Murphy loses legal battle over delayed Beckton power plant

Aaron Morby 9 years ago
Share

J Murphy & Sons has lost its fight in the High Court to stop the client of its East London power plant project calling an on-demand bond in respect of a claim for liquidated damages of £8.27m.

Client and contractor are at loggerheads about cost overuns
Client and contractor are at loggerheads about cost overuns

The ruling ahead of attempts to settle claims is the latest blow for the contractor on its fat-fired combined heat and power project in Beckton.

The project, which is now in protracted commissioning and testing, is running nearly 15 months late,  with a handover date still to be agreed by Murphy and client Beckton Energy.

Murphy first revealed the cost of problems on the power plant scheme five months ago when it blamed much of an £16m operating loss in 2014 on the extra cost of building the combined heat and power plant.

The contractor said difficulties with design, cost escalation, supply chain and engine related technical breakdowns all had major impacts on the project.

At the time Murphy said it was reviewing its entitlement for recovery of sums, but had stuck to its policy of booking losses as they emerged.

The £70m engineer, procure and construct contract was awarded following a competitive tender three years ago and was due to be handed over in January 2015.

In the High Court, Murphy had asked the judge to rule whether client Beckton Energy could make a demand on the bond in respect of its claim for liquidated damages before the project engineer had made a determination on the amount of LDs due.

During the case its emerged that Murphy disputes Beckton’s entitlement to any liquidated damages, and claims to have suffered significant delays on the project and requested extensions of time, in particular in August 2014, February 2015, September 2015, November 2015 and December 2015.

Beckton Energy claims that extensions were not granted by the engineer because Murphy had not demonstrated that any event or circumstances gave rise to a claim for extension of time or payment.

The judge ruled the details of the main dispute were not pertinent to contract terms at issue and in a set-back for Murphy ruled that Beckton Energy was entitled to call  the on demand bond under the contract.

Latest news

Breyer Group files administration notice

Staff hope rival firm could buy assets and save jobs
3 hours ago

Peel Ports reveals winners for £750m framework

18 firms win places on deal: Full list
1 hour ago

Wates wins fit-out for Manchester First Street Hub

Smartspace arm secures another Government hub deal
54 minutes ago

Former Severfield director takes helm at Embrace Steel

New CEO Martin Kelly aims to step up expansion of steelwork contractor
4 hours ago

£302m upgrade funding awarded to FE colleges – list

Cash shared out between England’s 179 college groups
3 hours ago

FK Facades thrives but construction arm hit by ISG row

Dispute with failed contractor costs specialist £5.5m
4 hours ago

Galliford Try gets go-ahead for Milton Keynes PRS tower

33-storey tower needs gateway 2 approval before work can start
22 hours ago

Small house builders get £150m funding for green homes

Developers will have to meet-up to ten new criteria to benefit from interest rate discounts
4 hours ago

Lendlease Construction renamed Bovis

US private equity firm completes £35m purchase of UK contracting business and rebrands
1 day ago

Breyer Group battles for survival as rivals circle

Housing maintenance firm fights three winding up petitions in a month
1 day ago

Careys facing £2.4m claim by developer over demolition cartel

Giant Hong Kong developer claims it was overcharged on Lots Road Power Station job
1 day ago

Multiplex profit drops a third as revenue rises to £780m

Spate of new orders sets contractor up for three years of work
1 day ago

Galliford Try and Breheny land latest Sizewell C road deals

More infrastructure deals for new nuclear power station
2 days ago

Worker trapped in collapsed septic tank pit

Contractor and director fined after worker suffers multiple fractures
1 day ago

Homes England buys stalled Broad Marsh site

Demolition to finally be completed as developer hunt begins
2 days ago

Vistry go-ahead for 353 homes at Rochester Riverside

Work to start on next phase of Kent town regeneration at end of this year
2 days ago

M&E firm J S Wright collapsed owing £19m

Trade creditors hit for £11.4m by employee-owned Midlands firm
2 days ago

Right to work checks to be extended to self-employed

Government plans crackdown on illegal working and rogue employers
2 days ago

Midlands developer turns to London with £1bn resi schemes trio

SevenCapital plans 1,000 flats in Kensington, Islington and the Isle of Dogs projects
2 days ago

Deck falls off huge scissor lift at Winvic site

Two men seriously injured as platform plunges to the ground
5 days ago

Weston targets Build to Rent with new division

Weston Partnerships signs first deals with asset managers and councils
2 days ago

Bouygues seals deal for £119m Cardiff college campus

Construction to start in June on two new buildings
5 days ago

£140m cash injection to speed-up flood defence schemes

Funding part of £2.65bn investment over the next two years
2 days ago

Bid race starts for £15bn schools framework refresh

DfE throws framework open to more contractors
5 days ago

Berkeley’s £600m Borough Triangle project approved

Controversial scheme features two towers of 38 and 44-storeys
6 days ago

London Mayor calls in blocked 600-bed student scheme

Refused 20-storey London PBSA block may still be built
5 days ago

HG to build 500-bed London Stratford student scheme

Work will start later this year subject to gateway 2 safety approval
6 days ago

Arrest after pedestrian death on construction site

Tragedy during site preparation works for new Wigan car park
5 days ago

British Steel threatens closure of Scunthorpe blast furnaces

Chinese owners say sectional steel and rail supplies will be maintained
6 days ago

Planning green light for Sheffield warehouse site

Existing factories to be demolished in new scheme for Rula Developments
5 days ago

Contractor services