Amey wins £5m payout in Cumbria roads court battle

Aaron Morby 1 year ago
Share

The High Court has ordered Cumbria County Council to pay Amey over £5m at the end of a long-running legal battle over a seven-year roads maintenance contract.

Amey emerges as the victor in long-running legal battle over seven-year road maintenance work

The contract for the provision of highways maintenance ended in 2013 with Amey claiming over £30m in unpaid fees and the council counterclaiming £20m for payments for what it said was substandard work.

The services had previously been provided by Cumbria’s direct labour organisation. Over the duration of the contract around 36,000 individual works instructions were issued by Cumbria, worth around £250m.

This included the laying of around 2,200 surfacing beds, with a combined area of around 4.2 million m² worth £41m, and the issuing of around 1,700 separate patching instructions, with a combined area of around 745,000 m².

After starting out well, the relationship between Amey and Cumbria from around 2009 onwards had steadily deteriorated.

By the time the contract expired several claims and counterclaims had already been intimated, with Cumbria making substantial deductions from Amey’s final monthly payment applications, and with both parties actively preparing to pursue claims against the other.

After attempts to settle the dispute through a week of mediation the two went to court in what proved to be a protracted legal battle.

In the end the mix of claim and counterclaim ended with the judge awarding Amey a balance of almost £3.7m and interest of £1.7m, representing contractual interest on the sum at 8% over base from June 2012.

Both sides are now arguing over legal costs which Amey claims cost it around £8.8m and the council says cost it a little over £10m.

An Amey spokesman said: “Amey worked with Cumbria County Council for almost a decade and we are proud to have served the county for this time, delivering high quality highways services.

“In 2013, when the contract concluded, there were a few items to be closed out. These are now concluded and we welcome the decision of the court.”

A spokeswoman for the council said: “The council is now considering the judgment with its lawyers to assess whether it is appropriate to make an appeal.”

“It is also awaiting a final decision as to what proportion of Amey’s costs it has to pay. Until these matters are concluded, the council will not be in a position to make a further statement for legal reasons.”

Latest news

February start for £70m Brentford FC stadium

Buckingham Group set to start work on scaled-down Bees ground in West London
28 mins ago

Developer chosen for trio of Woking towers

Mixed-use specialist Coplan aims to start work on town centre transformation in 2021
33 mins ago

Construction outlook brightens despite output gloom

HS2 awards see record spike in orders figures during the third quarter
3 days ago

Contractors to benefit from prequal red tape cut

Revamp of PAS 91 will help buyers know more about suppliers
3 days ago

Boost your online presence with the new Enquirer Directory

New site for suppliers and buyers will showcase their products, services and latest stories
1 month ago

Berkeley to build modular homes factory

Construction set to start on new plant in Kent as profits continue to soar
3 days ago

Wales switches to project bank accounts

Education and Skills Funding Agency last central agency left to adopt PBAs
4 days ago

Forrest to make apprentices redundant

Shift to using subcontractors puts M&E apprentices at risk
3 days ago

Wolverhampton Uni to rebid £20m construction college

Wates was preferred bidder for the Springfield Brewery built environment college
3 days ago

Liverpool council to set up firm to build 10,000 homes

Foundations housing company will build on council land and refurb vacant stock
3 days ago

Plans for £75m student digs in Oxford

Developer Unite Students buys site for 885-bed scheme
3 days ago

Western Thermal buys Newcastle pipework specialist

Acoustic and insulation specialist doubles workforce to 250 with Henderson Site Services deal
4 days ago

BAM starts two Glasgow primary schools worth £18m

List of Scottish school wins grows with Blairdardie and Carntyne projects
4 days ago

Betting Spy: Bookies pay out on Man City title win

Punters get paid out early while the Manchester derby promises plenty of goals
4 days ago

R G Carter to rescue stalled tower in Ipswich

£20m funding deal agreed for waterfront scheme abandoned in the 2008 crash
4 days ago

Koreans rescue £15bn Moorside nuclear power station plan

West Cumbria project gets back on track but could be delayed by four years
4 days ago

T Clarke North West boss leaves after three months

Contracting head Steve Wallwork parts company with building services specialist
4 days ago

Gleeson housing completions set to jump by 20%

Northern house builder gears up to raise it active sites to 70
4 days ago

Tender race set to begin for £35m Wimbledon site

Clarion Housing Group has ambitious plans to transform Merton
5 days ago

BBC studio firm fined after electrician falls ten metres

Court hears how lack of edge protection left worker with a blood clot to the brain
4 days ago

Morgan Sindall BeMo tie-up wins £20m Tube train depot

Deal signed for 160m long train maintenance facility in West London
5 days ago

Bechtel bags £180m Gatwick Pier 6 expansion

Airport settles on construction management model to deliver complex Pier 6 expansion
5 days ago

Government unveils £600bn of construction work

Update to National Infrastructure and Construction Pipeline and another efficiency drive
5 days ago

Winvic tops contracts league for first time

Move into build-to-rent pays off for country's leading shed builder
5 days ago

Hammerson to buy Intu creating £21bn retail developer

Takeover casts doubt over McAlpine's revamp of Nottingham Broadmarsh centre
5 days ago

Croydon picks seven winners for £300m resi framework

Work to start on at least 30 smaller sites over coming months
5 days ago

BAM gets nod to start £100m Boston Barrier

January start on major tidal barrier project in Lincolnshire
5 days ago

Bouygues regional director joins Stepnell

John Rawlinson joins Stepnell to lead expansion plans in the West Midlands
5 days ago

Aberla lands £6m M&E package at Salford resi towers

Specialist to start this month on latest win from Domis Construction
5 days ago

1 in 5 worker Brexodus threatens 300,000 homes target

House builders nearly twice as reliant on overseas workers than general construction
6 days ago

Contractor services