Amey wins £5m payout in Cumbria roads court battle

Aaron Morby 7 months ago
Share

The High Court has ordered Cumbria County Council to pay Amey over £5m at the end of a long-running legal battle over a seven-year roads maintenance contract.

Amey
Amey emerges as the victor in long-running legal battle over seven-year road maintenance work

The contract for the provision of highways maintenance ended in 2013 with Amey claiming over £30m in unpaid fees and the council counterclaiming £20m for payments for what it said was substandard work.

The services had previously been provided by Cumbria’s direct labour organisation. Over the duration of the contract around 36,000 individual works instructions were issued by Cumbria, worth around £250m.

This included the laying of around 2,200 surfacing beds, with a combined area of around 4.2 million m² worth £41m, and the issuing of around 1,700 separate patching instructions, with a combined area of around 745,000 m².

After starting out well, the relationship between Amey and Cumbria from around 2009 onwards had steadily deteriorated.

By the time the contract expired several claims and counterclaims had already been intimated, with Cumbria making substantial deductions from Amey’s final monthly payment applications, and with both parties actively preparing to pursue claims against the other.

After attempts to settle the dispute through a week of mediation the two went to court in what proved to be a protracted legal battle.

In the end the mix of claim and counterclaim ended with the judge awarding Amey a balance of almost £3.7m and interest of £1.7m, representing contractual interest on the sum at 8% over base from June 2012.

Both sides are now arguing over legal costs which Amey claims cost it around £8.8m and the council says cost it a little over £10m.

An Amey spokesman said: “Amey worked with Cumbria County Council for almost a decade and we are proud to have served the county for this time, delivering high quality highways services.

“In 2013, when the contract concluded, there were a few items to be closed out. These are now concluded and we welcome the decision of the court.”

A spokeswoman for the council said: “The council is now considering the judgment with its lawyers to assess whether it is appropriate to make an appeal.”

“It is also awaiting a final decision as to what proportion of Amey’s costs it has to pay. Until these matters are concluded, the council will not be in a position to make a further statement for legal reasons.”

Latest news

South African construction giant buys into Byrne Group

Johannesburg-listed construction giant Wilson Bayly Holmes-Ovcon eyes UK opportunity
8 mins ago

Crewe crane collapse victim was teenager on first job

Police identify both victims after crane came down while being erected
2 days ago

Rotherham unveils new town centre revamp plan

Ambitious regeneration plan focused on Forge Island area of the town
2 hours ago

Premier Modular bags £225m offsite housing deal

Central Housing Investment Consortium picks Premier for volumetric housing
3 hours ago

Singapore developer gets green light for £130m London flats

Final stage of Wandsworth's Riverside Quarter to start next year
3 hours ago

Every tower block checked so far fails fire tests

Cladding on 60 high-rise blocks in 25 local authorities fails combustibility tests
1 day ago

Willmott Dixon wins Old Admirality Building refurb

Contractor takes-on job originally earmarked for BAM
7 hours ago

Michelmersh buys Yorkshire brick maker for £31m

Deal for Carlton Main Brickworks will boost output to 100m units a year
7 hours ago

Celotex to stop supply of Grenfell insulation to towers

Insulation giant halts supply for rainscreen cladding systems to high-rise buildings
3 days ago

Crane drops 500 scaffold fittings on worker

Court hears how victim suffered three fractures and cuts to her head
7 hours ago

Council chief sounds warning over Battersea build costs

Wandsworth planning chairman claims project is facing "significant challenges"
3 days ago

Sisk seals £190m Quintain Wembley Park resi block

Builder also in talks about a further 500 homes next to Canada Court plot
6 hours ago

Police consider manslaughter charges after Grenfell fire

Detectives "seizing relevant material from a number of organisations"
3 days ago

Over 200 Birmingham tower blocks to get sprinklers

Council could delay its building projects to fund £31m retrofit programme
3 days ago

First tests reveal combustible cladding on 11 towers

Up to 600 towers need to be checked
4 days ago

Safety alarm raised over fall in HSE construction visits

Surprise site visits by inspectors drop by 14%
3 days ago

Plans for 35-storey Manchester student tower

Unite unveils plan for 600-bed student block near Oxford Road station
3 days ago

London’s Camden Council to strip cladding from five towers

Chalcots Estate project was delivered by Grenfell contractors Rydon and Harley Facades
4 days ago

Contractors urged to stop asking site chefs for skills cards

Firms urged to use common sense over allowing non-construction staff on sites
3 days ago

Planning thumbs up for £150m Lincoln shopping centre

St Marks shopping centre owner Standard Life plans to start work in 2020
3 days ago

Two killed in crane collapse on Crewe construction site

Tower crane comes down on Seddon site
5 days ago

Berkeley cleared to fast-track scheme for Grenfell survivors

Homes and Communities Agency strike deal to buy Kensington Row luxury apartment scheme
5 days ago

Buckingham Group targets £500m revenue in 2018

Profits soar as firm eyes swelling pipeline of stadium projects.
5 days ago

Five more Edinburgh schools found with building defects

Investigation reveals more schools in Edinburgh suffered wall-tie defects
4 days ago

Galliford/Lagan jv wins £135m RAF Marham hangar

New hangar will house a dozen F-35B vertical take-off jets
5 days ago

CIOB sets up commission to probe control of build quality

Paul Nash to lead urgent review into behaviour that undermines quality in construction
5 days ago

Barratt names new finance boss

Barratt promotes Jessica White to top financial executive
4 days ago

Opinion: Construction must say never again to another Grenfell

The industry must break with its lowest cost culture
5 days ago

Profits soar at Berkeley despite housing market uncertainty

Berkeley worried about Brexit impact on skills as half its site labour comes from EU
5 days ago

Hewden sell-off raises £120m but trade creditors get pennies

More than £41m was owed to plant hire giant's trade creditors
5 days ago

Contractor services