Carillion fined £130,000 after scaffold death fall

Grant Prior 12 years ago
Share

Carillion has been fined £130,000 with costs of £52,500 after a scaffolder fell to his death while building apartments at Meridian Quay in Swansea.

But the concrete subcontractor the victim was working for dodged a £250,000 fine by going into liquidation after the tragedy.

Carillion and Febrey Ltd were jointly prosecuted by the Health and Safety Executive following the incident on 22 January 2008.

Self-employed father of two, Russell Samuel from Porth was contracted by Febrey  to work as a scaffolder at the Swansea site.

Swansea Crown Court heard he was dismantling a scaffold ladder access platform ready for the installation of the roof and staircase on the fourth floor, when he fell approximately 19 metres to the ground below, narrowly missing carpenter Raymond Haines, who was working directly below.

Samuel, 40, suffered multiple injuries during his fall, including a fractured skull. He was taken to Morriston Hospital but died two days later on 24 January 2008.

The HSE investigation found that Febrey had inadequate and ineffective health and safety management arrangements in place and there was little or no communication, information and instruction provided to its workforce.

The management team on site was not adequately trained in health and safety, despite repeated warnings by its health and safety consultants, and this led to persistent and systematic failures to control work at height risks at site.

The failing of its director was also found to have had a direct bearing on the sequence of events that led to the death of Samuel.

Carillion failed to ensure the safety of its employees and those under its control.

The company, as principal contractor, was made aware of and had detected many failings in the safety management of Febrey but failed to gain improvement from Febrey on many occasions.

Carillion pleaded guilty safety breaches and was fined a total of £130,000 and ordered to pay £52,500 in costs.

Febrey Ltd has gone into liquidation and was fined a total of £85, although the judge said he would have fined them £250,000 before it became insolvent.

Speaking after the hearing, HSE inspector Anne-Marie Orrells said: “There were recurrent indicators that should have alerted Carillion to Febrey’s persistent and systematic failures throughout the whole project.

“Yet Carillion failed to adequately address Febrey’s significant failings.

“As the principal contractor on site, Carillion had a clear duty to plan, manage and monitor the construction work.

“Falls from height are still the biggest killer in the construction industry and this is the tragic reality of what can happen when adequate arrangements are not in place to manage health and safety.

“Mr Samuel’s children and family will have to live with the consequences the defendants’ failings for the rest of their lives.”

Febrey director, Michael Febrey, of Bristol pleaded guilty to a breach of the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974 and will be fined at a later date.

Latest news

Breakthrough for HS2 as first Birmingham tunnel section dug

Balfour Beatty VINCI completes 3.5km TBM drive in 652 days drive
2 days ago

HS2 Curzon Street station redesign approved as timber roof axed

Change to meet stricter fire safety rules and cut maintenance costs
2 days ago

Care home fire trial collapses

Prosecution withdrawn against four firms including Morgan Sindall Property Services
3 days ago

Leicester rebids £22m station revamp after failed tender race

Council opts for ECI route after receiving one bid for project
2 days ago

Kier wins East Coast College rebuild job in Great Yarmouth

Work to start this summer for 1,300-student college
2 days ago

R G Carter wins £28m hospital car park job in King’s Lynn

MSCP paves way for £1.5bn Queen Elizabeth Hospital rebuild in 2027
2 days ago

London to relax green belt building rules

Sadiq Khan shifts position on planning
2 days ago

Willmott Dixon wins Great Yarmouth waterfront deal

North Quay 10.5 acres mixed-use scheme to advance
3 days ago

SIG chief quits to join Travis Perkins

Gavin Slark to leave by the end of this year
2 days ago

Eight take key spots on £250m Prosper framework

Housing and public building upkeep deal for North East awarded
3 days ago

Early call-out for £150m Ebbsfleet Garden City infrastructure

Bidders day to set out plan for Ebbsfleet Central commercial scheme
4 days ago

McLaren storms April contracts league with flurry of wins

Cardiff Bay Arena job headlines a series of big contract wins
3 days ago

Balfour Beatty lifts cash forecast after strong first quarter

Contractor set to hit £1bn average monthly net cash in 2025
3 days ago

Goldman Sachs-owned Adler & Allan buys 180-strong civils outfit

West Country's Glanville Environmental gets new owner
3 days ago

Caddick lands first contract for £200m Skelmersdale revamp

Developer gets green light for masterplan
3 days ago

Van Elle sells HGV fleet to haulage firm

WS Specialist Logistics pays £2.9m to take on fleet and drivers
3 days ago

Buyers more bullish about prospects for year ahead

Residential "resilient" but commercial work a weak spot
4 days ago

Council backs first Brutalist car park-to-flats scheme

Newcastle-under-Lyme multi-storey car park to be reborn as pioneering homes scheme
4 days ago

Hinkley Point C hits peak build with 26,000 jobs

3,000 more workers to join as fit-out work ramps up
4 days ago

Over 40 firms win Wessex Water M&E minor works deal

Broad sweep of specialists picked for AMP8 programme
4 days ago

Spencer lands Scottish bridge hat-trick

Steelwork, gantries and bearing upgrades on Kessock, Forth and Tay crossings
5 days ago

Winners revealed for £1.5bn decarbonisation deal

Fusion21 confirms places for 40 firms: Full list
4 days ago

Cladding firm fined £225,000 after fatal fall

Court hears how cherry picker didn't reach all parts of repair job
4 days ago

Completed buildings caught-up in Gateway 2 chaos

Developer distraught after dealing with Building Safety Regulator
5 days ago

Aviva submits plans for 34-storey City office tower

Subject to planning work to start in autumn 2027
5 days ago

Murphy takes 40% stake in Aussie civils contractor

Firm enters Australasian market with stake in Sydney-based contractor Abergeldie
6 days ago

Moat seeks firm for £420m repairs and maintenance deal

15-year deal to upkeep 20,000 south east homes
5 days ago

Lynch takes over hotel for Sizewell plant operators

Hire giant now in the hotel business to guarantee accommodation for workers
5 days ago

Subcontractors wanted across Scotland

Latest Constructionline event in Glasgow: Register now
5 days ago

Six guilty of £2m bribery over Devon housing site deals

Corrupt building bosses and E.ON project chief and QS sentenced
1 week ago

Contractor services