Centre Point Tower developer claws back £1m from McAlpine

Aaron Morby 10 months ago
Share

The developer behind London’s Centre Point tower conversion into luxury apartments has clawed back a £1m payment to Sir Robert McAlpine in the High Court.

Developer Almacantar and McAlpine became pitched against each other following a bust-up over delivering the project as a design and build job.

McAlpine was working on the £100m-plus project under a pre-construction service agreement (PCSA) signed in Spetember 2012. But by June 2014 ahead of moving to the next main contract stage, McAlpine said it would no longer entertain a design and build contract and proposed a construction management or management contract form of procurement.

Almacantar rejected the offer and the contract was terminated in September. Three months later Almacantar appointed Multiplex as the main contractor for the job.

The two then became embroiled in a dispute about whether the contract terms allowed a final part of McAlpine’s fee to be released under the PCSA agreement.

McAlpine contended that the previous two-stage contract terms allowed it to be paid a remaining 50% tranche of fee when any main contractor was appointed.

Almacantar argued that the terms of releasing the second part of the fee only applied once a main contract was agreed with McAlpine, not any other contractor.

Initially an adjudicator ruled in McAlpine’s favour, but the High Court has now backed Almacantar, ordering McApine to repay the £1.1m including interest awarded in the adjudication.

Justice Jefford said: “This is not a contract under which, if Almacantar exercised its right to terminate, it would, with impunity, avoid paying the second 50% of the fee.

“The purpose of the PCSA was to put Almacantar in a position to proceed with a well-planned design and build contract with developed contractor’s proposals and a robust contract sum.

“In most circumstances in which Almacantar terminated SRM’s engagement, Almacantar would to a greater or lesser extent lose those benefits and have to go back to the drawing board with another contractor.

“That would be the position if the parties could not reach agreement, if Almacantar was dissatisfied with SRM or if, as happened, SRM did not wish to proceed.”

Justice Jefford added: “The only circumstance in which Almacantar would have a windfall  – but a fairly valueless one – and SRM would be unfairly out of pocket would be if Almacantar decided not to proceed with the project at all.

“If on the other hand SRM’s construction of the PCSA were right, they would receive the second 50% of the fee even if its services had been of no benefit to Almacantar in engaging with another contractor.”

 

 

Latest news

Balfour Beatty delivers 2-3% construction margin goal

Leo Quinn hits phase two target of Build to Last turnaround plan
2 days ago

Firms admit price-fixing of concrete drainage products

Precast firms took part in cartel for seven years
2 days ago

£300m Edgbaston mixed-use scheme advances

Phase one office project edges closer at New Garden Square regen scheme
2 days ago

All JCB staff get £1000 Christmas bonus

Over 7,000 staff earn biggest Christmas bonus in a decade
2 days ago

Robertson appoints Morgan Sindall director

Scott Wilson is now Robertson's business development director
3 days ago

Beeston leisure centre out to bid

Bidding starts on cinema project in £30m shops and 130 homes scheme
3 days ago

Scape MD to head Perfect Circle consortium

Victoria Bambini to lead AECOM, Pick Everard and Gleeds joint venture
3 days ago

EastEnders set rebuild soars £27m over budget

NAO slams BBC for planning failures and procurement delays
3 days ago

Spurs stadium delays continue into New Year

Man Utd match will be played at Wembley next month as contractors work through Christmas
3 days ago

Speedy buys construction training business for £9m

Plant hirer buys Glasgow-based Geason in construction training push
3 days ago

Summer start for £25m Carlisle flood defence plan

Flood defence plan to be revealed three years after storm Desmond hit
3 days ago

Amco wins Dunbar railway station upgrade

Work to start next summer on new platform and footbridge
3 days ago

Architects win post-Brexit talent deal

Designers win concessions but construction still in skills turmoil
4 days ago

Boost your online presence – join the Enquirer Directory

New site for suppliers and buyers showcases products, services and latest stories
8 months ago

Essex contractor collapses after posting record results

Bolt and Heeks Ltd in administratron with 55 job losses
4 days ago

Science park starts contractor hunt for £12m office scheme

Construction work up for grabs on trio of buildings near Liverpool
4 days ago

Hitachi to pull out of £14bn Anglesey nuclear power plant

Hitachi plans for Anglesey nuclear power plant now in doubt
4 days ago

M&E specialist Ameon replaces Imtech on Graham site

Subcontractor steps in to keep project on track
4 days ago

Marshalls to buy rival concrete brick maker

Marshalls to buy Edenhall for up to £17m
4 days ago

Argent gets go-ahead for major Tottenham Hale revamp

Contractor hunt to start soon with construction set to start next summer
5 days ago

Drylining boss banned for tax dodging

Insolvency Service investigators uncover huge CIS and VAT payment discrepancies
5 days ago

£2bn Elephant & Castle shopping centre scheme final go-ahead

Demolition to start after London mayor nods through vast scheme
5 days ago

Modular building specialist goes into administration

Timber accommodation pod maker Carbon Dynamic runs out of cash on major contract
5 days ago

Structural engineer crushed under scaffold tubes

Housing giant and scaffold contractor fined a total of £180,000
5 days ago

Consultant MHBC merges with Cumming

City of London based firm now part of global giant
5 days ago

Crossrail delayed again as costs rise by another £2bn

Mayor attacks previous management team who insisted project was "on time and on budget"
5 days ago

Top housing association hires Lendlease resi chief

Richard Cook will lead Clarion Group's ambitious development plans
5 days ago

UK’s tallest Premier Inn plan in Docklands

Premier Inn books in at 30-storey mixed resi and hotel scheme
5 days ago

Kier wins £45m Cambridge schools campus phase one

Northstowe education campus includes a new 1,800 pupil secondary
5 days ago

Ian Lawson to advise McLaren on growth plans

Former Severfield and Kier boss becomes consultant at expanding contractor
6 days ago

Contractor services