Centre Point Tower developer claws back £1m from McAlpine

Aaron Morby 4 months ago
Share

The developer behind London’s Centre Point tower conversion into luxury apartments has clawed back a £1m payment to Sir Robert McAlpine in the High Court.

Developer Almacantar and McAlpine became pitched against each other following a bust-up over delivering the project as a design and build job.

McAlpine was working on the £100m-plus project under a pre-construction service agreement (PCSA) signed in Spetember 2012. But by June 2014 ahead of moving to the next main contract stage, McAlpine said it would no longer entertain a design and build contract and proposed a construction management or management contract form of procurement.

Almacantar rejected the offer and the contract was terminated in September. Three months later Almacantar appointed Multiplex as the main contractor for the job.

The two then became embroiled in a dispute about whether the contract terms allowed a final part of McAlpine’s fee to be released under the PCSA agreement.

McAlpine contended that the previous two-stage contract terms allowed it to be paid a remaining 50% tranche of fee when any main contractor was appointed.

Almacantar argued that the terms of releasing the second part of the fee only applied once a main contract was agreed with McAlpine, not any other contractor.

Initially an adjudicator ruled in McAlpine’s favour, but the High Court has now backed Almacantar, ordering McApine to repay the £1.1m including interest awarded in the adjudication.

Justice Jefford said: “This is not a contract under which, if Almacantar exercised its right to terminate, it would, with impunity, avoid paying the second 50% of the fee.

“The purpose of the PCSA was to put Almacantar in a position to proceed with a well-planned design and build contract with developed contractor’s proposals and a robust contract sum.

“In most circumstances in which Almacantar terminated SRM’s engagement, Almacantar would to a greater or lesser extent lose those benefits and have to go back to the drawing board with another contractor.

“That would be the position if the parties could not reach agreement, if Almacantar was dissatisfied with SRM or if, as happened, SRM did not wish to proceed.”

Justice Jefford added: “The only circumstance in which Almacantar would have a windfall  – but a fairly valueless one – and SRM would be unfairly out of pocket would be if Almacantar decided not to proceed with the project at all.

“If on the other hand SRM’s construction of the PCSA were right, they would receive the second 50% of the fee even if its services had been of no benefit to Almacantar in engaging with another contractor.”

 

 

Latest news

Multiplex bags £400m New Scotland Yard redevelopment

Multiplex will to start six-tower Westminster Broadway scheme in January
4 hours ago

Balfour Beatty fined £500,000 for white finger exposure

Court hears how workers were exposed to hand-arm vibration for nine years
7 hours ago

McLaren lands new HQ for consultant Dar Group

John F Hunt to start demolition work in August to make way for new nine-storey scheme
12 hours ago

On-site training boost to ease skills shortages

New £22m Construction Skills Fund now open for applications
9 hours ago

Chandler promoted to Wates board

Wates MD, Paul Chandler, ushers in nearly £3bn of new business
10 hours ago

Legal firm moves into cost consultancy

Blake Morgan hires former Aecom director to head project management and cost consultancy
10 hours ago

Fire destroys Kier restoration of Glasgow School of Art

Second major blaze in four years reduces £35m of repair work to ashes
2 days ago

Race starts to build £20m Basildon cinema complex

Basildon town centre’s planned East Square cinema complex up for grabs
15 hours ago

One in four MPs now back retention reform

Aldous Bill second reading delayed to October
15 hours ago

Late payment delays hit 42 days for subcontractors

Firms waiting longer for money despite raft of initiatives to speed up payment
15 hours ago

Mace wins £90m Tunbridge Wells civic centre complex

Mace to agree final design and build price in April 2019 on theatre and civic offices
1 day ago

Caledonian wins £27m haul of MoD orders

Modular specialist ramps up production for MoD Lyneham and Worthy Down projects
15 hours ago

Forrest bags fifth X1 scheme at Chatham Docks

£58m Chatham Waters build to rent blocks get underway
16 hours ago

Mace slims down construction divisions

Former Carillion operations boss to head Mace major projects arm
4 days ago

Subcontractors write-off £2.8bn in bad debts every year

Average firm hit by £16,000 annually in unpaid bills
4 days ago

Pochin’s hires ex-Balfour boss to head construction arm

Jon Adams appointed managing director of Pochin Construction
4 days ago

Wates scoops £150m Birmingham office scheme

Work to start on phase one of Axis Square city centre scheme in February
4 days ago

Faulty tower scaffold led to fatal roof fall

Court hears how a catalogue of mistakes led to death plunge
4 days ago

UCL East starts race for £90m student blocks

Bidding starts for Queen Elizabeth Olympic Park student accommodation
4 days ago

Firefighters and sprinklers contain tower block blaze

Fire breaks out in London 20-storey block of flats on Grenfell anniversary
5 days ago

Heating engineer wins landmark workers rights battle

Pimlico Plumbers boss warns industry faces "tsunami" of self-employed claims
5 days ago

Network Rail ordered to spend an extra £1bn on renewals

Rail watchdog wants more spent replacing worn out rails and smoother spend over CP6
5 days ago

Site cleaners and chefs will no longer need skills cards

CSCS to phase out visitor cards for non construction staff
5 days ago

Costain moving to bigger construction technology centre

Contractor continues to ramp up investment in tech innovations
5 days ago

Green light for £150m Crawley mixed-use regeneration

Tenders due back this month for Crawley town centre rebuild
5 days ago

Wates on the hunt for South West subcontractors

Meet the Buyer event next month: Register now
5 days ago

Problem job sees Multiplex profit slump to £4.4m

Order book rises to £4.2bn on back of major tower projects
6 days ago

Boost your online presence – join the new Enquirer Directory

New site for suppliers and buyers will showcase their products, services and latest stories
2 months ago

Interserve sees shareholder revolt over chief’s pay

More than 17% of shareholders vote against executive remuneration report
6 days ago

Gatwick ramps up five-year spend to £1.1bn

Total investment since airport changed hands rises to £3.14bn
6 days ago

Contractor services