bid costs dent Hochtief UK profits

Operating margin drops to 0.7% as profit falls 45% to below £1m
1 day ago

Breakaway trade body formed by rebar producers

Independent rebar producers and suppliers split with BAR
1 day ago

Sinkhole closes busy stretch of A1

Contractors pumping huge hole with concrete in bid to reopen route
2 days ago

Lendlease to start £275m Hammersmith scheme

Construction to start next month on major office project
4 days ago

Contractors call for calm as Brexit victory spooks markets

Construction fears over costs, skills and investment as house builder shares crash
4 days ago

Shepherd Group suffers £74m hit from sold building arm

Strong profits at remaining Portakabin business help to cut group loss to £28m
4 days ago

Bidding set to start on £2bn East London cultural quarter

London Legacy Development Corporation set to procure shell and core work
4 days ago

Building worker critical after being crushed by JCB

Digger at Hebburn housing site believed to have reversed into worker
4 days ago

Plant test cheats website dodges closure threat

CITB chiefs battling to close down site undermining tests for machinery drivers
5 days ago

Green light for £18m Midland Metro extension

Preparatory utility diversion works to start immediately
5 days ago

Hill wins approval for £100m east London housing scheme

Work to start on Walthamstow triple towers this autumn
5 days ago

Construction workers win inflation busting pay rise

Deal agreed but unions warn pay agreement is "no longer fit for purpose"
5 days ago

Cameron resigns as exit vote sends markets crashing

New Prime Minister to be elected by October
4 days ago

Costain to use more drones to make sites safer

Unmanned aerial vehicles can take on hazardous tasks
5 days ago

Bowmer & Kirkland profit jumps by almost half

Derbyshire private builder lifts profit to nearly £40m
5 days ago

Plans for £250m Liverpool resi towers trio

Liverpool developer Elliot plans cluster of 34-storey towers
5 days ago

Specialist wins low road tender court hearing

Judge rules against public client who rejected "abnormally low" bid from FP McCann and Balfour Beatty
6 days ago

Yorkshire plumbing contractor sinks

More than 100 jobs cut after firm fails to reach agreement with HMRC over tax arrears
6 days ago