Amey wins £5m payout in Cumbria roads court battle

Aaron Morby 9 months ago
Share

The High Court has ordered Cumbria County Council to pay Amey over £5m at the end of a long-running legal battle over a seven-year roads maintenance contract.

Amey
Amey emerges as the victor in long-running legal battle over seven-year road maintenance work

The contract for the provision of highways maintenance ended in 2013 with Amey claiming over £30m in unpaid fees and the council counterclaiming £20m for payments for what it said was substandard work.

The services had previously been provided by Cumbria’s direct labour organisation. Over the duration of the contract around 36,000 individual works instructions were issued by Cumbria, worth around £250m.

This included the laying of around 2,200 surfacing beds, with a combined area of around 4.2 million m² worth £41m, and the issuing of around 1,700 separate patching instructions, with a combined area of around 745,000 m².

After starting out well, the relationship between Amey and Cumbria from around 2009 onwards had steadily deteriorated.

By the time the contract expired several claims and counterclaims had already been intimated, with Cumbria making substantial deductions from Amey’s final monthly payment applications, and with both parties actively preparing to pursue claims against the other.

After attempts to settle the dispute through a week of mediation the two went to court in what proved to be a protracted legal battle.

In the end the mix of claim and counterclaim ended with the judge awarding Amey a balance of almost £3.7m and interest of £1.7m, representing contractual interest on the sum at 8% over base from June 2012.

Both sides are now arguing over legal costs which Amey claims cost it around £8.8m and the council says cost it a little over £10m.

An Amey spokesman said: “Amey worked with Cumbria County Council for almost a decade and we are proud to have served the county for this time, delivering high quality highways services.

“In 2013, when the contract concluded, there were a few items to be closed out. These are now concluded and we welcome the decision of the court.”

A spokeswoman for the council said: “The council is now considering the judgment with its lawyers to assess whether it is appropriate to make an appeal.”

“It is also awaiting a final decision as to what proportion of Amey’s costs it has to pay. Until these matters are concluded, the council will not be in a position to make a further statement for legal reasons.”

Latest news

Subbies start winding-up petition against Titan Construction

Financial crisis at firm where ISG founder David King is chairman
1 hour ago

Race starts for one of biggest demolition jobs of 2017

Six Grimsby tower blocks to be demolished
7 hours ago

Major York city mixed-use scheme approved

Four block redevelopment of Hudson House near railway station approved
24 mins ago

Midas construction margin edges up to 0.5%

South western builder sees recovery in profit to £1.6m
7 hours ago

Colas to trial driverless cone laying vehicles on roads

Autonomous Impact Protection Vehicles can make highways sites safer: Video
1 hour ago

Multiplex quits £750m Stage of East London project

Client hunts for new contractor to deliver vast scheme on Shakespeare’s Curtain Theatre site
1 day ago

Graham bags £19m East Anglian highways upgrade

Growing civils arm bags biggest highways package in over two years
16 hours ago

Betting Spy: Defence is a dying art in the Premier League

Goals guaranteed this season while a home win treble can pay a 7/1 return
10 hours ago

A2Dominion ramps up homes target to 6,000

Leadership shake-up to raise private rental and homes for sale
2 days ago

VolkerHighways names new ops director

Former Kier highways general manager Jerry Pert joins Volker
24 hours ago

Contractors named and shamed over minimum wage

Builders among latest list of offenders published in government crackdown
1 day ago

Virtual reality set to spread across construction sites

Research programme to push use of high-tech headsets
24 hours ago

Time nearly up for skills cards for fringe trades

85,000 Construction Related Occupation cards become obsolete within weeks
1 day ago

CITB buys plant simulators to fill operator skills gap

Sixteen plant simulators will help to train next generation of operators
2 days ago

Argent appoints five new firms on construction framework

Developer to shake-up one of the industry's longest running partnership deals
2 days ago

Balfour Beatty construction swings back into profit

Balfour generates positive cash from operations for first time since 2013
2 days ago

£300m dualling on A47 set for Spring 2020 start

Six projects planned to improve link between East Anglia and the Midlands
2 days ago

Big Ben safety row rumbles on

HSE chiefs hit back after criticism of plans to silence chimes during restoration work
2 days ago

Morgan Sindall wins £28m Soton sports centre race

Works starts on Southampton Solent University sports facility
2 days ago

London Mayor pumps £25m into Pocket Living

Over 1,000 off-site first-time buyer homes to be built by 2021
3 days ago

Second cladding system gets fire test ‘all clear’

Large-scale fire tests suggest over 200 buildings need to be reclad
3 days ago

Welsh contractor goes under with loss of 102 jobs

Contract Services (South Wales) suffers cash flow crisis
3 days ago

Leeds Beckett £75m arts building go-ahead

Work to start before end of year on major creative arts building
3 days ago

New MD takes helm at Hochtief UK

Lawrence Jackson takes over immediately as Sally Cox steps down
4 days ago

Costain to offer counselling to subcontractors

Employee programme to combat stress and anxiety extended to supply chain
4 days ago

London garden bridge project officially scrapped

Charity behind Thames bridge project wrapped up after failing to win support
4 days ago

ISG wins Investec London office fit-out

Fit out is due to complete next May
3 days ago

First ACM cladding passes fire tests

Aluminium cladding system used on 13 high-rises meets Building Regs
4 days ago

£45m trio of roads for housing projects approved

Two Leicestershire and one Hampshire schemes win funding
4 days ago

Lovell clear for first tower block reclad since Grenfell

Revamp of three Sandwell tower blocks includes fire-resistant cladding
4 days ago

Contractor services